Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
79 bytes removed ,  23:08, November 4, 2009
improved
Line 1: Line 1:  
{{Economics_Lectures}}
 
{{Economics_Lectures}}
   −
This Lecture is shorter because we first take the midterm exam.  Now we are more than halfway through this course.  We have already covered all of the basic concepts and are applying them to various new situations.
+
This Lecture is shorter due to our midterm exam.  Now we are more than halfway through this course.  We have already covered all of the basic concepts and are applying them to various new situations.
    
Today we learn the important concept of a "monopoly".  Readers of the New Testament in Greek will know what a “monopoly” is by its roots: “monos” means one, and “polein” means “to sell.”  A monopoly is only one seller in an industry.  Examples are the United States Postal Service for regular mail, many local power companies for your gas or electricity, your cable television provider and, to some extent, your local public school system.  Monopolies arise for a variety of reasons.   
 
Today we learn the important concept of a "monopoly".  Readers of the New Testament in Greek will know what a “monopoly” is by its roots: “monos” means one, and “polein” means “to sell.”  A monopoly is only one seller in an industry.  Examples are the United States Postal Service for regular mail, many local power companies for your gas or electricity, your cable television provider and, to some extent, your local public school system.  Monopolies arise for a variety of reasons.   
   −
There are "natural" monopolies, where an industry has increasing economies of scale, such that long-run average costs of production decrease, like power companies or railroads.  There are "barriers to entry" that prevent new competition in these entries, because it is so expensive to start a new railroad from scratch (nothing).  There are monopolies created by government regulation (the Post Office) or by laws (copyright law is one cause of the Microsoft monopoly) or perhaps even by illegal behavior (Microsoft was found to have violated laws against anti-competitive behavior).
+
There are "natural" monopolies, where an industry has increasing economies of scale, such that long-run average costs of production decrease, like power companies or railroads.  There are "barriers to entry" that prevent new competition, because it is so expensive to start a new railroad from scratch (nothing).  There are monopolies created by government regulation (the Post Office) or by laws (copyright law is one cause of the Microsoft monopoly) or perhaps even by illegal behavior (Microsoft was found to have violated laws against anti-competitive behavior).
    
Thousands of companies enjoy market power that are, in effect, monopolies.  Microsoft is the most profitable example.  It has over 90% of the market for computer operating systems, which is the software needed to make your computer work.  Microsoft’s operating system is called “Windows”.  There are other operating systems available (such as Linux), but they have small market share and Windows has nearly a complete monopoly.
 
Thousands of companies enjoy market power that are, in effect, monopolies.  Microsoft is the most profitable example.  It has over 90% of the market for computer operating systems, which is the software needed to make your computer work.  Microsoft’s operating system is called “Windows”.  There are other operating systems available (such as Linux), but they have small market share and Windows has nearly a complete monopoly.
Line 13: Line 13:  
IBM was the big monopoly in the computer industry for a long time, particularly for businesses.  The popular saying was that “no one was ever fired for recommending to buy from IBM.”
 
IBM was the big monopoly in the computer industry for a long time, particularly for businesses.  The popular saying was that “no one was ever fired for recommending to buy from IBM.”
   −
Perhaps the most famous monopoly of all was John D. Rockefeller’s “Standard Oil,” which controlled most of the oil industry in America around 1900.
+
Perhaps the most famous monopoly of all time was John D. Rockefeller’s “Standard Oil,” which controlled most of the oil industry in America around 1900.
    
What do all these monopolies have in common?  In their heyday, they made extraordinary profits.  Microsoft still does.
 
What do all these monopolies have in common?  In their heyday, they made extraordinary profits.  Microsoft still does.
Line 19: Line 19:  
These monopolies were able to garner enormous profits for one simple reason: they had no competition.  As a monopoly increases its price, there is no other company to take customers away from it with a lower price.  If Microsoft increases (or fails to reduce) its price on Windows, there is almost nothing the consumer can do about it except pay.  If you want a computer that is compatible with all the other computers out there, then you will likely buy Windows even if overpriced.
 
These monopolies were able to garner enormous profits for one simple reason: they had no competition.  As a monopoly increases its price, there is no other company to take customers away from it with a lower price.  If Microsoft increases (or fails to reduce) its price on Windows, there is almost nothing the consumer can do about it except pay.  If you want a computer that is compatible with all the other computers out there, then you will likely buy Windows even if overpriced.
   −
Is the monopoly able to increase its price without limitation?  No.  The Law of Demand still applies to monopolies:  demand will decrease as the price increases simply because people will buy less as the price increases.  People have limits on what they will spend.  Even a monopoly has to live with the demand curve.  The marginal revenue is not always positive as price increases, even for a monopoly.  At some high price, a further increase in price causes a larger drop in quantity and the marginal revenue goes down.  A monopoly does not increase its price when its marginal revenue is less than zero, or when it is less than its marginal cost.
+
Is the monopoly able to increase its price without limitation?  No.  The Law of Demand still applies to monopolies:  demand will decrease as the price increases simply because people will buy less as the price increases.  People have limits on what they will spend.  Even a monopoly has to live with the demand curve.  The marginal revenue is not always positive as price increases, even for a monopoly.  At some high price, a further increase in price causes a larger drop in quantity and the marginal revenue goes down.  A monopoly does not increase its price when its marginal revenue falls to its marginal cost.
    
== Monopoly ==
 
== Monopoly ==
Line 27: Line 27:  
A monopoly is more profitable than a firm in a competitive market.  A monopoly is like a football team playing a game without an opponent.  The team still has to score touchdowns, but it is so easy to do so.
 
A monopoly is more profitable than a firm in a competitive market.  A monopoly is like a football team playing a game without an opponent.  The team still has to score touchdowns, but it is so easy to do so.
   −
A monopoly increases its profit by increasing prices, which it can do because there is no competition, no substitutes.  A monopoly reduces its output when it increases its price, as fewer people buy the good due the Law of Demand (higher price, less demand).  As a result, a monopoly produces less output than the efficient quantity, or the equilibrium level of output in a competitive market.
+
A monopoly increases its profit by increasing prices, which it can do because there is no competition, no substitutes.  A monopoly reduces its output when it increases its price, as fewer people buy the good due to the Law of Demand (higher price, less demand).  As a result, a monopoly produces less output than the efficient quantity, or the equilibrium level of output in a competitive market.
    
If you have played the board game called "Monopoly", you might have noticed that the rents on property increase enormously when someone has all two or three properties in a "color group."  The player monopolizes property and then obtains much higher rent because it.  The player who monopolizes the most property is usually the one who wins.
 
If you have played the board game called "Monopoly", you might have noticed that the rents on property increase enormously when someone has all two or three properties in a "color group."  The player monopolizes property and then obtains much higher rent because it.  The player who monopolizes the most property is usually the one who wins.
Line 37: Line 37:  
There are several other “barriers to entry” that prevent competition.  They are listed and described below:
 
There are several other “barriers to entry” that prevent competition.  They are listed and described below:
   −
*'''''The licensing of professionals creates a barrier to entry'''''.  To become a doctor, someone must go to an accredited medical school (which usually take four years), and then pass certain exams.  Most doctors also spend several years doing internships and residencies in hospitals.  Attorneys, electricians, barbers, and just about every other line of work have licensing procedures that constitute a “legal barrier to entry” to reduce competition.
+
*'''''The licensing of professionals creates a barrier to entry'''''.  To become a doctor, someone must go to an accredited medical school (which usually takes four years), and then pass certain exams.  Most doctors also spend several years doing internships and residencies in hospitals.  Attorneys, electricians, barbers, and just about every other line of work have licensing procedures that constitute a “legal barrier to entry” to reduce competition.
    
*'''''Control of a valuable resource can also create a monopoly'''''.  If you owned all the oil wells in the world, then you would essentially have a monopoly.  Your would become the wealthiest person in the world.  A company called DeBeers once controlled the vast majority of diamond production, giving it a monopoly.
 
*'''''Control of a valuable resource can also create a monopoly'''''.  If you owned all the oil wells in the world, then you would essentially have a monopoly.  Your would become the wealthiest person in the world.  A company called DeBeers once controlled the vast majority of diamond production, giving it a monopoly.
Line 53: Line 53:  
==Pricing by Monopoly==
 
==Pricing by Monopoly==
   −
Even Bill Gates and the Microsoft monopoly is limited by the demand curve, and the Law of Demand.  Even for a monopoly, the higher its price, the lower its quantity sold.  Overall revenue is price times quantity, so a monopoly does not maximize revenue simply by maximizing its price.  At highest price extreme, for example, a monopoly will not charge a price higher than what the wealthiest people will pay.   
+
Even Bill Gates and the Microsoft monopoly is limited by the demand curve, and the Law of Demand.  Even for a monopoly, the higher its price, the lower its quantity sold.  Overall revenue is price times quantity, so a monopoly does not maximize revenue simply by maximizing its price.  For example, a monopoly will not charge a price higher than what the wealthiest people will pay.   
    
A monopoly maximizes profit by lowering price until marginal revenue (MR) equals marginal cost (MC).  '''''The universal rule of pricing applies to monopolists just like any other firm: they all sell where MR=MC'''''.
 
A monopoly maximizes profit by lowering price until marginal revenue (MR) equals marginal cost (MC).  '''''The universal rule of pricing applies to monopolists just like any other firm: they all sell where MR=MC'''''.
   −
Because a monopoly owns its industry, all of its focus is on the demand curve.  There are no competitors.  Accordingly, there is no supply curve for any competitors either.  '''''There is no market supply curve when there is a monopoly, but there is still a market demand curve for the public'''''.
+
Because a monopoly owns its industry, all of its focus is on the demand curve.  There are no competitors.  Accordingly, there is no supply curve for any competitors either.  '''''There is no market supply curve when there is a monopoly, but there is still a market demand curve by the public for the good'''''.
   −
If a firm can raise the price of its goods or services and still hold on to some of its customers, then it must possess at least some monopoly power.  Professional athletes and actors enjoys a bit of a monopoly on their own fans, but competition does exist for those fans.
+
If a firm can raise the price of its goods or services and still hold on to some of its customers, then it must possess at least some monopoly power.  Professional athletes and actors enjoys a bit of a monopoly on their own fans, but competition also exists for those fans.
    
Three equations to memorize:
 
Three equations to memorize:
   −
*In a ''natural monopoly'', there is marginal cost (MC) decreases as size increases, and thus ATC > MC.  The falling MC causes ATC (average total cost) to fall also, but it is always bigger than MC
+
*In a ''natural monopoly'', marginal cost (MC) decreases as size increases, and thus ATC > MC.  The falling MC causes ATC (average total cost) to fall also, but it is always bigger than MC
    
*A monopoly should shut down in the short run if AVC > P when MR = MC.
 
*A monopoly should shut down in the short run if AVC > P when MR = MC.
Line 75: Line 75:  
If the demand curve is P = 1000-100Q, then when P=0, Q=10.  That curve intersects the x-axis at Q=10.  According to the above rule, the curve for the marginal revenue of a monopoly should intersect the x-axis at Q=5.  Its equation should be P=1000-200Q.  Is it?
 
If the demand curve is P = 1000-100Q, then when P=0, Q=10.  That curve intersects the x-axis at Q=10.  According to the above rule, the curve for the marginal revenue of a monopoly should intersect the x-axis at Q=5.  Its equation should be P=1000-200Q.  Is it?
   −
At Q=5 on the demand curve, P=$500.  The revenue at this point is PxQ=$2500.  If Q moves to 4 units, then P moves to $600 and the revenue decreases to PxQ=$2400.  If Q moves to 6 units, then P moves to $400 and PxQ=$2400 again.  Moving quantity in either direction causes revenue to decline, so revenue is at its maximum.  Marginal revenue, therefore, is no longer greater than zero.  In fact, MR=0 at this point.  (If you changed Q by a tiny fraction less than one unit, then you would see that marginal revenue is actually zero at Q=5).
+
At Q=5 on the demand curve, P=$500.  The revenue at this point is PxQ=$2500.  If Q moves to 4 units, then P moves to $600 and the revenue decreases to PxQ=$2400.  If Q moves to 6 units, then P moves to $400 and PxQ=$2400 again.  Moving quantity in either direction causes revenue to decline, so revenue is at its maximum at P=$500.  MR=0 at this point.  (If you changed Q by a tiny fraction less than one unit, then you would see that marginal revenue is actually zero at Q=5).
    
Revenue is maximized by setting Q to equal one-half the value of Q when P=0.  This is very useful when MC=0.  Because a monopoly sets its price at MR=MC, when MC=0 then MR=0 can be easily determined when the demand curve is a straight line.
 
Revenue is maximized by setting Q to equal one-half the value of Q when P=0.  This is very useful when MC=0.  Because a monopoly sets its price at MR=MC, when MC=0 then MR=0 can be easily determined when the demand curve is a straight line.
   −
==Deadweight Loss==
+
==Honors: Deadweight Loss==
    
Adam Smith, the founder of the “invisible hand” in economics, was an opponent of monopolies created by the government.  He viewed them as very hurtful, and wrote brilliant criticisms of them.  Monopolies produce less, and they charge the public more.  They maximize their profit by increasing the price and reducing the quantity sold.  They are also less efficient and less innovative than a competitive company.
 
Adam Smith, the founder of the “invisible hand” in economics, was an opponent of monopolies created by the government.  He viewed them as very hurtful, and wrote brilliant criticisms of them.  Monopolies produce less, and they charge the public more.  They maximize their profit by increasing the price and reducing the quantity sold.  They are also less efficient and less innovative than a competitive company.
   −
Sometimes monopolies cause even greater harm.  Microsoft, to perpetuate its monopoly, makes its software incompatible with competitors in order to force consumers to buy Microsoft products.  Users cannot copy text from a Microsoft Word document and paste into a competitive product like WordPerfect, for example.  Microsoft would also hire innovate engineers who were developing something new that might be better than Microsoft products, and put these bright people into an office at Microsoft and stop their new work.  It is difficult to measure the enormous harm caused that anti-competitive strategy.
+
Sometimes monopolies cause even greater harm.  Microsoft, to perpetuate its monopoly, makes its software incompatible with competitors in order to force consumers to buy Microsoft products.  Users cannot copy text from a Microsoft Word document and paste into a competitive product like WordPerfect, for example.  Microsoft would fine innovate engineers who were developing something new at another company, which might become something better than Microsoft products, and Microsoft would hire these bright people in order to stop their new work.  The harm caused that anti-competitive strategy is enormous.
   −
We can measure the harm caused by how a monopoly reduces its output.  '''''The reduction in output is always hurtful, because there is a loss in consumer surplus corresponding to the missing output.'''''  The loss in consumer surplus is called the "deadweight loss."  Economists measure the “deadweight loss” imposed by monopolies in terms of the reduced output Q sold by a monopoly compared to the greater output that would occur in a competitive environment.  The deadweight loss the disutility imposed on society by a company.
+
We can measure the harm caused by how a monopoly reduces its output.  '''''The reduction in output is always hurtful, because there is a loss in consumer surplus corresponding to the missing output.'''''  The loss in consumer surplus is called the "deadweight loss."  Economists measure the “deadweight loss” imposed by monopolies in terms of the reduced output Q sold by a monopoly compared to the greater output that would occur in a competitive environment.  The deadweight loss the disutility imposed on society.
    
For a monopoly, the deadweight loss is defined as Price minus marginal cost (P-MC) summed over all of the output not sold by the monopoly that would have been sold in a competitive industry.  In a competitive industry, P and Q are determined by where supply meets demand, and the good would have sold at MC.  In an industry that has been monopolized by one company, the higher price charged by a monopoly summed over the reduced quantity causes the deadweight loss in the amount of the higher price used (P), minus the price that would have been used in a competitive market (MC), summed over the amount of output lost.
 
For a monopoly, the deadweight loss is defined as Price minus marginal cost (P-MC) summed over all of the output not sold by the monopoly that would have been sold in a competitive industry.  In a competitive industry, P and Q are determined by where supply meets demand, and the good would have sold at MC.  In an industry that has been monopolized by one company, the higher price charged by a monopoly summed over the reduced quantity causes the deadweight loss in the amount of the higher price used (P), minus the price that would have been used in a competitive market (MC), summed over the amount of output lost.
Line 99: Line 99:  
Now that we have learned about perfect competition, at one extreme, and the monopoly, at the other extreme, let's contrast the two.  The biggest difference is that consumers obtain goods at cheaper prices when there is competition than when there is a monopoly.  Competitive companies will produce goods at their minimum average total cost in the long run.  Monopolies usually do not.
 
Now that we have learned about perfect competition, at one extreme, and the monopoly, at the other extreme, let's contrast the two.  The biggest difference is that consumers obtain goods at cheaper prices when there is competition than when there is a monopoly.  Competitive companies will produce goods at their minimum average total cost in the long run.  Monopolies usually do not.
   −
Quality may also be better in a competitive industry.  Microsoft Windows is not only expensive, but many think it is not as good as a competitive operating system would be.  For example, it takes a long time to "boot up" and sometimes "hangs", requiring users to turn off their computers (and lose their work-in-progress) in order to reboot.  Those annoyances are not efficient, and reflect poor quality.
+
Quality may also be better in a competitive industry.  Microsoft Windows is not only expensive, but many think it is not as good as a competitive operating system would be.  For example, it takes a long time to "boot up" and it sometimes "hangs", requiring users to turn off their computers (and lose their work-in-progress) in order to reboot.  These annoyances are not efficient, and reflect poor quality.
    
Another difference between a monopoly and perfect competition is that an increase in demand does not necessarily cause a monopoly to supply more.  In contrast, in a competitive industry, an increase in demand always forces an increase in supply (greater Q).
 
Another difference between a monopoly and perfect competition is that an increase in demand does not necessarily cause a monopoly to supply more.  In contrast, in a competitive industry, an increase in demand always forces an increase in supply (greater Q).
   −
As an owner of a small business, you want perfect competition in the markets from which you buy your inputs, including your supply materials and your labor.  That way you could keep your costs down.  But you would want a monopoly for your own company in the market in which you sell your good or service.  That way you could charge more and make higher profits.
+
As an owner of a small business, you want perfect competition in the markets from which you buy your inputs, including your supply materials and your labor.  That way you can keep your costs down.  But you would want a monopoly for your own company in the market in which you sell your good or service.  That way you could charge more and make higher profits.
    
In reality, there is almost never perfect competition, and complete monopolies are also rare.  The business world is typically somewhere between perfect competition and a monopoly, depending on the market.  Some markets are more competitive than others.  Some companies enjoy more of a monopoly than others.
 
In reality, there is almost never perfect competition, and complete monopolies are also rare.  The business world is typically somewhere between perfect competition and a monopoly, depending on the market.  Some markets are more competitive than others.  Some companies enjoy more of a monopoly than others.
Line 178: Line 178:  
==Cartel==
 
==Cartel==
   −
A cartel is an ''illegal'' oligopoly whereby the firms agree with each other to "fix" or increase prices.  '''''In a cartel, the companies have an actual agreement among each other to raise prices, reduce supply, or otherwise reduce competition.  This is illegal in the United States.'''''  But foreign companies, like the oil producing nations of Algeria, Indonesia, Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, Libya, Nigeria, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates and Venezuela, formed a big cartel known as “Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries,” or “OPEC”.
+
A cartel is an ''illegal'' oligopoly whereby the firms agree with each other to "fix" or increase prices.  '''''In a cartel, the companies have an actual agreement with each other to raise prices, reduce supply, and otherwise reduce competition.  This is illegal in the United States.'''''  But foreign companies, like the oil producing nations of Algeria, Indonesia, Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, Libya, Nigeria, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates and Venezuela, formed a big cartel known as “Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries,” or “OPEC”.
   −
On the CLEP exam you only need to know this:  a cartel causes higher prices and less quantity than competition.  A cartel is nearly as bad for the public as a monopoly, except in a cartel some of the companies may "cheat" and sell more output at a lower price than the fixed, agreed-upon price.
+
On the CLEP exam you need only know this:  a cartel causes higher prices and less quantity than competition.  A cartel is nearly as bad for the public as a monopoly, except in a cartel some of the companies may "cheat" and sell more output at a lower price than the fixed, agreed-upon price.
    
In a cartel, there are (1) relatively few companies, (2) high barriers to entry, and (3) a higher price and lower output determined by agreement so that all companies act alike (except for some cheating that may occur by some of the companies).   
 
In a cartel, there are (1) relatively few companies, (2) high barriers to entry, and (3) a higher price and lower output determined by agreement so that all companies act alike (except for some cheating that may occur by some of the companies).   
Line 206: Line 206:  
2.  Order the types of industries from those having the lowest price (due to the greatest competition) to those having the highest price (due to the least competition).   
 
2.  Order the types of industries from those having the lowest price (due to the greatest competition) to those having the highest price (due to the least competition).   
   −
3.  Explain which type of industries these quotes are probably referring to: (1) "She's the finest hair stylist in town; no one has her special style!", (2) "Crazy Eddie ... his low prices are INSANE!", (3) "Don't like his prices?  He's the only one in town selling what you need."  
+
3.  Explain which specific type of industry (e.g., oligopoly or something else) each of these quotes probably refers to: (1) "She's the finest hair stylist in town; no one has her special style!", (2) "Crazy Eddie ... his low prices are INSANE!", (3) "Don't like his prices?  He's the only one in town selling what you need."  
    
4. List how monopolies can be established.
 
4. List how monopolies can be established.
   −
5. What prevents a monopoly from always increasing its prices?
+
5. What prevents a monopoly from increasing its prices without limitation?
    
== Honors ==
 
== Honors ==
   −
6.  Where is the Nash equilibrium in this set of options, where (x,y) represents the profits to (Firm A, Firm B)?  Explain.
+
6.  Where is the Nash equilibrium for this set of options, where (x,y) represents the profits to (Firm A, Firm B)?  Explain.
 
<br><br><div style=float:left; padding: 20px">
 
<br><br><div style=float:left; padding: 20px">
 
{|style="border-collapse:collapse"
 
{|style="border-collapse:collapse"
Line 239: Line 239:  
7. Monopolies: should the government regulate them?  Or is regulation worse?
 
7. Monopolies: should the government regulate them?  Or is regulation worse?
   −
8. Identify something that a firm in monopolistic competition is unable to do.
+
8. Does the "deadweight loss" equal the "consumer surplus"?  Explain the relationship.
    
9. How does a monopolist maximize his profits?
 
9. How does a monopolist maximize his profits?
Anthony, Irenaeus, Siteadmin, apieditor, Bureaucrats, Check users, nsAm_Govt_101RO, nsAm_Govt_101RW, nsAm_Govt_101_ta, nsJudgesRO, nsJudgesRW, nsJudges_talkRO, nsJudges_talkRW, nsTeam2RO, nsTeam2RW, nsTeam2_talkRO, nsTeam2_talkRW, oversight, Administrators
126,747

edits

Navigation menu