Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
3,347 bytes added ,  14:51, October 22, 2007
Line 198: Line 198:     
*Very well said, Mathers!  --<font color="#1E90FF" face="Comic Sans MS">[[User:TK|şŷŝôρ-₮K]]</font><sup><font color="DC143C">[[User_Talk:TK|/Ṣρёаќǃ]]</font></sup> 18:33, 19 October 2007 (EDT)
 
*Very well said, Mathers!  --<font color="#1E90FF" face="Comic Sans MS">[[User:TK|şŷŝôρ-₮K]]</font><sup><font color="DC143C">[[User_Talk:TK|/Ṣρёаќǃ]]</font></sup> 18:33, 19 October 2007 (EDT)
 +
 +
==Democrat (or at least ex-Democrat), sure. But liberal?==
 +
Describing Phelps as a Democrat is justifiable, since he did run as a Democrat, but the first sentence dexcribes him as a "leftist", which I believe is the same as "liberal". This seems flawed. Not all Democrats are liberal and vice versa (anyone remember Zell Miller? Reagan and Thurmond were both Democrats once too). Looking at Conservapedia's own definition of [[liberal]] we have the following specific views how many of them apply to Phelps?
 +
#denial of inherent gender differences, leading to things such as allowing men and women to have the same jobs in the military (while quietly holding them to different standards)
 +
#:No evidence that he feels this way
 +
#taxpayer-funded abortion
 +
#:Certainly not
 +
#same-sex marriage
 +
#:HA!
 +
#support of affirmative action
 +
#:No evidence of this
 +
#support of political correctness
 +
#:Not at all
 +
#censorship of prayer in classrooms
 +
#:No
 +
#compelled taxpayer funding of government schools for nearly all ages
 +
#:Hard to say, but publicly funded schools are hardly a liberal issue; there is widespread support for them. Most people do not want to completely privatize education.
 +
#government-controlled medical care
 +
#:No evidence of this
 +
#labor unions
 +
#:no evidence of this
 +
#elimination of abstinence-only program funding
 +
#:Given his religious views, this seems unlikely
 +
#income redistribution, usually through progressive taxation
 +
#:No evidence of this
 +
#a "living Constitution" that is reinterpreted rather than an unchanging Constitution as written
 +
#:No idea. He'd probably support a "living constitution" if interpretations of the document would harm the homosexual agenda, but against it if it would promote it.
 +
#support for gun control
 +
#:No evidnce for this (seems unlikely)
 +
#government programs to rehabilitate criminals
 +
#:No idea
 +
#environmentalism
 +
#:No evidence for this
 +
#disarmament treaties
 +
#:No evidence (this guy seems not to be much of a foreign policy wonk, except when it comes to praising anti-gay foreign leaders)
 +
#globalism
 +
#:No evidence of this (except for global condemnation of homosexuality)
 +
#opposition to a strong American foreign policy
 +
#:No evidence
 +
#support of obscenity and pornography as a First Amendment right
 +
#:Seems unlikely
 +
#opposition to full private property rights
 +
#:No evidence of this
 +
#limit conservative talk radio by reinstating the Fairness Doctrine
 +
#:Seems unlikely that he'd want to do anything to aid the pro-gay liberal media
 +
So he basically has no discernable liberal traits. This does not make him a conservative, but it really seems he's not a leftist. The only things that point to his leftism are running as a Democrat (who can say why he picked one party over the other? He didn't have much suport from either, it seems) and his support for Gore (dropped when it turned out Gore's views on homosexuality were more liberal than the previously appered). Since Democrat is not the same as liberal, I'm not sure how the latter applies to him. Can anyone justify the inclusion of the term leftist? If someone can point out statements he's made supporting strong environmentalism, opposition to gun rights, disarmament treaties, property rights opposition, or such a case could certainly be made, but right now I'm not seeing any real leftism here. [[User:BillyFranco|BillyFranco]] 10:51, 22 October 2007 (EDT)

Navigation menu