4,459 bytes added
, 09:22, April 17, 2007
I think there are two arguments in the creationism versus evolution debate.
(i) Creationism/Intelligent Design is based primarily on the belief that the bible is essentially a revealed text and is accurate. If this is not so, then Creationism per se has no foundation. If you START from the assumption that the bible is correct PLUS there is an omnipotent being who is prepared to do what it takes to ensure that what is written in the bible is correct, then you can, in principle come up with any explanation that you like and claim that you theory is justified. The thesis is not only repugnant to many people as it is profoundly anti-intellectual; it is also intellectually bankrupt, as it does not progress our understanding, either of God or of the world.
(ii) Scientific Understanding (as opposed to the scientific method), is an endeavour which attempts to make sense of what we see around us. One of the features of this, is that God as an explanation appears to recede into ever narrower gaps in our understanding as our scientific understanding expands. You can take one of two opposing views here: either God exists, and he constructed all this so that when reality is inspected through the lens of science it appears as if he is not necessary (i.e there is a load of evidence to suggest that evolution is real, but actually it's a ploy by god to fool us - or to test our faith or something similar), OR on the other hand we might conclude that the scientific expanation is adequate on its own and God is unnecessary. It was on this last point that Galileo had such trouble with the inquisition. They did not per se, disagree that the facts said that the earth apparently moves around the sun, but they vehemently disagreed with what they saw as Galileo's heresy that scientific understanding, per se, can lead you to conclude anything about the true nature of the cosmos. Their viewpoint parallels the argument taken by many young earth creationists, viz: the bible appears to say that the earth is at the centre of the universe, so it must be. If the observable facts disagree with this, then it must be that God has arranged the universe so that it appears as if the sun is at the centre and the earth goes around the sun.
I think it is this latter which is the basic stumbling block, and it does come down to belief - either a belief that the universe is fundamentally mysterious and no matter how much we try, we will never understand the mind of God, so stop trying and just worship him, or a belief that the universe IS basically understandible (irrelevant to whether or not god exists, created it, died some time ago or never existed in the first place), in which case we use the simplist theories, the most elegant explanations, to form the most consistent, coherent and logical understandings of the universe that we can, based on currently available best evidence and the most effective and robust of our prevailing theories.
If you believe in the former, you are subscribing to the god theory, and you do not need to look for other explanations, as the single explanation you have is fully satisfying and is the ultimate 'theory of everything'. If you do not subscribe to the god theory, then you will be continually striving for better explanations, which are more elegant, deeper, more powerful and more all-encompassing, as no explanation that you can come up with will be the ultimate 'theory of everything'.
However, just one rider to all this: suppose that 2000 years ago, all of humanity had been witness to Christ's death on the cross, and was totally convinced of god's omnipotence and that the bible reveals all. The quest for scientific understanding would have ceased, as it would have become unnecessary, and we would be living in a theological golden age, but without technology; in fact we could not be having this internet conversation now.
Whatever the creationist might believe about the way that the universe functions, the real challenge is to come up with an explanation of how the pursuit of science per se, has been so successful, has been able to make such excellent predictions, and is able to provide clear, rational and usually mathematical models of the the way that the world operates, then further go on to explain why, in this particular field of science (evolution), where the same principles have been adopted, human beings have got it so wrong. --[[User:Felix|Felix]] 05:22, 17 April 2007 (EDT)