Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Reply to Felix
Line 11: Line 11:     
Whatever the creationist might believe about the way that the universe functions, the real challenge is to come up with an explanation of how the pursuit of science per se, has been so successful, has been able to make such excellent predictions, and is able to provide clear, rational and usually mathematical models of the the way that the world operates, then further go on to explain why, in this particular field of science (evolution), where the same principles have been adopted, human beings have got it so wrong. --[[User:Felix|Felix]] 05:22, 17 April 2007 (EDT)
 
Whatever the creationist might believe about the way that the universe functions, the real challenge is to come up with an explanation of how the pursuit of science per se, has been so successful, has been able to make such excellent predictions, and is able to provide clear, rational and usually mathematical models of the the way that the world operates, then further go on to explain why, in this particular field of science (evolution), where the same principles have been adopted, human beings have got it so wrong. --[[User:Felix|Felix]] 05:22, 17 April 2007 (EDT)
 +
 +
:That creationism is based primarily on the Bible may be correct (at least if you mean as a starting point), but that's not necessarily true for Intelligent Design.
 +
:Creationists do ''not'' start from the assumption that "there is an omnipotent being who is prepared to do what it takes to ensure that what is written in the bible is correct".  They start from the assumption that the Bible is an accurate historical record, correctly documenting what did take place.
 +
:You have provided no evidence of your claim that "you can, in principle come up with any explanation that you like and claim that you theory is justified".  I reject that claim.
 +
:I was interested in your wording that "...God as an explanation appears to recede...".  Perhaps it ''appears'' that way because that is, for many, the ''goal'', not because of any necessary result of science.
 +
:Your "two opposing views" are not the only two possible views, and neither are what creationists believe.  So you have presented a false dichotomy.
 +
:Your statements about Galileo are wrong.  For the most part, his views were ''accepted'', and there was (again for the most part) strong support from the church for science.  Galileo's problem was that he upset someone who was in a position to make life difficult for him, plus he was challenging Aristotle's ''non-biblical'' views that the church had adopted.
 +
:Again with reference to the Earth and the sun being at the centre, creationists do ''not'' subscribe to the [[Omphalos]] view that God made things look contrary to the way they are.
 +
:You referred to a "belief that the universe IS basically understandible".  What you don't seem to realise is that this belief came from Christianity!  A review of Rodney Stark's book ''For The Glory of God: How Monotheism Led to Reformations, Science, Witch-hunts and the End of Slavery '' says the following:
 +
{{QuoteBox|India, China, Persia, Greece and Rome all had venerable traditions of scholarship but why did only Christian Europe develop science? Stark’s answer is simple but profound—the Christian God was rational, responsive, dependable and omnipotent and the universe was his personal creation in which his divine nature was put on display for man’s benefit and instruction. Among the passages most commonly cited by medieval scholars was: ‘Thou has ordered all things in measure and number and weight.’ Christians believed that science could be done and should be done.[http://www.creationontheweb.com/content/view/1581/]}}
 +
:I might agree that we should use the simplest and most elegant theories, etc., as you said, but I might disagree with which theory best fits that "requirement".
 +
:Your claim that subscribing to the "god theory" means that you need not look for other explanation contradicts the quote in the box above, and the fact that many if not most of the early scientists were Christians (creationists).  It did not stop them looking for explanation; in fact it encouraged them to look for explanations.  The same response applies to your following paragraph about all quest for scientific understanding ceasing.  The claim is simply contrary to the facts.  Much of the technology behind the Internet (electricity, for example) was discovered and/or developed by Christians.  So again, your assertions are contrary to the facts.
 +
:With regard to your final paragraph, the difference is that the science that developed technology is ''empirical'' or ''experimental'' science that is able to observe, test, and measure results.  If I don't believe that water boils at 100 degrees Celsius, I can test it for myself.  Goo-to-your evolution, on the other hand, is a story about the past, which we do not have available to observe, test, and measure.  If I believe that reptiles changed into birds 65 million years ago, what tests can I run to see if that happened?
 +
:[[User:Philip J. Rayment|Philip J. Rayment]] 07:31, 17 April 2007 (EDT)
nsTeam2RO, nsTeam2RW, nsTeam2_talkRO, nsTeam2_talkRW
13,254

edits

Navigation menu