Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
no edit summary
Line 8: Line 8:  
Putting the issue into context, here's the line: "Some of the central dogmas of atheism include the non-existence of God, the non-existence of afterlife or an immortal soul, that all which exists is ultimately reducible to matter (materialism), and that faith is illegitimate". okay, fair point, but as the word 'materialism' is associated more often with the philosophical definition, rather than the science one, perhaps it would be better to put "(the scientific theory of materialism)" instead of just "materialism". - JamesCA, 31 July 2011
 
Putting the issue into context, here's the line: "Some of the central dogmas of atheism include the non-existence of God, the non-existence of afterlife or an immortal soul, that all which exists is ultimately reducible to matter (materialism), and that faith is illegitimate". okay, fair point, but as the word 'materialism' is associated more often with the philosophical definition, rather than the science one, perhaps it would be better to put "(the scientific theory of materialism)" instead of just "materialism". - JamesCA, 31 July 2011
 
:JamesCA, there is a distinction between the ''philosophical'' definition of materialism (all reality is reducible to matter), and the ''popular'' one (excessive focus on material wealth). It should be obvious from the context that the first definition is meant, not the second. [[User:Maratrean|Maratrean]] 00:12, 6 August 2011 (EDT)
 
:JamesCA, there is a distinction between the ''philosophical'' definition of materialism (all reality is reducible to matter), and the ''popular'' one (excessive focus on material wealth). It should be obvious from the context that the first definition is meant, not the second. [[User:Maratrean|Maratrean]] 00:12, 6 August 2011 (EDT)
 +
:It is only obvious to those who know of both. It was only after following the link above that I was aware of the philosophical definition. So I think that a bit of clarity is useful, and is not harmful to the article. JamesCA, August 6 2011
SkipCaptcha
175

edits

Navigation menu