62
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 102:
Line 102: − + + +
→Debate over the merge of MSM and Mainstream Media
Vandal? Hardly - I removed none of your content barring opinion. No Feed-back? Hardly - I offered evidence on the Talk page, we discussed it, others agreed. A Sysop - Crocoite - agreed with the redirect of an acronym. I gave notes constantly. I asked openly for "help" with the edit in the summary, and also added a "how am i doing?" in another summary. You can see extensive dialogue between you and I and others on the Talk page. And if adding references from widely accepted sources like Nielsen is 'liberal', I can't agree with that - they are used by every broadcaster worldwide. I can hardly see how much more open I could have been? I have not tried to deceive anyone, as I have characterised all entires as 'some believe one thing', providing references, and 'others believe another', providing references. I simply don't understand your comments. [[User:BrianRobertson|BrianRobertson]] 15:36, 2 August 2007 (EDT)
Vandal? Hardly - I removed none of your content barring opinion. No Feed-back? Hardly - I offered evidence on the Talk page, we discussed it, others agreed. A Sysop - Crocoite - agreed with the redirect of an acronym. I gave notes constantly. I asked openly for "help" with the edit in the summary, and also added a "how am i doing?" in another summary. You can see extensive dialogue between you and I and others on the Talk page. And if adding references from widely accepted sources like Nielsen is 'liberal', I can't agree with that - they are used by every broadcaster worldwide. I can hardly see how much more open I could have been? I have not tried to deceive anyone, as I have characterised all entires as 'some believe one thing', providing references, and 'others believe another', providing references. I simply don't understand your comments. [[User:BrianRobertson|BrianRobertson]] 15:36, 2 August 2007 (EDT)
==Debate over the merge of MSM and Mainstream Media==
==Merging of MSM and Mainstream Media Articles==
One other point: would you agree that, forgetting everything else we're discussing, MSM should be a redirect to Mainstream Media? if not, can you explain why an acronym should NOT redirect to its actual term? [[User:BrianRobertson|BrianRobertson]] 15:48, 2 August 2007 (EDT)
One other point: would you agree that, forgetting everything else we're discussing, MSM should be a redirect to Mainstream Media? if not, can you explain why an acronym should NOT redirect to its actual term? [[User:BrianRobertson|BrianRobertson]] 15:48, 2 August 2007 (EDT)
Speaking to this, we now have duplicate info on both MSM and Mainstream Media. For example, the removal of the blog info on CBS that TK did on this page has not been done on the other page. Yet another reason for a merge is that spelling and grammatical mistakes fixed on one page now exist on another. [[User:BrianRobertson|BrianRobertson]] 16:39, 2 August 2007 (EDT)