Difference between revisions of "Talk:Doe v. Bolton"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(→ABC- serious objections to the current article.: reply with a link to the consensus opinion) |
|||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
:: You a) ignored my point that even if there were a link there isn't anything ironic in this decision. I don't know how much I can emphasize that- all medical decisions are trade-offs. The presence of possible negatives here doesn't make that ironic. (To use an easy example, consider a female with an ectopic pregnancy). Second, your citations are to put it mildly, not representative of the scientific consensus. See for example [http://www.cancer.gov/cancerinfo/ere-workshop-report| the NIH's report]. The pro-life cause has far better arguments than relying on minority scientific opinions about at best barely statistically significant risks and to continue to push these sorts of things hurts both the cause and Conservapedia. We can do better than this, and should be doing better than this. [[User:JoshuaZ|JoshuaZ]] 20:48, 19 February 2007 (EST) | :: You a) ignored my point that even if there were a link there isn't anything ironic in this decision. I don't know how much I can emphasize that- all medical decisions are trade-offs. The presence of possible negatives here doesn't make that ironic. (To use an easy example, consider a female with an ectopic pregnancy). Second, your citations are to put it mildly, not representative of the scientific consensus. See for example [http://www.cancer.gov/cancerinfo/ere-workshop-report| the NIH's report]. The pro-life cause has far better arguments than relying on minority scientific opinions about at best barely statistically significant risks and to continue to push these sorts of things hurts both the cause and Conservapedia. We can do better than this, and should be doing better than this. [[User:JoshuaZ|JoshuaZ]] 20:48, 19 February 2007 (EST) | ||
| + | |||
| + | ::: There is no "trade-off" in health risks/benefits for abortion. The studies almost unanimously show that abortion significantly increases risk of breast cancer and premature birth for future children. No reasonably objective scientist seriously disputes this. Many studies predate ''Roe v. Wade''. | ||
| + | |||
| + | ::: Your link to NIH, a highly politicized arm of government, does not work. | ||
| + | |||
| + | ::: There may be better arguments against abortion, but that does not justify concealing the facts: abortion causes serious health long-term medical harm to the patients. Regardless of your position on abortion, the public should be aware of this. This is precisely the type of information that Conservapedia should truthfully provide. I haven't looked, but I bet this information wouldn't last 60 minutes on Wikipedia.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 22:16, 19 February 2007 (EST) | ||
Revision as of 03:16, February 20, 2007
ABC- serious objections to the current article.
Um, were not going to seriously claim there's a link are we? First, of all that's been pretty thoroughly debunked. Second of all, even if there were a link there isn't anything ironic here- almost all medical decisions are trade offs- even routine surgery has risks of serious side effects, most standard vaccines have risks of problems, etc. One doesn't need pretend that there is an ABC link to see serious problems with Doe v. Bolton and with Roe. It does a disservice to Conservapedia by making it look like we need to do so. JoshuaZ 00:20, 19 February 2007 (EST)
- Nearly all the studies, and simple logic, indicate the link, Joshua. For starters, it's conclusively proven that childbirth is preventive of breast cancer. No one disputes this.
- But your reaction is not surprising as the abortion industry is as effective as the tobacco industry was in the 1950s in concealing its harm. Regardless, the entry on Doe v. Bolton cites the peer-reviewed articles supporting the link.--Aschlafly 10:27, 19 February 2007 (EST)
- You a) ignored my point that even if there were a link there isn't anything ironic in this decision. I don't know how much I can emphasize that- all medical decisions are trade-offs. The presence of possible negatives here doesn't make that ironic. (To use an easy example, consider a female with an ectopic pregnancy). Second, your citations are to put it mildly, not representative of the scientific consensus. See for example the NIH's report. The pro-life cause has far better arguments than relying on minority scientific opinions about at best barely statistically significant risks and to continue to push these sorts of things hurts both the cause and Conservapedia. We can do better than this, and should be doing better than this. JoshuaZ 20:48, 19 February 2007 (EST)
- There is no "trade-off" in health risks/benefits for abortion. The studies almost unanimously show that abortion significantly increases risk of breast cancer and premature birth for future children. No reasonably objective scientist seriously disputes this. Many studies predate Roe v. Wade.
- Your link to NIH, a highly politicized arm of government, does not work.
- There may be better arguments against abortion, but that does not justify concealing the facts: abortion causes serious health long-term medical harm to the patients. Regardless of your position on abortion, the public should be aware of this. This is precisely the type of information that Conservapedia should truthfully provide. I haven't looked, but I bet this information wouldn't last 60 minutes on Wikipedia.--Aschlafly 22:16, 19 February 2007 (EST)