| Line 96: |
Line 96: |
| | | | |
| | ==Assessment== | | ==Assessment== |
| − | Bragg was known to his contemporaries as a strict disciplinarian, but also as an irritable person, with Grant recalling a pre-Civil War anecdote where Bragg, after quarreling "with every officer in the army", even managed to get into a quarrel with himself. Worse, Bragg was quite outspoken about his negative opinion of others, making him unpopular with his subordinates and contributing to a breakdown of personal relations. His record as a general was decidedly mixed; he routinely failed to exploit the victories he won, tended to retreat after a draw, and at Chattanooga he suffered a major defeat. On the other hand, his strategic plans mostly were adequate or even inspired, but the execution was often handicapped by Bragg's subordinates, and unlike [[Robert E. Lee]], Bragg would not be allowed a free hand at choosing them. | + | Bragg was known to his contemporaries as a strict disciplinarian, but also as an irritable person, with Grant recalling a pre-Civil War anecdote where Bragg, after quarreling "with every officer in the army", even managed to get into a quarrel with himself. Worse, Bragg was quite outspoken about his negative opinion of others, making him unpopular with his subordinates and contributing to a breakdown of personal relations. |
| | + | |
| | + | His record as a general was decidedly mixed; he was unable to get along with other senior officers or delegate authority; he spent far too much time on drill, details, and minutia. Worse, he routinely failed to exploit the victories he won, and tended to retreat after a draw. At Chattanooga he suffered a major defeat. On the other hand, his strategic plans mostly were adequate or even inspired, but the execution was often handicapped by Bragg's subordinates, and unlike [[Robert E. Lee]], Bragg would not be allowed a free hand at choosing them. |
| | | | |
| | President [[Jefferson Davis]] retained such generals as Bragg and [[P. G. T. Beauregard]] long after they demonstrated incompetence in leading the Army of Tennessee, an error in judgment costly to the Confederacy. | | President [[Jefferson Davis]] retained such generals as Bragg and [[P. G. T. Beauregard]] long after they demonstrated incompetence in leading the Army of Tennessee, an error in judgment costly to the Confederacy. |
| | ==Further reading== | | ==Further reading== |
| | * McWhiney, Grady. ''Braxton Bragg and Confederate Defeat'' (2 vol 1991) 440 pp., 298pp. Standard scholarly history; by a conservative historian | | * McWhiney, Grady. ''Braxton Bragg and Confederate Defeat'' (2 vol 1991) 440 pp., 298pp. Standard scholarly history; by a conservative historian |
| − |
| |
| − | ==References==
| |
| | *Woodworth, Steven E., ''Six Armies in Tennessee: The Chickamauga and Chattanooga Campaigns'', University of Nebraska Press, 1998. Takes a rather positive view of Bragg's performance. | | *Woodworth, Steven E., ''Six Armies in Tennessee: The Chickamauga and Chattanooga Campaigns'', University of Nebraska Press, 1998. Takes a rather positive view of Bragg's performance. |
| | [[Category:American Civil War Commanders]] | | [[Category:American Civil War Commanders]] |