Block, Siteadmin, SkipCaptcha, Upload, Automoderated users, delete, edit, move, nsTeam2RO, nsTeam2RW, nsTeam2_talkRO, nsTeam2_talkRW, protect, rollback, Administrators, template
294,717
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 1,076:
Line 1,076: − + Line 1,086:
Line 1,086: − + + +
→Should CP allow Essay space to be used as a platform for Holocaust denial and Holocaust revisionism?
:::::You fail to understand that the SA leadership is not the same as the rank-and-file. The organizational leadership was purged in 1934, but the rank-and-file remained in the Nazi movement. If you can't understand that, then too bad. —[[User:LT|<code><span style="background:#FF8181">'''LT'''</span></code>]] '''''[[User talk:LT|<sup>Rev. 22:13</sup>]]''''' Sunday, 01:30, October 29, 2023 (EDT)
:::::You fail to understand that the SA leadership is not the same as the rank-and-file. The organizational leadership was purged in 1934, but the rank-and-file remained in the Nazi movement. If you can't understand that, then too bad. —[[User:LT|<code><span style="background:#FF8181">'''LT'''</span></code>]] '''''[[User talk:LT|<sup>Rev. 22:13</sup>]]''''' Sunday, 01:30, October 29, 2023 (EDT)
::::::The SA was nor empowered to execute the Holocaust (the "Final Solution"). The SS was. it originated with Goring's Commission to Heydrich (see Lucy Davidowicz, ''A Holocaust Reader'').
::::::The SA was not empowered to execute the Holocaust (the "Final Solution"). The SS was. it originated with Goring's Commission to Heydrich (see Lucy Davidowicz, ''A Holocaust Reader'').
::::::The SA was a party organization, not a paramilitary group.
::::::The SA was a party organization, not a paramilitary group.
::::::Yes, the SA was primarily responsible for [[Kristallnacht]] in 1938, but that was at least three and half years before the Holocaust.
::::::Yes, the SA was primarily responsible for [[Kristallnacht]] in 1938, but that was at least three and half years before the Holocaust.
::::::You are simply barking up the wrong tree, attempting to demonize communists or the Communist Party as responsible for the Holocaust to meet contemporary American anti-Socialist and anti-Communist sentiment. That is historical revisionism and Holocaust revisionism. And some might even say Holocaust denial. You are beginning with a conclusion and trying to twist historical facts to fit your contemporary view. [[User:RobSmith|RobS]]<sup>[[User talk:RobSmith|''Give Peace a Chance!'']]</sup> 01:48, October 29, 2023 (EDT)
::::::You are simply barking up the wrong tree, attempting to demonize communists or the Communist Party as responsible for the Holocaust to meet contemporary American anti-Socialist and anti-Communist sentiment. That is historical revisionism and Holocaust revisionism. And some might even say Holocaust denial. You are beginning with a conclusion and trying to twist historical facts to fit your contemporary view.
::::::Your argument is basically, "Well, they're both [[totalitarian]], so what's the difference?" Well, there is a difference. And for all your emphasis on ideology as a motivating factor, I'm at a loss why you can't see the difference. i blame the sources you are looking at.[[User:RobSmith|RobS]]<sup>[[User talk:RobSmith|''Give Peace a Chance!'']]</sup> 01:48, October 29, 2023 (EDT)
:::::::Your Communist/Nazi revisionism won't work on me, pal. To reiterate (and slightly expand) for the zillionth time: the three million rank-and-file Nazis in the SA continued the NSDAP ranks, even if not in the exact SA hierarchy. The Night of the Long Knives was a power struggle within the Nazi leadership that purged the SA leaders, not three million members of the rank-and-file.
:::::::Your Communist/Nazi revisionism won't work on me, pal. To reiterate (and slightly expand) for the zillionth time: the three million rank-and-file Nazis in the SA continued the NSDAP ranks, even if not in the exact SA hierarchy. The Night of the Long Knives was a power struggle within the Nazi leadership that purged the SA leaders, not three million members of the rank-and-file.