Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Reply to Felix.
Line 42: Line 42:  
However, (and this is probably where I really diverge from creationists): I believe that in attempting to claim that creationism is a science, the biblical creation argument becomes fatally flawed; if science is actually about uncovering ever more sophisticated explanations which grow, develop and eventually become the prevailing paradigm, then creation science must either challenge its own underlying beliefs (just as science has done via the work of Aristotle, Hume, Popper etc.) and in doing so ultimately develop ''scientific'' explanations which are on a par with evolution, and are as elegant as those of evolution. Challenging its underlying beliefs means taking seriously the notion that the world was not created less than 10000 years ago, and weighing the evidence for it, with the possible conclusion that it is very much older than this, '''despite what it might say in the bible''' If it does this, then it could conceivably supercede evolution as an explanatory framework for how the universe actually works. If it does not do this, it will simply demonstrate that no matter how convincing the arguments become for evolution, and no matter how much evidence and argument weighs in against creationism, it sticks doggedly to its position, unmovable, and will never convince anyone in the scientific community, as it is merely demonstrating by any accepted philosophical criteria that it is not a science. (unless of course it creates a new definition of science which has by then become the prevailing paradigm!)
 
However, (and this is probably where I really diverge from creationists): I believe that in attempting to claim that creationism is a science, the biblical creation argument becomes fatally flawed; if science is actually about uncovering ever more sophisticated explanations which grow, develop and eventually become the prevailing paradigm, then creation science must either challenge its own underlying beliefs (just as science has done via the work of Aristotle, Hume, Popper etc.) and in doing so ultimately develop ''scientific'' explanations which are on a par with evolution, and are as elegant as those of evolution. Challenging its underlying beliefs means taking seriously the notion that the world was not created less than 10000 years ago, and weighing the evidence for it, with the possible conclusion that it is very much older than this, '''despite what it might say in the bible''' If it does this, then it could conceivably supercede evolution as an explanatory framework for how the universe actually works. If it does not do this, it will simply demonstrate that no matter how convincing the arguments become for evolution, and no matter how much evidence and argument weighs in against creationism, it sticks doggedly to its position, unmovable, and will never convince anyone in the scientific community, as it is merely demonstrating by any accepted philosophical criteria that it is not a science. (unless of course it creates a new definition of science which has by then become the prevailing paradigm!)
 
--[[User:Felix|Felix]] 08:19, 17 April 2007 (EDT)
 
--[[User:Felix|Felix]] 08:19, 17 April 2007 (EDT)
 +
 +
:I agree with your first paragraph about the way terms are used.  That is why on my user Creationism page I particularly said that I was talking about Young Earth Creation (which I would equate with Biblical creation).  And why I mentioned "goo-to-you evolution" to clarify that I wasn't talking about a change in gene frequencies or some other definition.
 +
:Your characterisation of the Bible as a book "of this nature" that is subject to interpretation is unfair.  That ''could'' be said of pretty well any book, and I don't see why it could be said of the Bible in particular.
 +
:Creationists do not believe that the Bible is the "only" valid source of information.  It provides a basis/outline/foundation, on which we can build our knowledge.  The fact that the Bible doesn't say anything about the speed of light or lasers is irrelevant.  Your "major problem for creation scientists" is in your imagination, it seems, because I know of no creation scientist who has that problem.
 +
:Science is not "about about uncovering ever more sophisticated explanations which grow, develop and eventually become the prevailing paradigm", but about learning about the world we inhabit.  It might result in what you said, but that is not its purpose.
 +
:Your assessment that creation science must end up challenging its own underlying beliefs ''presumes'' that there will be some conflict there.  Perhaps evolutionists should challenger their beliefs that the world is older than 6,000 years, '''despite what atheists say''' (not only atheists, of course).
 +
:It seems to me that evolutionists stick doggedly to evolution took, despite all the evidence offered by creationists that is more consistent with creation than evolution.  See I can spout rhetoric too!
 +
:Evolutionists have already done what you predict creationists might do—they have redefined science to be a search for ''natural'' explanations, thus ruling creationism out ''by definition'', despite its origins in a Christian worldview.
 +
:[[User:Philip J. Rayment|Philip J. Rayment]] 10:31, 17 April 2007 (EDT)
nsTeam2RO, nsTeam2RW, nsTeam2_talkRO, nsTeam2_talkRW
13,254

edits

Navigation menu