Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
2,800 bytes added ,  23:52, March 23, 2009
new section on "Testimony" controversy
Line 1: Line 1: −
'''Dmitri Shostakovich''' (1906-1975) was a [[Russia]]n [[composer]] who worked in many different styles and forms.  While he is primarily known for his symphonies and string quartets, he also composed several operas, orchestral suites, concertos, and much piano music. Along with that of [[Sergei Prokofiev]], Shostakovich's music is almost universally considered by critics and listeners to be among the most compelling to come out of the [[Soviet Union]].
+
'''Dmitri Shostakovich''' (1906-1975) was a [[Russia]]n [[composer]] who worked in many different styles and forms.  While he is primarily known for his symphonies and string quartets, he also composed several operas, orchestral suites, concertos, and much piano music. Along with that of [[Sergei Prokofiev]], Shostakovich's music is almost universally considered by critics and listeners to be among the most compelling to come out of the stifling creative atmosphere of the [[Soviet Union]].
   −
Shostakovich's compositional legacy is complicated by the demands of the repressive political environment in which he lived. He was required to occasionally write obsequious and banal works which satisfied the doctrines of Soviet Realism.<ref>Ian MacDonald, ''The New Shostakovich,'' 1988</ref> Additionally, in the USSR, every new work had to be vetted by a committee of members from the [[Communist Party]]'s Composer's Union, which tried to ensure that no ideological rules were being broken.<ref>Laurel Fay, ''Shostakovich: A Life,'' 2000.</ref> For reasons that perhaps will never be understood (and apparently against his will<ref>Eliabeth Wilson, ''Shostakovich: A Life Remembered,'' 1995</ref>), Shostakovich also joined the Communist Party himself in 1960.
+
Shostakovich's compositional legacy is complicated by the demands of the repressive political environment in which he lived. He was required to occasionally write obsequious and banal works which satisfied the doctrines of Socialist Realism.<ref>Ian MacDonald, ''The New Shostakovich,'' 1988</ref> Additionally, in the USSR, every new work had to be vetted by a committee of members from the [[Communist Party]]'s Composer's Union, which tried to ensure that no ideological rules were being broken.<ref>Laurel Fay, ''Shostakovich: A Life,'' 2000.</ref> For reasons that perhaps will never be understood (and apparently against his will<ref>Eliabeth Wilson, ''Shostakovich: A Life Remembered,'' 1995</ref>), Shostakovich also joined the Communist Party himself in 1960.
    
==Wartime years==
 
==Wartime years==
Line 13: Line 13:     
In his later years, Shostakovich's music became increasingly personal, and often involving the theme of death.  Notably, the Fourteenth Symphony (1968) is a series of eleven songs on the theme of death.  In contrast to many classical works dealing with death, the Fourteenth symphony does not seek to offer religious consolation.  The late String Quartets, notably the Thirteenth (Op 138) and the Fifteenth (Op 144) are similarly bleak and death-obsessed.  Shostakovich's final work is a sonata for viola and piano (Op 147) which was completed a few days before his death from lung cancer in 1975.
 
In his later years, Shostakovich's music became increasingly personal, and often involving the theme of death.  Notably, the Fourteenth Symphony (1968) is a series of eleven songs on the theme of death.  In contrast to many classical works dealing with death, the Fourteenth symphony does not seek to offer religious consolation.  The late String Quartets, notably the Thirteenth (Op 138) and the Fifteenth (Op 144) are similarly bleak and death-obsessed.  Shostakovich's final work is a sonata for viola and piano (Op 147) which was completed a few days before his death from lung cancer in 1975.
 +
 +
==The ''Testimony'' controversy - Was Shostakovich a secret dissident?==
 +
 +
Because of his public actions as a member of the Communist Party, which included signing letters of condemnation against any musician who ran afoul of the authorities, as well as his official pronouncements on several of his symphonies' meanings (all conveniently fitting in with a Socialist Realist program), Shostakovich died being celebrated as a loyal son of the Party.
 +
 +
This picture was complicated, to say the least, when in 1979 Russian émigré journalist Solomon Volkov released what he claimed were Shostakovich's official memoirs. ''Testimony,'' which Volkov claimed to be compiled from several personal interviews with the ailing composer in his last months, first put forth the supposition that Shostakovich's music contained hidden messages which the audience could easily interpret. These messages showed signs of dissidence against the Communist regime, and satirized the aims of Socialist Realism.  A well-known example of this is the conclusion of the Fifth Symphony (1937), viewed by the authorities as a triumphant conclusion.  However, in ''Testimony,''Shostakovich was supposed to have said that the end of the Fifth symphony is about enforced rejoicing.
 +
 +
''Testimony'' hit the musicological and political worlds like a meteor. The Soviet government was quick to denounce the alleged memoirs, and began a swift PR campaign to discredit Volkov. ''Shostakovich: About his Life and Times'' was soon released, which musicologist Ian MacDonald has called a "KGB snow job,"<ref>http://www.siue.edu/~aho/musov/fay/fayrev1.html</ref> and which reproduces speeches and official articles published under Shostakovich's name throughout his life. These articles, which friends of the composer claim were written by party officials and had no choice but to sign, reinforced the image of the composer as a loyal Communist.
 +
 +
Then came an article by Laurel Fay in 1980, entitled "Shostakovich versus Volkov - Whose Testimony?" Fay viciously attacked Volkov's credibility further, claiming that he had plagiarized most of it, and that the rest was pure fantasy. Fay's own credibility has been questioned by MacDonald, who also questions her possible political motives,<ref>http://www.siue.edu/~aho/musov/fay/fayrev6.html</ref> as she had been a student in Leningrad in the late 1970's.
 +
 +
Dozens of Shostakovich's friends and confidants who had previously emigrated to the West, such as Mstislav Rostropovich and the composer's own son, Maxim, were quick to defend the statements of ''Testimony'' as being very characteristic of how he talked and believed in private. Their recollections have been recorded in Allan B. Ho and Dmitri Feofanov's ''Shostakovich Reconsidered'' in 1998.
    
==References==
 
==References==
1,266

edits

Navigation menu