| Line 8: |
Line 8: |
| | The [[Conservative Bible Project]] may be the first to adopt the "best of the public" approach for a scholarly project. Other examples of approaches using the "best of the public" include: | | The [[Conservative Bible Project]] may be the first to adopt the "best of the public" approach for a scholarly project. Other examples of approaches using the "best of the public" include: |
| | | | |
| − | *Sports competitions,<ref>See below for specific examples of unexpected, extraordinary performances.</ref> such as the [[Olympic Games]],<ref>Since 1990 there has been a qualifying requirement of reasonable success at a prior event.</ref> the [[Chicago Marathon]], and the [[Tour de France]].<ref>In the 1920s it was open to all; now there is a qualifying process for teams.</ref> Anyone can enter, and winning is based solely on skill.
| |
| − | *[[American Idol]]
| |
| − | *Internet blogs. Anyone can start a blog, and readers read the best blog posts. Such blogs have been responsible for breaking crucial news stories well before the "experts" of the traditional media--for example, the [[Monica Lewinsky]] story and [[Rathergate]].
| |
| | | | |
| − | Intellectual examples of the "best of the public" include: | + | ===Intellectual examples=== |
| | | | |
| | *the [[Bible]] | | *the [[Bible]] |
| Line 27: |
Line 24: |
| | *The [[Constitution of the United States of America]]. The [[Founding Fathers]], in their wisdom, chose to eschew the idea of "expert" hereditary nobility, but were also wary of the mob rule that could result with pure democracy; thus, they chose a democratic republic instead. | | *The [[Constitution of the United States of America]]. The [[Founding Fathers]], in their wisdom, chose to eschew the idea of "expert" hereditary nobility, but were also wary of the mob rule that could result with pure democracy; thus, they chose a democratic republic instead. |
| | *'''''Conservapedia''''' posted [[Flaws in Richard Lenski Study|errors and flaws]] in a pro-[[evolution]] article by Professor [[Richard Lenski]] (published after a mere 14-day peer review), but [[PNAS]] [[Letter to PNAS|refused to correct the errors]] and Lenski responded with [[Conservapedia:Lenski dialog|petulant rants]] insisting his critic lacked "expertise". | | *'''''Conservapedia''''' posted [[Flaws in Richard Lenski Study|errors and flaws]] in a pro-[[evolution]] article by Professor [[Richard Lenski]] (published after a mere 14-day peer review), but [[PNAS]] [[Letter to PNAS|refused to correct the errors]] and Lenski responded with [[Conservapedia:Lenski dialog|petulant rants]] insisting his critic lacked "expertise". |
| | + | *Internet blogs. Anyone can start a blog, and readers read the best blog posts. Such blogs have been responsible for breaking crucial news stories well before the "experts" of the traditional media--for example, the [[Monica Lewinsky]] story and [[Rathergate]]. |
| | | | |
| − | Musical examples of the "best of the public" include: | + | ===Musical examples=== |
| | | | |
| | *"Battle Hymn of the Republic," the only significant song by Julia Ward Howe. | | *"Battle Hymn of the Republic," the only significant song by Julia Ward Howe. |
| | *"American Pie," the only hit by Don McLean, one of the most thoughtful ballads to top the charts for several weeks | | *"American Pie," the only hit by Don McLean, one of the most thoughtful ballads to top the charts for several weeks |
| | *"You Light Up My Life," the only hit by Debbie Boone, was a tribute to God that topped the charts for many weeks | | *"You Light Up My Life," the only hit by Debbie Boone, was a tribute to God that topped the charts for many weeks |
| | + | *[[American Idol]] |
| | | | |
| − | :(add more one-hit wonders) | + | :''(add more one-hit wonders)'' |
| | | | |
| − | Specific athletic achievements:
| + | ===Athletics=== |
| | | | |
| | + | Anyone can enter, and winning is based solely on skill. |
| | + | ====Competitions==== |
| | + | *The [[Olympic Games]],<ref>Since 1990 there has been a qualifying requirement of reasonable success at a prior event.</ref> |
| | + | *The [[Chicago Marathon]] |
| | + | *The [[Tour de France]].<ref>In the 1920s it was open to all; now there is a qualifying process for teams.</ref> |
| | + | ====Achievements==== |
| | *Dick Fosbury invented the Fosbury Flop despite criticism by all the experts. He won the 1968 Gold Medal with it, and now all imitate it. | | *Dick Fosbury invented the Fosbury Flop despite criticism by all the experts. He won the 1968 Gold Medal with it, and now all imitate it. |
| | *Unsuccessful Olympian, student Roger Bannister broke the 4-minute barrier for the mile, which some experts considered impossible; now the record is 3:43. | | *Unsuccessful Olympian, student Roger Bannister broke the 4-minute barrier for the mile, which some experts considered impossible; now the record is 3:43. |
| Line 46: |
Line 51: |
| | | | |
| | | | |
| − | :(add more) | + | :''(add more)'' |
| | | | |
| − | Examples from science and technology:
| + | ===Science and technology=== |
| | *the [[free software]] movement and its development of the [[Linux]] operating system | | *the [[free software]] movement and its development of the [[Linux]] operating system |
| | *the development of a heavier-than-air, fixed wing aircraft by the [[Wright brothers]], despite opposition and mockery by aviation "experts." | | *the development of a heavier-than-air, fixed wing aircraft by the [[Wright brothers]], despite opposition and mockery by aviation "experts." |
| Line 58: |
Line 63: |
| | *[[Leonardo Da Vinci]] is one of the most well known designers in history, yet was illiterate in Latin, and never attended a university. | | *[[Leonardo Da Vinci]] is one of the most well known designers in history, yet was illiterate in Latin, and never attended a university. |
| | *distributed computing projects such as [[Folding@home]] that combine the computing power of hundreds of thousands of standard home PCs to solve computationally intense problems. | | *distributed computing projects such as [[Folding@home]] that combine the computing power of hundreds of thousands of standard home PCs to solve computationally intense problems. |
| | + | |
| | == Obstacles Created by Experts == | | == Obstacles Created by Experts == |
| | | | |