Changes

The Plan reflected wartime hatred of Nazi Germany, which had started and nearly won two great wars using its industrial base.  The alternative was to reform the German people, and that idea won out. The Plan was strongly opposed by Secretary of State [[Cordell  Hull]], by Secretary of War [[Henry Stimson]] and by the British and French because it would make Germans a perpetual enemy.  Hull said: "This was a plan of blind vengeance ... It failed to see that in striking at Germany it was striking at all Europe."  When the Americans did invade Germany almost their first act was, and needed to be, to work the mines to fullest production to aid the European economy.  Roosevelt and Churchill seemed to agree with Morgenthau at the Quebec Conference in Sept. 1944 but in October Roosevelt vetoed the Morgenthau Plan and it never went into effect. Nevertheless it is used to this day by anti-American elements in Germany to attack America.

The Plan reflected wartime hatred of Nazi Germany, which had started and nearly won two great wars using its industrial base.  The alternative was to reform the German people, and that idea won out. The Plan was strongly opposed by Secretary of State [[Cordell  Hull]], by Secretary of War [[Henry Stimson]] and by the British and French because it would make Germans a perpetual enemy.  Hull said: "This was a plan of blind vengeance ... It failed to see that in striking at Germany it was striking at all Europe."  When the Americans did invade Germany almost their first act was, and needed to be, to work the mines to fullest production to aid the European economy.  Roosevelt and Churchill seemed to agree with Morgenthau at the Quebec Conference in Sept. 1944 but in October Roosevelt vetoed the Morgenthau Plan and it never went into effect. Nevertheless it is used to this day by anti-American elements in Germany to attack America.

===Leaks===

===Leaks===

The contents of the Morgenthau Plan leaked <ref>FBI Silvermaster file, Statement by Harold Glasser to Agents Garland and Mossberg, [http://education-research.org/PDFs/Silvermaster116.pdf Vol. 116, pgs. 120 - 129] pdf, May 13, 1947. Glasser states: "during the conference, the press obtained details concerning the MORGANTHAU Plan before it was public. Shortly thereafter, while I was in Montreal, Canada, attending the Second Council Meeting of [[UNRRA]], EMELIO G. CALLAJO of the State Department was my roommate and I regard him as a very close friend.  During that time, I discussed the German Plan with him.  When MORGANTHAU and I had returned to the Untied States, MORGANTHAU called me to his office and accused me of the leakage to the press. I denied it at that time and of course I deny it now.  It is my opinion that through CALLAJO the State Department accused me of talking and being overheard by a newspaperman.  I know MORGANTHAU has never forgotten this and I believe that is the reason why I was passed over and [[FRANK COE]] was selected as the Director of the Division of Monetary Research when [[HARRY WHITE]] left the Treasury Department." (pgs. 128 - 129 pdf).</ref> to the papers and Roosevelt became alarmed at the violence of the reaction, a fine evidence of the fundamentally decent nature of the majority of Americans. Roosevelt tried to deny what he had done. <ref>''The Roosevelt Myth'', John T. Flynn, Fox and Wilkes, 1948, Book 3, Ch. 11, [http://www.rooseveltmyth.com/book/fdrmyth_Chapter_Eleven___How_Germany_s_F.htm ''How Germany's Fate Was Sealed'']</ref>

The contents of the Morgenthau Plan leaked <ref>FBI Silvermaster file, Statement by Harold Glasser to Agents Garland and Mossberg, [http://education-research.org/PDFs/Silvermaster116.pdf Vol. 116, pgs. 120 - 129] pdf, May 13, 1947. Glasser states: "during the conference, the press obtained details concerning the MORGANTHAU Plan before it was public. Shortly thereafter, while I was in Montreal, Canada, attending the Second Council Meeting of [[UNRRA]], EMELIO G. CALLAJO of the State Department was my roommate and I regard him as a very close friend.  During that time, I discussed the German Plan with him.  When MORGANTHAU and I had returned to the United States, MORGANTHAU called me to his office and accused me of the leakage to the press. I denied it at that time and of course I deny it now.  It is my opinion that through CALLAJO the State Department accused me of talking and being overheard by a newspaperman.  I know MORGANTHAU has never forgotten this and I believe that is the reason why I was passed over and [[FRANK COE]] was selected as the Director of the Division of Monetary Research when [[HARRY WHITE]] left the Treasury Department." (pgs. 128 - 129 pdf).</ref> to the papers and Roosevelt became alarmed at the violence of the reaction, a fine evidence of the fundamentally decent nature of the majority of Americans. Roosevelt tried to deny what he had done. <ref>''The Roosevelt Myth'', John T. Flynn, Fox and Wilkes, 1948, Book 3, Ch. 11, [http://www.rooseveltmyth.com/book/fdrmyth_Chapter_Eleven___How_Germany_s_F.htm ''How Germany's Fate Was Sealed'']</ref>

==References==

==References==