| | One Question. Who are you to determine what constitutes Christianity? Obama has just as much a right to be considered Christian as you or I. And if the entire point of this website is truth and backing it up with evidence, why is what I'm doing not accomplishing that? --[[User:MAVE182|MAVE182]] 17:27, 3 July 2011 (EDT) | | One Question. Who are you to determine what constitutes Christianity? Obama has just as much a right to be considered Christian as you or I. And if the entire point of this website is truth and backing it up with evidence, why is what I'm doing not accomplishing that? --[[User:MAVE182|MAVE182]] 17:27, 3 July 2011 (EDT) |
| | + | :Well, you've been blocked now, so you may not be responding - but to respond to your question. There are two approaches to "who is a Christian"? One approach, which you seem to be using, is that "anyone who claims to be a Christian is a Christian". The problem with that, is it turns "Christian" into an empty label, with no substance. Of course, by that definition, no doubt Obama is a Christian. But, is that the right definition? I think not. Another approach to defining Christianity, is the idea that there are some core beliefs, which you must have to be a Christian, and if you lack them, you aren't one. Different people have different views on which beliefs are core, and I don't claim to know whose view is right. And, whatever set of core beliefs we adopt as our definition of "Christianity", does Obama meet them? I don't claim to know. So, in conclusion, "Is Obama really a Christian?" is a fair question to ask, and doesn't have an obvious "Yes" answer like you claim. (On an aside, I actually like Obama, and my objections to him are that he isn't liberal enough for me; but, you are being like the person who turns up to a Republican party meeting with flyers put out by the Obama campaign to hand out. Silly. Accept most people here don't like him, and if you want to change their mind, you'll need a more serious effort than just sheets of talking points to do it.) [[User:Maratrean|Maratrean]] 16:35, 6 July 2011 (EDT) |