Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
112 bytes added ,  20:23, June 6, 2011
→‎Appeal to Consequences: added alternate name; clarified; added example
Line 30: Line 30:     
===Appeal to Consequences===
 
===Appeal to Consequences===
−
An ''appeal to consequences'' is an attempt to motivate belief with an appeal either to the good consequences of believing or the bad consequences of disbelieving. This may or may not involve an appeal to force. Such arguments are clearly fallacious. There is no guarantee, or even likelihood, that the world is the way that it is best for us for it to be. Belief that the world is the way that it is best for us for it to be, absent other evidence, is therefore just as likely to be false as true.  The following is an example:
+
An ''appeal to consequences,'' or, more fully, ''appeal to consequences of a belief,'' is an attempt to motivate belief with an appeal either to the good consequences of believing or the bad consequences of disbelieving. This may or may not involve an appeal to force. Such arguments are fallacious because the consequences of believing or disbelieving have no bearing on the truth or falsity of a belief.  The following is an example:
    
* If you believe in evolution, then you'll be miserable, thinking that life is meaningless
 
* If you believe in evolution, then you'll be miserable, thinking that life is meaningless
Line 41: Line 41:     
This makes an appeal to the positive consequences of believing in evolution, without actually providing any proof of evolution itself.  Just because belief in evolution makes you more respected by [[liberal]] professors, this does not mean that evolution is correct.
 
This makes an appeal to the positive consequences of believing in evolution, without actually providing any proof of evolution itself.  Just because belief in evolution makes you more respected by [[liberal]] professors, this does not mean that evolution is correct.
 +
 +
To use a more extreme example, but one doubtless familiar from everyday life, the mere fact that a child's belief in [[Santa Claus]] can have positive consequences does not prove that Santa Claus exists.
    
===''Argumentum ad hominem''===
 
===''Argumentum ad hominem''===
Block, SkipCaptcha, Automoderated users, edit, rollback
3,026

edits

Navigation menu