Atheism and free will

Dr. Jonathan Sarfati is a staff member of Creation Ministries International.

In the Western World, most atheists hold to the philosophy of Philosophical naturalism (see: Atheist worldview).

If naturalism is true, then we ought not to trust our capacity for reason for the human brain would be a byproduct of blind/unintelligent natural forces. Therefore, believing in naturalism is self-defeating.

In short, atheism/naturalism and reason are incompatible. See also: Intelligent design and Evolution

The Christian Apologetics and Research Ministry declares:

“

If matter and energy are all that exist in the universe, then how do you rationally defend the idea that you have free will and can properly use logic? The point is this--how can you as a strict materialist really trust your own mind? I mean, if everything in the universe is matter and energy, then that means your physical brain is bound by the laws of physics. Think about this. In a purely materialistic worldview where the human brain is nothing more than the summation of chemicals and brain wiring, how do you justify having both free will and rationality?... ...perhaps you “believe” you have free will. Maybe you “think” you’re logical. But then again, perhaps you are forced to believe and think that way due to the neuro-chemical wiring in your brain. I have to ask. How do you know that the neuro-chemical wiring in your brain doesn’t just produce a set of processes that force you to think and feel a certain way so that, according to evolutionary theory, your genetics can be passed down to other generations? In this evolutionary, materialistic process, deception could be a reality provided it results in genetic descendants. This way, your atheism is nothing more than a set of chemical states in your brain which forces you into certain beliefs and behaviors so that genes are carried on throughout the centuries.

”

See also:

• Atheism and reason

• Atheism and irrationality

• Atheism and logic