:Your argument presumes that other scientists will dispassionately and objectively judge creation science on its merits, whereas the opposite is true. Many scientists reject creationism simply because it includes God in the equation, and they have an ideological problem with that.[http://www.creationontheweb.com/content/view/703/]
+
:Modern science was founded mostly by creationists. Creationism was at the time entirely consistent with scientific thinking. It's not that creationism changed its underlying assumptions or its arguments, but that secular scientists decided that science had to be, by definition, based on naturalism, thus excluding the supernatural even from consideration. So no amount of demonstrating that creation science is science is going to change that mindset.
+
:I'd say that creationists have done all the things that you suggest that they should do. They have developed their own theories, in detail. They have made successful predictions. They have changed their minds on particular proposals as further evidence became available. But the response is often simply to deny that it makes successful predictions, deny that it does any research, deny that there is any evidence that supports it, deny that it can be scientific, deny on that basis the opportunity to publish in the secular science journals, use the lack of publication in secular science journals as evidence that it's not science (see the circular argument?), etc. etc.
+
:Your defence of your presumption that creationism will be found wanting is illogical. You are basically saying that it will be found wanting if it is science because science never has the right answer! ("...if it really is science, its basic tenets and theories will inevitably be found wanting at some point."). It may be true that 99.99% of scientific ideas are wrong, but in theory some idea ''must'' be right, so you cannot say with certainty that a particular idea ''must'' inevitably be found wanting. And remember we are talking here about the basic premise; I've already said that some of the details (individual propositions) ''have'' been found wanting.
+
:[[User:Philip J. Rayment|Philip J. Rayment]] 11:34, 17 April 2007 (EDT)