Difference between revisions of "Talk:Polygamy"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(choose my own words more carefully) |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==request more info== | ==request more info== | ||
| − | Could somebody who knows where to find suitable references please add something to this article about the people involved? It presently defines the terms, and sets a historic background. I would like to read about the motivations and feelings of the participants - how | + | Could somebody who knows where to find suitable references please add something to this article about the people involved? It presently defines the terms, and sets a historic background. I would like to read about the motivations and feelings of the participants - how did a Mormon woman react when her husband decided to take a second wife? How were the household duties divided? Were the wives typically of similar age to each other and their husband, or was one much younger or older? --[[User:Scott|Scott]] 04:47, 20 March 2007 (EDT) <small>updated my words to past tense when referring to polygamous Mormons, but descriptions of contemporary polygamists is OK too. [[User:Scott|Scott]] 17:53, 20 March 2007 (EDT)</small> |
::I think the problem you will encounter, in looking for how people feel in these situations, is that people feel very differently in these situations. Some feel they are fulfilling a religious obligation, some feel betrayed, some feel relived, and some feel abused. It depends on the individuals involved. At best we can generalize, and say most feel X. But, because sociology is a relatively new discipline and since such arrangements are illegal most places today, there is little to no data from which to extrapolate. So I suspect that it will be hard if not impossible to find appropriately verifiable evidence to support general claims about the feelings of those involved. I certainly couldn’t find any—however, if you (or anyone else can) I’d be very interested to see it.--[[User:Reginod|Reginod]] 09:41, 20 March 2007 (EDT) | ::I think the problem you will encounter, in looking for how people feel in these situations, is that people feel very differently in these situations. Some feel they are fulfilling a religious obligation, some feel betrayed, some feel relived, and some feel abused. It depends on the individuals involved. At best we can generalize, and say most feel X. But, because sociology is a relatively new discipline and since such arrangements are illegal most places today, there is little to no data from which to extrapolate. So I suspect that it will be hard if not impossible to find appropriately verifiable evidence to support general claims about the feelings of those involved. I certainly couldn’t find any—however, if you (or anyone else can) I’d be very interested to see it.--[[User:Reginod|Reginod]] 09:41, 20 March 2007 (EDT) | ||
:::Perhaps I should have asked what the Church said they should feel. The demographic statistics and the official Mormon teaching might well survive, even if we can't quote newspaper interviews with any first wives. --[[User:Scott|Scott]] 10:14, 20 March 2007 (EDT) | :::Perhaps I should have asked what the Church said they should feel. The demographic statistics and the official Mormon teaching might well survive, even if we can't quote newspaper interviews with any first wives. --[[User:Scott|Scott]] 10:14, 20 March 2007 (EDT) | ||
Revision as of 21:53, March 20, 2007
request more info
Could somebody who knows where to find suitable references please add something to this article about the people involved? It presently defines the terms, and sets a historic background. I would like to read about the motivations and feelings of the participants - how did a Mormon woman react when her husband decided to take a second wife? How were the household duties divided? Were the wives typically of similar age to each other and their husband, or was one much younger or older? --Scott 04:47, 20 March 2007 (EDT) updated my words to past tense when referring to polygamous Mormons, but descriptions of contemporary polygamists is OK too. Scott 17:53, 20 March 2007 (EDT)
- I think the problem you will encounter, in looking for how people feel in these situations, is that people feel very differently in these situations. Some feel they are fulfilling a religious obligation, some feel betrayed, some feel relived, and some feel abused. It depends on the individuals involved. At best we can generalize, and say most feel X. But, because sociology is a relatively new discipline and since such arrangements are illegal most places today, there is little to no data from which to extrapolate. So I suspect that it will be hard if not impossible to find appropriately verifiable evidence to support general claims about the feelings of those involved. I certainly couldn’t find any—however, if you (or anyone else can) I’d be very interested to see it.--Reginod 09:41, 20 March 2007 (EDT)
- Perhaps I should have asked what the Church said they should feel. The demographic statistics and the official Mormon teaching might well survive, even if we can't quote newspaper interviews with any first wives. --Scott 10:14, 20 March 2007 (EDT)
- I think the problem you will encounter, in looking for how people feel in these situations, is that people feel very differently in these situations. Some feel they are fulfilling a religious obligation, some feel betrayed, some feel relived, and some feel abused. It depends on the individuals involved. At best we can generalize, and say most feel X. But, because sociology is a relatively new discipline and since such arrangements are illegal most places today, there is little to no data from which to extrapolate. So I suspect that it will be hard if not impossible to find appropriately verifiable evidence to support general claims about the feelings of those involved. I certainly couldn’t find any—however, if you (or anyone else can) I’d be very interested to see it.--Reginod 09:41, 20 March 2007 (EDT)