Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
2 bytes added ,  23:16, November 19, 2008
m
Line 94: Line 94:  
::::::::I don't know how you would go about disproving some of these. For example, look at the second one. I have never heard ''anyone'' make that argument. You can't prove or disprove it because its just random. Besides, the commandments say everything that is posted should be true and verifiable. Logic dictates that this would mean when someone adds to an article they should use references, instead of just making it up off the top of their head. '''[[user:FernoKlump|<font color="#000066" >FernoKlump</font>]]'''<sup>[[User:FernoKlump/petition|<font color="#bd2433" >Look at this petition!]]</font></sup> 09:48, 19 November 2008 (EST)
 
::::::::I don't know how you would go about disproving some of these. For example, look at the second one. I have never heard ''anyone'' make that argument. You can't prove or disprove it because its just random. Besides, the commandments say everything that is posted should be true and verifiable. Logic dictates that this would mean when someone adds to an article they should use references, instead of just making it up off the top of their head. '''[[user:FernoKlump|<font color="#000066" >FernoKlump</font>]]'''<sup>[[User:FernoKlump/petition|<font color="#bd2433" >Look at this petition!]]</font></sup> 09:48, 19 November 2008 (EST)
   −
::::::::If the statement was accepted to be true, then you're right, they would not need citations. But they are not accepted to be true, which is the point of the argument in the first place! If FernoKlump thought it was common knowledge, he wouldn't have placed fact tags. --'' '''[[user:JArneal|<font color="#006666" >JArneal</font>]]''' '' 18:15, 19 November 2008 (EST)
+
::::::::If the statements were accepted to be true, then you're right, they would not need citations. But they are not accepted to be true, which is the point of the argument in the first place! If FernoKlump thought it was common knowledge, he wouldn't have placed fact tags. --'' '''[[user:JArneal|<font color="#006666" >JArneal</font>]]''' '' 18:15, 19 November 2008 (EST)
359

edits

Navigation menu