Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
109 bytes removed ,  12:20, July 23, 2010
→‎Journalism: copy edit
Line 6: Line 6:  
In 1939, the Committee for Cultural Freedom, co-founded by progressive educator [[John Dewey]] and Socialist Irving Howe, published a “Manifesto” in ''The Nation'' criticizing Stalin's purges, arguing that Stalinism had made the Soviet Union into a totalitarian country, like [[Fascist]] [[Italy]] or [[National Socialist]] [[Germany]]. Stone was one of “400 leading Americans” who signed an “Open Letter,” published in ''Soviet Russia Today'', denouncing the CCF as “Fascists” and “reactionaries” for endorsing “the fantastic falsehood that the USSR and the totalitarian states are basically alike.”<ref>[http://www.marxistsfr.org/history/usa/parties/cpusa/1939/08/0814-openletter.pdf To All Active Supporters of Democracy and Peace], ''Soviet Russia Today'', vol. 8, no. 5 (September 1939), pp. 24-25, 28</ref> Unfortunately for Stone and other defenders of Stalin, this righteous blast appeared in the September 1939 issue, coinciding with the revelation of the [[Hitler-Stalin pact]] and joint [[Nazi]]-[[Soviet]] invasion of [[Poland]].
 
In 1939, the Committee for Cultural Freedom, co-founded by progressive educator [[John Dewey]] and Socialist Irving Howe, published a “Manifesto” in ''The Nation'' criticizing Stalin's purges, arguing that Stalinism had made the Soviet Union into a totalitarian country, like [[Fascist]] [[Italy]] or [[National Socialist]] [[Germany]]. Stone was one of “400 leading Americans” who signed an “Open Letter,” published in ''Soviet Russia Today'', denouncing the CCF as “Fascists” and “reactionaries” for endorsing “the fantastic falsehood that the USSR and the totalitarian states are basically alike.”<ref>[http://www.marxistsfr.org/history/usa/parties/cpusa/1939/08/0814-openletter.pdf To All Active Supporters of Democracy and Peace], ''Soviet Russia Today'', vol. 8, no. 5 (September 1939), pp. 24-25, 28</ref> Unfortunately for Stone and other defenders of Stalin, this righteous blast appeared in the September 1939 issue, coinciding with the revelation of the [[Hitler-Stalin pact]] and joint [[Nazi]]-[[Soviet]] invasion of [[Poland]].
   −
Even his worshipful biographer Myra MacPherson admitted that Stone voiced "only tepid criticism of Stalin's brutalities."<ref>Myra MacPherson, ''[http://books.google.com/books?id=kP3i6WsQBtsC 'All Governments Lie!': The Life and Times of Rebel Journalist I. F. Stone]'' (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2006) ISBN 0684807130, p. 118</ref> He was much more vocal in his criticism of the U.S. Government: for example, the Eisenhower White House's "merely 'official'" condolences upon the death of Stalin were "small-minded and unworthy of a great power," wrote Stone. "Magnanimous salute was called for on such an occasion," he added, which "Washington seemed afraid to show."<ref>Isidor Feinstein Stone (Karl Weber, ed.), ''[http://books.google.com/books?id=C8eWAfxx_cUC The Best of I.F. Stone]'' (PublicAffairs, 2006) ISBN 158648463X, pp. 112-113</ref>
+
Even his worshipful biographer Myra MacPherson admitted that Stone voiced "only tepid criticism of Stalin's brutalities."<ref>Myra MacPherson, ''[http://books.google.com/books?id=kP3i6WsQBtsC 'All Governments Lie!': The Life and Times of Rebel Journalist I. F. Stone]'' (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2006) ISBN 0684807130, p. 118</ref> He was much more vocal in his criticism of the U.S. Government: for example, the Eisenhower White House's "merely 'official'" condolences upon the death of Stalin were "small-minded and unworthy of a great power," wrote Stone.<ref>Isidor Feinstein Stone (Karl Weber, ed.), ''[http://books.google.com/books?id=C8eWAfxx_cUC The Best of I.F. Stone]'' (PublicAffairs, 2006) ISBN 158648463X, pp. 112-113</ref>
 
Stone came to be seen as “an apologist for the hammer-and-sickle,” according to another sympathetic biographer, Robert Cottrell:
 
Stone came to be seen as “an apologist for the hammer-and-sickle,” according to another sympathetic biographer, Robert Cottrell:
 
{{cquote|there was something disingenuous in his willingness to suspend judgment or to refuse to criticize still more forcefully the terror that was being played out in Soviet Russia.... What could not be denied was that Stone, like many of his political and intellectual counterparts, continued to afford Russia and even Stalinist communism something of a double standard, fearing that to do otherwise would endanger... the very possibility of socialism.”<ref>Robert C. Cottrell, ''[http://books.google.com/books?ei=86hITO3ZGMT68Abl_bHJDg&ct=result&id=GHDlvZNV0lIC Izzy: A Biography of I.F. Stone]'' (Rutgers University Press, 1994) ISBN 0813520088, pp. 68, 76</ref>}}
 
{{cquote|there was something disingenuous in his willingness to suspend judgment or to refuse to criticize still more forcefully the terror that was being played out in Soviet Russia.... What could not be denied was that Stone, like many of his political and intellectual counterparts, continued to afford Russia and even Stalinist communism something of a double standard, fearing that to do otherwise would endanger... the very possibility of socialism.”<ref>Robert C. Cottrell, ''[http://books.google.com/books?ei=86hITO3ZGMT68Abl_bHJDg&ct=result&id=GHDlvZNV0lIC Izzy: A Biography of I.F. Stone]'' (Rutgers University Press, 1994) ISBN 0813520088, pp. 68, 76</ref>}}
SkipCaptcha, Automoderated users, edit
7,178

edits

Navigation menu