Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
→‎Michele Bachmann: People who framed debates of great importance
Line 258: Line 258:  
:::This list is not about titles, or who won or lost a particular election.  It's about '''''influence'''''.  Obama is simply trying to be reelected.  That's not influence.  Bachmann, in contrast, is framing the debate and moving the entire process to the more [[conservative]] side, as illustrated as recently as Thursday night when she essentially eliminated media-favorite [[Tim Pawlenty]] from contention with her response to his criticism.--[[User:Aschlafly|Andy Schlafly]] 19:00, 13 August 2011 (EDT)
 
:::This list is not about titles, or who won or lost a particular election.  It's about '''''influence'''''.  Obama is simply trying to be reelected.  That's not influence.  Bachmann, in contrast, is framing the debate and moving the entire process to the more [[conservative]] side, as illustrated as recently as Thursday night when she essentially eliminated media-favorite [[Tim Pawlenty]] from contention with her response to his criticism.--[[User:Aschlafly|Andy Schlafly]] 19:00, 13 August 2011 (EDT)
 
::::Also, Michelle Bachmann is one of the leading figures of the [[Tea Party]]. You wouldn't argue that the tea party isn't influential, would you? Well Bachmann has been one of the main reasons why it has stayed at the front of the political scene.--[[User:MorrisF|MorrisF]] 19:28, 13 August 2011 (EDT)
 
::::Also, Michelle Bachmann is one of the leading figures of the [[Tea Party]]. You wouldn't argue that the tea party isn't influential, would you? Well Bachmann has been one of the main reasons why it has stayed at the front of the political scene.--[[User:MorrisF|MorrisF]] 19:28, 13 August 2011 (EDT)
 +
:::::OK, understood. If influence in shaping the debate is the main factor in determining influence, I would move at least the following from List 2 to List 1:
 +
Bush (shaped debate on how to deal with international terrorism)
 +
Chamberlain (how can economic growth contribute to achieving peace or preparing for war)
 +
Eisenhower (how to deal with communist expansionism)
 +
Healey (how to achieve long-term economic stability by control of the money supply)
 +
Kemp (how to drive prosperity by cutting taxes)
 +
Lévesque (how far should distinct language groups have autonomy)
 +
Major (how to achieve peace in a situation of civil strife by consensus)
 +
Macmillan (how to decolonise empire)
 +
Rice (as Bush Jr)
 +
Salmond (how far should small, economically successful nations have independence)
 +
Trudeau (how far should independent constitutions be seen as a sign of national maturity).
 +
All these names were people of considerable experience of life and work outside politics and brought fresh ideas to framing debates of the highest importance (which is your criterion for putting Bachmann in List 1). I'll leave this posting here for a couple of hours before moving them all to List 1 in case of any reasoned objections. [[User:KhalidM|KhalidM]] 10:37, 14 August 2011 (EDT)
    
== Obamacare? ==
 
== Obamacare? ==
151

edits

Navigation menu