Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
243 bytes added ,  02:07, November 1, 2008
Infobox issues
Line 9: Line 9:     
Among other problems, the sentence "Using design inference based on their morphology, paleontologists believe that they were sea-dwelling carnivores that dined on fish and shellfish" is both uncited and essentially false (at least in so far as if design inference is being used as Dembski would use it). As I understand it, the main evidence for being sea-dwelling is that elements of the morphology match those of sea-dwelling creatures. Similar comments apply to their carnivorous nature. Second, the article says that "According to creation scientists, who use the Bible, plesiosaurs were created on the fifth day of the Creation Week[1] and lived concurrently with Man. It is also widely held among creation researchers that the leviathan mentioned in the Bible[2] was a plesiosaur." The references given are biblical verses. Now, I know my Bible pretty well, and it doesn't anywhere say anything of the form "Creation scientists say X" - these aren't really citations but simple references to the verses that Young Earth Creationists base their views upon. That they do so needs a separate citation, such as to AIG. [[User:JoshuaZ|JoshuaZ]] 02:41, 28 February 2007 (EST)
 
Among other problems, the sentence "Using design inference based on their morphology, paleontologists believe that they were sea-dwelling carnivores that dined on fish and shellfish" is both uncited and essentially false (at least in so far as if design inference is being used as Dembski would use it). As I understand it, the main evidence for being sea-dwelling is that elements of the morphology match those of sea-dwelling creatures. Similar comments apply to their carnivorous nature. Second, the article says that "According to creation scientists, who use the Bible, plesiosaurs were created on the fifth day of the Creation Week[1] and lived concurrently with Man. It is also widely held among creation researchers that the leviathan mentioned in the Bible[2] was a plesiosaur." The references given are biblical verses. Now, I know my Bible pretty well, and it doesn't anywhere say anything of the form "Creation scientists say X" - these aren't really citations but simple references to the verses that Young Earth Creationists base their views upon. That they do so needs a separate citation, such as to AIG. [[User:JoshuaZ|JoshuaZ]] 02:41, 28 February 2007 (EST)
 +
 +
==Infobox==
 +
The infobox section on the families that comprise the "Plesiosaur" name, could someone make it to where each has its own redlink? All of them together would not make a good article. [[User:JY23|JY23]] 22:07, 31 October 2008 (EDT)
4,272

edits

Navigation menu