Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Argument by Bald Assertion
Line 80: Line 80:  
:Your defence of your presumption that creationism will be found wanting is illogical.  You are basically saying that it will be found wanting if it is science because science never has the right answer! ("...if it really is science, its basic tenets and theories will inevitably be found wanting at some point.").  It may be true that 99.99% of scientific ideas are wrong, but in theory some idea ''must'' be right, so you cannot say with certainty that a particular idea ''must'' inevitably be found wanting.  And remember we are talking here about the basic premise; I've already said that some of the details (individual propositions) ''have'' been found wanting.
 
:Your defence of your presumption that creationism will be found wanting is illogical.  You are basically saying that it will be found wanting if it is science because science never has the right answer! ("...if it really is science, its basic tenets and theories will inevitably be found wanting at some point.").  It may be true that 99.99% of scientific ideas are wrong, but in theory some idea ''must'' be right, so you cannot say with certainty that a particular idea ''must'' inevitably be found wanting.  And remember we are talking here about the basic premise; I've already said that some of the details (individual propositions) ''have'' been found wanting.
 
:[[User:Philip J. Rayment|Philip J. Rayment]] 11:34, 17 April 2007 (EDT)
 
:[[User:Philip J. Rayment|Philip J. Rayment]] 11:34, 17 April 2007 (EDT)
 +
 +
== Argument by Bald Assertion ==
 +
 +
''I'll agree that the basic concept of creationism is not falsifiable. That is, nobody can formulate any scientific test of whether God did actually create the world.''
 +
:And that's why Creationism is ''not science''.
 +
''However, neither can anybody formulate any scientific test of whether the basic concept of goo-to-you evolution, or at least its underlying premise of naturalism, is falsifiable.''
 +
:I keep trying to tell you differently, but you keep not listening.  --[[User:Gulik5|Gulik5]] 12:55, 10 April 2008 (EDT)
199

edits

Navigation menu