Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
An interesting debate
Line 51: Line 51:  
:Evolutionists have already done what you predict creationists might do—they have redefined science to be a search for ''natural'' explanations, thus ruling creationism out ''by definition'', despite its origins in a Christian worldview.
 
:Evolutionists have already done what you predict creationists might do—they have redefined science to be a search for ''natural'' explanations, thus ruling creationism out ''by definition'', despite its origins in a Christian worldview.
 
:[[User:Philip J. Rayment|Philip J. Rayment]] 10:31, 17 April 2007 (EDT)
 
:[[User:Philip J. Rayment|Philip J. Rayment]] 10:31, 17 April 2007 (EDT)
 +
 +
== An interesting debate ==
 +
 +
Philip, I can tell we will eventually agree to disagree with one another, but you seem to be missing the point of what I am saying. If creationism is to be a science, then it must demonstrate it scientific credentials or be condemned as a non-science. That to me is a given.
 +
 +
Therefore it seems to me that there are two paths forward for 'creation science'
 +
 +
# to redefine what science is, and have that accepted by the scientific community, or
 +
# to use scientific principles in a root-and-branch manner in order to develop a single coherent creationist theory, which will then be accpted by the scientific community.
 +
 +
I really think that (1) is probably off the agenda, as from the level of creationist debate that I have seen, there are very few people writing on the topic who have the scientific and philosophical clout to be able to convince the holders of the current paradigm that they have it wrong. (I could be wrong, but I don't think so).
 +
 +
This means that to claim creationism is a science, you must do (2) , or something very like it. However, this means, as I have said, not sniping at evolution, and saying what is wrong with that,  but pursuing an extended project which involves (amongst other things)
 +
(i) Examining the essential principles that lie at the heart of the theory, producing a simple account of this, and arguing critically as to why, exactly the simple account is valid.
 +
(ii) Using the 'simple account', developing a consistent, coherent theory of how things got to be the way they did, for example, which things were created, when, and what has happened after that? Is evolution (macro or micro) any part of this story? and then going back to (i) to modify the 'simple account' when it turns out that your 'simple account' is not quite right.
 +
(iii) Using the theory developed to explain phenomena that have already been explained via other mechanisms, and also demonstrating that the theory has greater explanatory power than anything currently on offer. Being prepared to return to (ii) and modify the theory to take account of the fact that it did not precisely give satisfactory explanations.
 +
(iv) Making predictions on the basis of the theory, that can be systematically checked against observation and experiment.Being prepared to return to (ii) to modify the theory when it turns out that your predictions are incorrect.
 +
 +
You say that I presume that creationism will be found wanting. That is correct, because if it really is science, its basic tenets and theories will inevitably be found wanting at some point. All scientific theories are eventually be superceded by something better - either modifications or refutations. I take the pragmatic view. If someone, whether they be evolutionist or creationist, comes up with evidence which invalidates any of the current theories, then that is wonderful! It moves knowledge on, because we can dispense with an inadequate theory and base our understanding one something much better.
 +
 +
If creationism is based on something else, such as a revealed truth, then it is immutable, and will not change. In this case it is not amenable to scientific methodology, and its proponents should not be claiming that it is a science.
 +
 +
--[[User:Felix|Felix]] 11:13, 17 April 2007 (EDT)
182

edits

Navigation menu