Automoderated users, edit
2,403
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 29:
Line 29: + + +
Talk:The Chronicles of Narnia (view source)
Revision as of 20:48, December 30, 2008
, 20:48, December 30, 2008Opening discussion on the Religious criticisms
==Our World/Narnia==
==Our World/Narnia==
Not to be rude, but when you switched our world and Narnia, you totally missed that. They are adults in Narnia, and return to our world, not become adults in our world, and go back to Narnia as kids. That totally contradicts the book. Just something I noticed. [[User:Mskreuz|Mskreuz]] 15:08, 7 July 2007 (EDT)
Not to be rude, but when you switched our world and Narnia, you totally missed that. They are adults in Narnia, and return to our world, not become adults in our world, and go back to Narnia as kids. That totally contradicts the book. Just something I noticed. [[User:Mskreuz|Mskreuz]] 15:08, 7 July 2007 (EDT)
==Religious Criticisms==
It is just my opinion, but the religious criticisms are rather long and overly specific. The arguments probably should be summarized quickly or they should be fewer. I also think they rely over-much on an allegorical interpretation of the Chronicles and sometimes in little details. I don't think it's ''completely'' allegorical, although there are allegorical parallels. Sometimes the arguments (such as that last one on celibacy) is incredibly weak. I think it should be altered or moved to a debate page, where the arguments can be examined and discussed. (However, I'm glad the author of these critics was careful about how he placed the arguments and gave it a section.) -[[User:Additioner|Additioner]] 15:48, 30 December 2008 (EST)