Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
1,395 bytes added ,  14:53, August 25, 2011
m
Slight grammatical changes
Line 2: Line 2:     
Dawkins' main objectives are to convince his readers that the existence of [[God]] or any other [[deity]] is highly unlikely, that the Bible is incoherent, that [[morality]] does not come from [[religion]], and that if religion does effect morality, it only does so negatively.
 
Dawkins' main objectives are to convince his readers that the existence of [[God]] or any other [[deity]] is highly unlikely, that the Bible is incoherent, that [[morality]] does not come from [[religion]], and that if religion does effect morality, it only does so negatively.
 +
 +
This book is a voice of rationality. If any of the Conservatives actually read and understood it the world would be a rather better place. Indeed, if they read the Koran, rather than trying to burn it, and talk about Muslim and Atheist intolerance the same would happen. In fact, if they read the Bible, the world might greatly improved. I ask them now, have they actually read the Old Testament? Can they really agree with Joshua "killing all within Jericho, young and old, man and woman, ox and sheep and ass by the sword"?
 +
 +
Incidently, Satan kills far less people than God does in the Bible.
    
Critics have called the book "surprisingly intolerant".<ref>{{cite book | quote=For a scientist who criticizes religion for its intolerance, Dawkins has written a surprisingly intolerant book, full of scorn for religion and those who believe. | publisher=Publishers Weekly | title=The God Delusion | year=2006 | month=August | url=http://www.amazon.com/God-Delusion-Richard-Dawkins/dp/0618680004 | }}</ref>
 
Critics have called the book "surprisingly intolerant".<ref>{{cite book | quote=For a scientist who criticizes religion for its intolerance, Dawkins has written a surprisingly intolerant book, full of scorn for religion and those who believe. | publisher=Publishers Weekly | title=The God Delusion | year=2006 | month=August | url=http://www.amazon.com/God-Delusion-Richard-Dawkins/dp/0618680004 | }}</ref>
Line 7: Line 11:  
* Richard Dawkins (2006) makes great play in his recent book ''The God Delusion'' of what he calls the appalling propensity of religious people to base their ideas on [[dogma]] rather than on the [[evidence]]. Well, many do, but this reads strange in a book bursting at the seams with its own dogmas, its uncritical acceptance of [[metaphysical]] theories such as [[Identity Theory]], its refusal to take note of the relevant evidence from [[parapsychology]], and its [[special pleading]] with regard to the views of [[Darwin]] and [[Wallace]] on [[genocide]] (see Smythies, 2007, for details). For example, Dawkins states that he knows that this life is the only life we have. How could he possibly know that? [http://www.scientificexploration.org/journal/jse_22_1_smythies.pdf]
 
* Richard Dawkins (2006) makes great play in his recent book ''The God Delusion'' of what he calls the appalling propensity of religious people to base their ideas on [[dogma]] rather than on the [[evidence]]. Well, many do, but this reads strange in a book bursting at the seams with its own dogmas, its uncritical acceptance of [[metaphysical]] theories such as [[Identity Theory]], its refusal to take note of the relevant evidence from [[parapsychology]], and its [[special pleading]] with regard to the views of [[Darwin]] and [[Wallace]] on [[genocide]] (see Smythies, 2007, for details). For example, Dawkins states that he knows that this life is the only life we have. How could he possibly know that? [http://www.scientificexploration.org/journal/jse_22_1_smythies.pdf]
   −
Dawkins also intends to teach that atheists can live happy, intelligent, lives&mdash;perhaps even happier lives than religious people.  He asserts that atheists do not do evil things in the name of [[atheism]], while [[religion|religious]] people have been known to commit atrocities in the name of their religion.
+
Dawkins also intends to teach that atheists can live happy, intelligent, lives&mdash;perhaps even happier lives than religious people. This is true.  He asserts that atheists do not do evil things in the name of [[atheism]], while [[religion|religious]] people have been known to commit atrocities in the name of their religion. This is also true. The only reason for the Crusades was religious intolerance. On the other hand, Stalin's main motivations were personal power and making Russia powerful. Atheism played only a small role.
    
==Criticism==
 
==Criticism==
''The God Delusion'' has been subject to a great deal of criticisms from the religious and the non-religious alike.
+
''The God Delusion'' has been subject to a great deal of criticisms from the religious and the non-religious alike. Most of it was merely automatic backlash from people who hadn't even read it.
 +
 
 +
Some people wish to complain about the poor quality of Dawkins' book. These people should probally first note the hundereds of innacuracies in the Bible, such as Luke quoting far less generations in between Joesph and David than Mark.
    
===Andrew Brown: Prospect Magazine===
 
===Andrew Brown: Prospect Magazine===
Line 18: Line 24:  
Andrew Brown of Prospect Magazine was unimpressed by Dawkins' book. Brown calls atheism "unnatural" and points out that many atheists were violent in their belief (or lack thereof), citing Stalin killing members of the clergy.
 
Andrew Brown of Prospect Magazine was unimpressed by Dawkins' book. Brown calls atheism "unnatural" and points out that many atheists were violent in their belief (or lack thereof), citing Stalin killing members of the clergy.
   −
Brown also attacks Dawkins' argument that suicide bombers are caused by religious schools. While Dawkins states that if these children were not taught what he calls "faith without question", suicide bombings would not be an issue. Brown, however, says that religion is not a necessity in suicide bombings. He points out that it is a tactic used by Marxists in Sri Lanka.
+
Brown also attacks Dawkins' argument that suicide bombers are caused by religious schools. While Dawkins states that if these children were not taught what he calls "faith without question", suicide bombings would not be an issue. Brown, however, says that religion is not a necessity in suicide bombings. He points out that it is a tactic used by Marxists in Sri Lanka. This is true, but if you look at the world today by far the most amount of terrorists are motivated by religion. In conclusion, most of the writers on Conservapedia know very little about anything. They fabricate most of their facts, and have severe tunnel vision.
    
===Marilynne Robinson: Harper's Magazine===
 
===Marilynne Robinson: Harper's Magazine===

Navigation menu