Difference between revisions of "I.F. Stone"

From Conservapedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(→‎Journalis: eliminated red links)
(→‎Korean war disinformation: added info to this section)
Line 19: Line 19:
 
==Korean war disinformation==
 
==Korean war disinformation==
  
−
Documents from Soviet era archive show that Stone was wrong in his assessment and that [[Joseph Stalin]] and [[Kim Il Sung]] orchestrated the [[Korean War]].
+
In 1952, Stone published ''The Hidden History of the Korean War,'' in which he lent credence to the patently false [[Communist Party]] line that South Korea was the aggressor that initiated the conflict, by invading the Communist North, with leading Americans in complicit accord.<ref>Myra MacPherson, “[http://www.huffingtonpost.com/myra-macpherson/review-ispies-the-rise-an_b_208731.html Review: ''Spies: the Rise and Fall of the KGB in America'' and 'Three Tales of I.F Stone and the KGB: Kalugin, Venona and the Notebooks']”, HuffingtonPost.com, May 28, 2009</ref> His double-talk style may be glimpsed in the following quote:
 +
{{cquote|Whether on June 25 the North attacked without provocation or went over to the offensive after an attack from the South, the attempt to pick that tempting plum solved many political problems on the anti-Communist side.<ref>Lionel Abel, “[http://www.commentarymagazine.com/viewarticle.cfm/cold-war-14738 Cold War], Reader Letters, Commentary, August 1969</ref>}}
 +
James Wechsler, a former leader of the Young Communist League<ref>Herbert Romerstein and Eric Breindel, ''[http://books.google.com/books?id=NEEJrm38jLAC The Venona Secrets: Exposing Soviet Espionage and America's Traitors]'' (Regnery Publishing, 2000) ISBN 0895262754, p. 172 </ref> writer at ''The Nation''&mdash;later a vicious foe of [[Senator]] [[Joe McCarthy]] (R.-Wisc.) as editor of the ''New York Post''&mdash;characterized Stone as “a fairly regular apologist for the Communists.”<ref>Myra MacPherson, ''[http://books.google.com/books?id=kP3i6WsQBtsC 'All Governments Lie!': The Life and Times of Rebel Journalist I. F. Stone]'' (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2006) ISBN 0684807130, p. 126</ref>
 +
 
 +
Meanwhile the ex-[[Communist]] Richard Rovere, then a writer for ''The New Masses'', a Marxist journal once edited by Soviet espionage courier [[Whittaker Chambers]] (and future author of a book trashing McCarthy),<ref>Richard Halworth Rovere, ''[http://books.google.com/books?id=c5GOLPhg954C Senator Joe McCarthy]'' (University of California Press, 1996) ISBN 0520204727</ref> accused Stone of writing “heavily documented rubbish” with a pro-Communist slant. He called Stone “a man who thinks up good arguments for poor Communist positions,” adding, “Never, I think, has the communist line been upheld with such an elaborate display of the mechanics of research.” ''The Nation'' itself dismissed the book as “tendentious.”<ref>Myra MacPherson, ''[http://books.google.com/books?id=kP3i6WsQBtsC 'All Governments Lie!': The Life and Times of Rebel Journalist I. F. Stone]'' (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2006) ISBN 0684807130, p. 268</ref> Even his worshipful biographer Myra McPherson agreed that this was Stone's “most tendentious work.”<ref>Myra MacPherson, “[http://www.huffingtonpost.com/myra-macpherson/review-ispies-the-rise-an_b_208731.html Review: ''Spies: the Rise and Fall of the KGB in America'' and 'Three Tales of I.F Stone and the KGB: Kalugin, Venona and the Notebooks']”, HuffingtonPost.com, May 28, 2009</ref>
  
 
==Liberal icon and Wikipedia disinformation==
 
==Liberal icon and Wikipedia disinformation==

Revision as of 01:10, July 23, 2010

Isador Feinstein Stone (also I.F. Stone or Izzy Stone) (December 24, 1907 – July 17, 1989) was a Soviet propagandist considered by many liberals as the standard for independent investigative journalism. Several independent historians and researchers as well as retired KGB officials have come to the conclusion that Stone was among a number of persons inside the U.S. journalism community used as a Soviet agent of influence, with one columnist going as far to call Stone "the KGB's front man in American journalism."

Journalis

Stone began writing for The Nation in 1932, becoming the magazine's Washington editor in 1940. He became Washington correspondent for the New York daily P.M.,[1] then in 1948 for its successor, The New York Star,[2] the next year moving, in turn, to that paper's successor, The Daily Compass,[3] for which he was a columnist until it went out of business in 1952. That year he began writing his own newsletter, I.F. Stone's Weekly, which he published until 1971.[4]

In 1939, the Committee for Cultural Freedom, co-founded by progressive educator John Dewey and Socialist Irving Howe, published a “Manifesto” in The Nation criticizing Stalin's purges, arguing that Stalinism had made the Soviet Union into a totalitarian country, like Fascist Italy or National Socialist Germany. Stone was one of “400 leading Americans” who signed an “Open Letter,” published in Soviet Russia Today, denouncing the CCF as “Fascists” and “reactionaries” for endorsing “the fantastic falsehood that the USSR and the totalitarian states are basically alike.”[5] Unfortunately for Stone and other defenders of Stalin, this righteous blast appeared in the September 1939 issue, coinciding with the revelation of the Hitler-Stalin pact and joint Nazi-Soviet invasion of Poland.

Stone came to be seen as “an apologist for the hammer-and-sickle,” according to his otherwise sympathetic biographer Robert Cottrell:

“ there was something disingenuous in his willingness to suspend judgment or to refuse to criticize still more forcefully the terror that was being played out in Soviet Russia.... What could not be denied was that Stone, like many of his political and intellectual counterparts, continued to afford Russia and even Stalinist communism something of a double standard, fearing that to do otherwise would endanger... the very possibility of socialism.”[6] ”

KGB recruitment

Retired KGB General Oleg Kalugin wrote, in The First Directorate, that KGB headquarters had cabled him to reestablish contact with Stone because "he was a man with whom we had regular contact." He goes on to describe Stone as a "fellow traveller who made no secret of his admiration for the Soviet system." [7] The Venona cables show that he had a relationship with the KGB. Venona cables describe a vigorous campaign by the veteran KGB officer and head of the Soviet Tass news agency, Vladimir Pravdin, to recruit Stone. Bernard Schuster was finally required to rescue the operation. Stone "was not refusing to help the KGB, but "had three children and did not want to attract the attention of the FBI." KGB operatives making the approaches had used "insufficient caution," Stone said. The KGB Resident's informed Moscow that Stone's fear "was his unwillingness to spoil his career" since he "earned $1500.00 per month but …would not be averse to having a supplemental income." In response to Pravdin's question as to "liaison" (clandestine meetings for passage of information), Stone "replied that he would be glad to meet but he rarely visited New York City." The cable went on to record: "for the establishment of business contact with him. . .we are insisting on reciprocity." [8] The cable exchange shows clearly Stone's willingness to cooperate with the Soviets and to accept additional income from them. "Business contact" meant espionage and "reciprocity" meant quid pro quo in the KGB vernacular. That Stone rarely went to New York would simply mean meetings would be held in Washington, his main base.

Korean war disinformation

In 1952, Stone published The Hidden History of the Korean War, in which he lent credence to the patently false Communist Party line that South Korea was the aggressor that initiated the conflict, by invading the Communist North, with leading Americans in complicit accord.[9] His double-talk style may be glimpsed in the following quote:

“ Whether on June 25 the North attacked without provocation or went over to the offensive after an attack from the South, the attempt to pick that tempting plum solved many political problems on the anti-Communist side.[10] ”

James Wechsler, a former leader of the Young Communist League[11] writer at The Nation—later a vicious foe of Senator Joe McCarthy (R.-Wisc.) as editor of the New York Post—characterized Stone as “a fairly regular apologist for the Communists.”[12]

Meanwhile the ex-Communist Richard Rovere, then a writer for The New Masses, a Marxist journal once edited by Soviet espionage courier Whittaker Chambers (and future author of a book trashing McCarthy),[13] accused Stone of writing “heavily documented rubbish” with a pro-Communist slant. He called Stone “a man who thinks up good arguments for poor Communist positions,” adding, “Never, I think, has the communist line been upheld with such an elaborate display of the mechanics of research.” The Nation itself dismissed the book as “tendentious.”[14] Even his worshipful biographer Myra McPherson agreed that this was Stone's “most tendentious work.”[15]

Liberal icon and Wikipedia disinformation

Stone remained a major hero to elements of the liberal media in the United States following his death just months short of the fall of the Berlin Wall, which led various print outlets from The Nation magazine to the Columbia Journalism Review to seek to exonerate him following the emergence of the new charges in 1992. In the pages of the Nation, liberal journalist D. D. Guttenplan argued that Stone could have agreed with some aspects of Soviet policy without his writing being limited to parroting their propaganda and that they may have considered him an agent of influence and sought meetings with him only to the extent he agreed. [16] Wikipedia of course got into the act and ended its own lengthy section of the I. F. Stone article by stating, "years of tailing by agents, informants, illegal car searches, and even pawing through his trash produced not a shred of evidence of clandestine activities." [17] These years apparently began only at the end of the Korean War and continued into the 1970's, when COINTELPRO was shut down. However, this statement notably lacked a cite, so we do not know where to go to read the declassified investigative reports accessed by Wikipedia.

References

  1. ↑ P.M., The Writings of I.F. Stone (The Official Web Site of I.F. Stone)
  2. ↑ The Star, The Writings of I.F. Stone (The Official Web Site of I.F. Stone)
  3. ↑ The Compass, The Writings of I.F. Stone (The Official Web Site of I.F. Stone)
  4. ↑ I.F. Stone’s Weekly, The Writings of I.F. Stone (The Official Web Site of I.F. Stone)
  5. ↑ To All Active Supporters of Democracy and Peace, Soviet Russia Today, vol. 8, no. 5 (September 1939), pp. 24-25, 28
  6. ↑ Robert C. Cottrell, Izzy: A Biography of I.F. Stone (Rutgers University Press, 1994) ISBN 0813520088, pp. 68, 76
  7. ↑ Oleg Kalugin, The First Directorate, New York: St. Martin's Press, 1994, p. 74.
  8. ↑ 1506 KGB New York to Moscow, 23 October 1944, pg.1, 1506 KGB New York to Moscow, 23 October 1944, pg.2.
  9. ↑ Myra MacPherson, “Review: Spies: the Rise and Fall of the KGB in America and 'Three Tales of I.F Stone and the KGB: Kalugin, Venona and the Notebooks'”, HuffingtonPost.com, May 28, 2009
  10. ↑ Lionel Abel, “Cold War, Reader Letters, Commentary, August 1969
  11. ↑ Herbert Romerstein and Eric Breindel, The Venona Secrets: Exposing Soviet Espionage and America's Traitors (Regnery Publishing, 2000) ISBN 0895262754, p. 172
  12. ↑ Myra MacPherson, 'All Governments Lie!': The Life and Times of Rebel Journalist I. F. Stone (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2006) ISBN 0684807130, p. 126
  13. ↑ Richard Halworth Rovere, Senator Joe McCarthy (University of California Press, 1996) ISBN 0520204727
  14. ↑ Myra MacPherson, 'All Governments Lie!': The Life and Times of Rebel Journalist I. F. Stone (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2006) ISBN 0684807130, p. 268
  15. ↑ Myra MacPherson, “Review: Spies: the Rise and Fall of the KGB in America and 'Three Tales of I.F Stone and the KGB: Kalugin, Venona and the Notebooks'”, HuffingtonPost.com, May 28, 2009
  16. ↑ D. D. Guttenplan, "Izzy an Agent?", The Nation, August 3/10, 1992
  17. ↑ Accessed online May 1, 2007

External links

External link