Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
1,462 bytes added ,  20:28, October 22, 2007
Line 253: Line 253:  
:::::So, were back to the definition "a liberal is a leftist," and "a leftist is a liberal."  We were attacked by cyberterrorists for months trying to put that stuff in.
 
:::::So, were back to the definition "a liberal is a leftist," and "a leftist is a liberal."  We were attacked by cyberterrorists for months trying to put that stuff in.
 
:::::Liberals don't hate?  Please....And nowhere in the text does it say Phelps is a liberal.  He is in Cat:Liberal activists, and a strong case can be made that he belongs there.  [[User:RobSmith|Rob Smith]] 16:07, 22 October 2007 (EDT)
 
:::::Liberals don't hate?  Please....And nowhere in the text does it say Phelps is a liberal.  He is in Cat:Liberal activists, and a strong case can be made that he belongs there.  [[User:RobSmith|Rob Smith]] 16:07, 22 October 2007 (EDT)
−
 
+
::::::I know nothing about cyberterrorists and such, but I was sort of under the impression that liberal and leftist were sort of interchangable. This site's own article says that leftist is associated with "social democracy, liberalism, or the several strains of socialism and communism. It may also be applied to those who oppose conservative politics. The word 'liberal' is often used in the US to mean 'leftist'. But this is inconsistent with the original meaning of the word liberal." I see nothing socialist or communist about Phelps (support for Castro is based solely on his anti-gay stance, not his economics), nor any real connection with social democracy. In this country it ''is'' basically interchangable with "liberal" (classical liberalism is out of the scope of this issue), so calling him a leftist is much the same as calling him a liberal. And note that I never said liberals don't hate, I said that hating gays is not a liberal trait. Are you trying to argue that it is? I think that would be an uphill battle, but feel free to try. And by the way, calling him a liberal activist ''is'' calling him a liberal (just like saying someone is a Mexican footballer is saying he is Mexican, and a footballer). So if he isn't a liberal but is a leftist, what is it that makes him a leftist (and how is that different from the standard definition of liberal that the 21 points illustrate)? [[User:BillyFranco|BillyFranco]] 16:28, 22 October 2007 (EDT)
 
I despise Liberals but I have to agree with this loonie leftie this time, Phelps is definetly not a liberal even though he was (or possibly still is) a member of the Democratic Party. Besides what's wrong with protesting homosexuality anyways? I just think he carries it too far thats all --[[User:Konservativekanadian|Konservativekanadian]] 16:22, 22 October 2007 (EDT)
 
I despise Liberals but I have to agree with this loonie leftie this time, Phelps is definetly not a liberal even though he was (or possibly still is) a member of the Democratic Party. Besides what's wrong with protesting homosexuality anyways? I just think he carries it too far thats all --[[User:Konservativekanadian|Konservativekanadian]] 16:22, 22 October 2007 (EDT)

Navigation menu