Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
no edit summary
Line 25: Line 25:  
:With regard to your final paragraph, the difference is that the science that developed technology is ''empirical'' or ''experimental'' science that is able to observe, test, and measure results.  If I don't believe that water boils at 100 degrees Celsius, I can test it for myself.  Goo-to-your evolution, on the other hand, is a story about the past, which we do not have available to observe, test, and measure.  If I believe that reptiles changed into birds 65 million years ago, what tests can I run to see if that happened?
 
:With regard to your final paragraph, the difference is that the science that developed technology is ''empirical'' or ''experimental'' science that is able to observe, test, and measure results.  If I don't believe that water boils at 100 degrees Celsius, I can test it for myself.  Goo-to-your evolution, on the other hand, is a story about the past, which we do not have available to observe, test, and measure.  If I believe that reptiles changed into birds 65 million years ago, what tests can I run to see if that happened?
 
:[[User:Philip J. Rayment|Philip J. Rayment]] 07:31, 17 April 2007 (EDT)
 
:[[User:Philip J. Rayment|Philip J. Rayment]] 07:31, 17 April 2007 (EDT)
 +
 +
 +
Some Further Thoughts--
 +
 +
 +
One of the major issues in attempting to debate these topics, is that not only are the terms 'creationism' and 'evolution' loose conglomerations of a whole load of actually quite diverse theories eg Creationism could involve strict biblical creation, young earth creation, intelligent design, creation over an extended timescale, creation and then some evolution, creation by extraterrestrial material via comet etc., whereas Evolution may involve Lamarkian or Darwinian forms, macro evolution, microevolution, random DNA mutations; non-random DNA mutations, environmental changes to metatags within the DNA code or whatever. This means that it is always, on both sides, possible to put up straw men to be knocked down, and equally, to hide behind a slightly different version of the theory when one particular version is under threat.
 +
 +
There is also the other issue of the bible versus science, and this debate is riddled with the same sort of contingencies: in quoting the bible, you are inevitably interpreting what one particular section might say; in a book of this nature, there will be other passages which appear to contradict or at least are not totally consistent with each other. Any argument that you give builds not only on what you think the passage means, but on what you have read about what other people think it means. In science too, there is no real consensus about what the scientific method actually is. Logical positivists take the fairly stark view that it's only about making predictions and not about explanations; however many scientists these days would claim (like Galileo) that science actually reveals truths about the world. However, many science educators take a constructivist view of knowledge, that is, knowledge and understanding are created by our brains via a process which is akin to the scientific methodology of theorising + falsification proposed by Popper. Radical Constructivists claim that we cannot in general know the content of another's brain and therefore are in no position to judge whether another's understanding of the world is is valid or invalid, merely whether it ''appears to be'' consistent with our own.
 +
 +
All of this is like trying to juggle with fog.
 +
 +
However the debate is fascinating, and it serves to expose what on the surface are two entirely different types of thinking, but in essence have many similarities. I personally believe that the essential difference between the two viewpoints is the one I have alluded to above, and that is your starting point, namely in one case, the bible is the only valid source of universal truths, and the other, scientific methodology is the only way of exposing universal truth. The fact is, on both sides whe have people using pseudoscience to justify, support and refute arguments, and this does not help.
 +
 +
In this debate, which is essentially about whether you believe that the bible or science is the more valid way of interpreting the world, you essentially take your pick. However, once having chosen, you then throw away all sorts of stuff. Science has got to be devoid of teleological explanations; life has no purpose etc. And the bible must be the source of all wisdom. However, this is often problematic. For example what does the bible tell you about the speed of light? What does the bible tell you about lasers? If it is quiet on these things, then you have to explain why this is. Furthermore you need to explore how you can ever be certain that you are simply failing to interpret the word of god effectively?  For if you start going off and using scientific methodology to develop and extend your world view, how can you ever be certain that the Answer wasn't in Genesis somewhere, but that you failed to spot it? This is a major problem for creation scientists as the bible is clearly not all-encompassing: where are the boundaries to biblical knowledge? Where does the bible leave off, and where should scientific reasoning begin?
 +
 +
However, (and this is probably where I really diverge from creationists): I believe that in attempting to claim that creationism is a science, the biblical creation argument becomes fatally flawed; if science is actually about uncovering ever more sophisticated explanations which grow, develop and eventually become the prevailing paradigm, then creation science must either challenge its own underlying beliefs (just as science has done via the work of Aristotle, Hume, Popper etc.) and in doing so ultimately develop ''scientific'' explanations which are on a par with evolution, and are as elegant as those of evolution. Challenging its underlying beliefs means taking seriously the notion that the world was not created less than 10000 years ago, and weighing the evidence for it, with the possible conclusion that it is very much older than this, '''despite what it might say in the bible''' If it does this, then it could conceivably supercede evolution as an explanatory framework for how the universe actually works. If it does not do this, it will simply demonstrate that no matter how convincing the arguments become for evolution, and no matter how much evidence and argument weighs in against creationism, it sticks doggedly to its position, unmovable, and will never convince anyone in the scientific community, as it is merely demonstrating by any accepted philosophical criteria that it is not a science. (unless of course it creates a new definition of science which has by then become the prevailing paradigm!)
 +
--[[User:Felix|Felix]] 08:19, 17 April 2007 (EDT)
182

edits

Navigation menu