| Line 59: |
Line 59: |
| | | | |
| | You're clearly not a friend to these themes: first you called it clutter, then you tried to dismiss it as irrelevant, then you tried to erase its thematic structure in the name of consistency, then you expected me to "compromise" along the lines of the previous actions, on your now maintaining that it ought to be removed altogether. It doesn't look like to me you are acting on rational principles but rather on personal preferences of what ideas to which the public should not have access. [[User:VargasMilan|VargasMilan]] ([[User talk:VargasMilan|talk]]) 18:12, 6 March 2016 (EST) | | You're clearly not a friend to these themes: first you called it clutter, then you tried to dismiss it as irrelevant, then you tried to erase its thematic structure in the name of consistency, then you expected me to "compromise" along the lines of the previous actions, on your now maintaining that it ought to be removed altogether. It doesn't look like to me you are acting on rational principles but rather on personal preferences of what ideas to which the public should not have access. [[User:VargasMilan|VargasMilan]] ([[User talk:VargasMilan|talk]]) 18:12, 6 March 2016 (EST) |
| − | :Please do not misinterpret my motives. I believe that Conservapedia can be a reliable and credible alternative to Wikipedia, even though we have adopted much of WP software and overall encyclopedia format. (I no longer edit Wikipedia and have come here to work instead so that home-schooled students may have a suitable alternative.) For Conservapedia to meet those needs, edits "must be informative, family-friendly, clean, concise, and without gossip" (Commandment 3). When we put an idea in a sentence in the main part of the article, it should have footnotes to sources where the student can verify what we are saying. If an article is reasonable well-written, the ideas and sentences will flow within an overall context. | + | :Please do not misinterpret my motives. I believe that Conservapedia can be a reliable and credible alternative to Wikipedia, even though we have adopted much of WP software and overall encyclopedia format. (I no longer edit Wikipedia and have come here to work instead so that home-schooled students may have a suitable alternative.) For Conservapedia to meet those needs, edits "must be informative, family-friendly, clean, concise, and without gossip" (Commandment 3). When we put an idea in a sentence in the main part of the article, it should have footnotes to sources where the student can verify what we are saying. If an article is reasonable well-written, the ideas and sentences will flow within an overall context. A "See also" list is not the place to add unrelated ideas. According to the Style Manual, "The See also section consists of a bullet list of article names without pipes. Only one article name should appear on each line. Only articles that are directly relevant to the topic of the article should be included on the See also list." However, by including [[Obama donor list]] on the see also list rather than in the text above promises the reader that if they click on the link they will find relevant information. The donor list article is only two sentences long and the relationship to the US National Debt is not obvious to the reader. |
| − | A "See also" list is not the place to add unrelated ideas. According to the Style Manual, "The See also section consists of a bullet list of article names without pipes. Only one article name should appear on each line. Only articles that are directly relevant to the topic of the article should be included on the See also list." However, by including [[Obama donor list]] on the see also list rather than in the text above promises the reader that if they click on the link they will find relevant information. The donor list article is only two sentences long and the relationship to the US National Debt is not obvious to the reader. | |
| | | | |
| − | :The only theme that bothers me is that bankers are Jews and gangsters. So, I have been working on removing that theme from a number of articles, which lead me to this one. | + | :So, I would not object to someone adding a paragraph (with proper sources) explaining that Obama donors lead to excess federal spending. (Although other sources would explain that donors to Appropriations Committee Chairmen also lead to excess federal spending.) But having a link to the two sentence donor list article without any explanation leaves the reader confused. |
| | + | |
| | + | :The only theme that bothers me is that bankers are Jews and gangsters. That is name-calling and gossip. So, I have been working on removing that theme from a number of articles, which lead me to this one. |
| | | | |
| | :I respect the amount of work that you have put into this article. Let's not allow its credibility to be diminished by someone copying and pasting the same, ill-formatted "see also" list into a large number of articles. That is just a lazy alternative to writing new material. Thanks, [[User:JDano|JDano]] ([[User talk:JDano|talk]]) 11:26, 10 March 2016 (EST) | | :I respect the amount of work that you have put into this article. Let's not allow its credibility to be diminished by someone copying and pasting the same, ill-formatted "see also" list into a large number of articles. That is just a lazy alternative to writing new material. Thanks, [[User:JDano|JDano]] ([[User talk:JDano|talk]]) 11:26, 10 March 2016 (EST) |
| − |
| |
| − | :So, I would not object to someone adding a paragraph (with proper sources) explaining that Obama donors lead to excess federal spending. (Although other sources would explain that donors to Appropriations Committee Chairmen also lead to excess federal spending.) But having
| |