461
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 28:
Line 28: + +
→"Christian" Novel
== "Christian" Novel ==
== "Christian" Novel ==
Sorry about the garbled edit summary of my last post (accidental copy-paste): it should read "that description was originally added by a known vandal. if you really feel that the descriptor 'christian' belongs, please discuss on the talk page. i am inclined to think it does not". I have not actually read the entire book, but the few summaries I looked at seemed to indicate this is inaccurate. since it was originally added by a blocked user I believe it to be nonsense. If you disagree, please discuss here.
Sorry about the garbled edit summary of my last post (accidental copy-paste): it should read "that description was originally added by a known vandal. if you really feel that the descriptor 'christian' belongs, please discuss on the talk page. i am inclined to think it does not". I have not actually read the entire book, but the few summaries I looked at seemed to indicate this is inaccurate. since it was originally added by a blocked user I believe it to be nonsense. If you disagree, please discuss here.
:I agree with you, and that is why I removed "Christian" in the first place (which was hardly "vandalism"). I have read the novel 3 or 4 times and have an advanced degree in English, and I can assure you that it is not, and is not regarded as, a Christian novel. One might argue that it has some Christian themes (I would not), and a section on those themes could be added to the article. [[User:ChrisFV|ChrisFV]] 17:38, 24 October 2009 (EDT)