12
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 4:
Line 4: +
re
While you're right that maybe a killing in self-defense wouldn't be "murder," I don't think it would be assassination, either. An assassination is done for the specific purpose of advancing a political agenda - a killing committed for self defense is NOT done primarily to advance a political agenda. As for the assassination of a tyrant being not murder, I'm not sure I agree. If somebody has walked up to Hitler and shot him through the heart, it may have been just, it may have been good, but it would still be murder. [[User:JacobB|JacobB]] 01:06, 1 March 2010 (EST)
While you're right that maybe a killing in self-defense wouldn't be "murder," I don't think it would be assassination, either. An assassination is done for the specific purpose of advancing a political agenda - a killing committed for self defense is NOT done primarily to advance a political agenda. As for the assassination of a tyrant being not murder, I'm not sure I agree. If somebody has walked up to Hitler and shot him through the heart, it may have been just, it may have been good, but it would still be murder. [[User:JacobB|JacobB]] 01:06, 1 March 2010 (EST)
:Consider for instance Judges 3:15-25, in which Ehud assassinates the Moabite king, Eglon. I don't think that would be considered a "murder" in the Exodus 20:13 ("thou shalt not kill") sense. Likewise, might there not be assassinations carried out against tyrannical rulers (e.g. the deliberate targeting of [[Simon Fraser of Balnain]] by American sniper [[Timothy Murphy]] at [[Bemis Heights]] during the [[American Revolutionary War]]) that would be justifiable acts of defense of life, liberty and property, and therefore not count as murder? Clearly there is a difference between "murder" and simple "homicide" or "killing," or there would be no need for debate about the wording. [[Murder]] refers to something morally wrong, while those other terms are morally neutral. [[User:NathanLarson|NathanLarson]] 01:18, 1 March 2010 (EST)