4,781
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 193:
Line 193: +
Talk:Brokeback Mountain (view source)
Revision as of 06:02, November 19, 2008
, 06:02, November 19, 2008→Fact citations: reply to the proud liberal
Don't you think you should actually watch the movie, or at least read the script or something before writing an article on it. I've seen the film numerous times, and the synopsis here doesn't describe the film at all. The article displays a definite Christian bias (which I understand and am not condemning), but the film itself doesn't depict the relationship between Ennis and Jack (the protagonists) so judgementally. You certainly don't get the sense, as a member of the audience that the protagonists "come to their senses" when they marry. In fact you get the feeling that they are both making a mistake in marrying women whom they clearly don't love. It's the site's prerogative to discuss a subject from a Conservative and Christian point of view, but no matter what you believe it is wrong to tell an outright lie, and wrong to parade an assumption as truth. Please watch this film before you judge it[[User:Liberalnproud|Liberalnproud]]
Don't you think you should actually watch the movie, or at least read the script or something before writing an article on it. I've seen the film numerous times, and the synopsis here doesn't describe the film at all. The article displays a definite Christian bias (which I understand and am not condemning), but the film itself doesn't depict the relationship between Ennis and Jack (the protagonists) so judgementally. You certainly don't get the sense, as a member of the audience that the protagonists "come to their senses" when they marry. In fact you get the feeling that they are both making a mistake in marrying women whom they clearly don't love. It's the site's prerogative to discuss a subject from a Conservative and Christian point of view, but no matter what you believe it is wrong to tell an outright lie, and wrong to parade an assumption as truth. Please watch this film before you judge it[[User:Liberalnproud|Liberalnproud]]
:For one, I will not have a movie I haven't seen be spoiled by reading some revealing script excerpts or detailed reviews. It takes the pleasure out of any surprises the film may have in store (in that line, I have thoroughly avoided reading the plot descriptions on movies like [[Vertigo_(film)|Vertigo]]). As a second point, you say you are not condemning the Christian <s>bias</s>point of view, yet you are so gullible to believe that the men were making a mistake when they married women and discount the Christian position that they were finally stepping on the right path. And lastly, no, I will not watch this movie, because of the clear [[brainwashing]] effect it has had on people like you who claim to respect Christian principles (although with your moniker, I find that hard to swallow). -[[User:Foxtrot|Foxtrot]] 01:02, 19 November 2008 (EST)
== More sensible actors ==
== More sensible actors ==