178
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 6:
Line 6: + +
Reply
:::So your source that Gibbs is anti-semetic is an article that you wrote that makes the assertion that all liberals are anti-semetic, based on a study done of "Christian Century" (a publication Gibbs has never been involved with as far as I'm aware) that concludes it is anti-semetic. I do not believe this is good enough. If an encyclopaedia article is to make a claim about Gibbs, it needs to provide a reliable source which shows Gibbs doing or say something anti-semetic.--[[User:JohnD|JohnD]] 11:11, 3 March 2009 (EST)
:::So your source that Gibbs is anti-semetic is an article that you wrote that makes the assertion that all liberals are anti-semetic, based on a study done of "Christian Century" (a publication Gibbs has never been involved with as far as I'm aware) that concludes it is anti-semetic. I do not believe this is good enough. If an encyclopaedia article is to make a claim about Gibbs, it needs to provide a reliable source which shows Gibbs doing or say something anti-semetic.--[[User:JohnD|JohnD]] 11:11, 3 March 2009 (EST)
::::No, my source is a well-referenced book written by an Israeli government official that carefully analyzes liberal policy and rhetoric and its results are that American liberalism (including much of American professors who discuss this topic) is anti-Semetic and often blame conservatives for what is in fact a liberal sin. --[[User:RickD|RickD]] 11:14, 3 March 2009 (EST)
::::No, my source is a well-referenced book written by an Israeli government official that carefully analyzes liberal policy and rhetoric and its results are that American liberalism (including much of American professors who discuss this topic) is anti-Semetic and often blame conservatives for what is in fact a liberal sin. --[[User:RickD|RickD]] 11:14, 3 March 2009 (EST)
::::No it isn't. Your source, provided in the article is [[Liberal Christianity#Liberal Christianity's Anti-Semitism]], an article which you wrote. This source then goes on to accuse all liberal Christians of being anti-Semites based on the book your mention above, (which incidently, isn't referenced properly in either article.)
::::Anyway, I don't wish to edit war with you about this so I have done what we did last time and raised the issue with an Sysop. I hope this acceptable.--[[User:JohnD|JohnD]] 11:26, 3 March 2009 (EST)