2
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 1:
Line 1: + + + + + + +
Rationale for the edit to the controversy line, suggestions for future work
:During his swearing in ceremony in early January 2007, Ellison replaced the Bible with a the Quran and then took his oath of duty with one hand placed on the Quran.
:During his swearing in ceremony in early January 2007, Ellison replaced the Bible with a the Quran and then took his oath of duty with one hand placed on the Quran.
This was debunked, or at least is misleading. The real swearing-in ceremony was done en masse, with no books. He later restated the oath with a Quran, which I suppose he characterized as a "ceremony," but it had no official weight or meaning. He did not replace the Bible with the Quran, because there was no Bible present or expected for him to replace at his personal "ceremony."--[[User:All Fish Welcome|All Fish Welcome]] 03:14, 15 April 2007 (EDT)
This was debunked, or at least is misleading. The real swearing-in ceremony was done en masse, with no books. He later restated the oath with a Quran, which I suppose he characterized as a "ceremony," but it had no official weight or meaning. He did not replace the Bible with the Quran, because there was no Bible present or expected for him to replace at his personal "ceremony."--[[User:All Fish Welcome|All Fish Welcome]] 03:14, 15 April 2007 (EDT)
----
The Post article cited for
:Ellison is quite controversial due to past statements made about Jews and white people, and his ties with the radical Nation of Islam.
Doesn't actually include any statements about Jews or white people, or mention their existence. It does mention the Powerline accusations of anti-Semitism, and the NoI ties, so I edited the entry to reflect just those. I'm okay with my edit, but if someone wants to change it to stronger language, it'd be cool if htey could find a source for the stronger claim, maybe someone who read Powerline more often back in 2006, and could find the sources that Powerline linked to. - [[User:Loremipsum|Loremipsum]] 18:48, 14 July 2007 (EDT)