| Line 90: |
Line 90: |
| | | | |
| | ===Illustration=== | | ===Illustration=== |
| − | In a case from recent memory User:C blocked User:BS as a "parodist." When asked for evidence to justify the block under CP policy, User:C provided none. User:C made a lengthy argument that User:BS, who had several "I am a Christian" userboxes in CP, was ''allegedy'' another User:SC aat RW 2.0. User:SC at RW 2.0 had several "this user is an atheist" userboxes at that website. With no evidence or explanation, User:C concluded that User:BS "had lied" at CP, and was a parodist. '''[[Conservapedia:How_Conservapedia_Differs_from_Wikipedia]]''' specifically states, | + | In a case from recent memory User:C blocked User:BS as a "parodist." When asked for evidence to justify the block under CP policy, User:C provided none. User:C made a lengthy argument that User:BS, who had several "I am a Christian" userboxes in CP, was ''allegedy'' another User:SC at RW 2.0. User:SC at RW 2.0 had several "this user is an atheist" userboxes at that website. With no evidence or explanation, User:C concluded that User:BS "had lied" at CP, and was a parodist. No mainspace or discussion page examples of parody were provided by User:C when asked. No evidence was produced to validate the claim that User:SC as RW 2.0 was indeed CP contributor User:BS. And no evidence was produced to support either claim the User:BS was either an atheist or a Christian, despite the fact CP does not have an ideological litmus test to register and account or contribute. |
| | + | |
| | + | '''[[Conservapedia:How_Conservapedia_Differs_from_Wikipedia]]''' specifically states, |
| | *11.We respect users' control over their own talk pages as much as possible. Wikipedia treats users' own talk pages like government or public property, and it becomes a place for Wikipedia editors to bully users. | | *11.We respect users' control over their own talk pages as much as possible. Wikipedia treats users' own talk pages like government or public property, and it becomes a place for Wikipedia editors to bully users. |
| | *15.We do not ban users based on their comments elsewhere, such as on their own blog. Wikipedia will monitor users' blogs and ban them for their exercise of free speech on their own blogs. | | *15.We do not ban users based on their comments elsewhere, such as on their own blog. Wikipedia will monitor users' blogs and ban them for their exercise of free speech on their own blogs. |
| − | '''[[Conservapedia:Guidelines#Duties]]''' specifiaclly sates, | + | '''[[Conservapedia:Guidelines#Duties]]''' specifically sates, |
| | *Unlike Wikipedia, we do not block for ideological reasons. | | *Unlike Wikipedia, we do not block for ideological reasons. |
| | | | |
| − | So, User:BS was blocked, evidently, for ideological views he expressed on another site, assuming the two are the same person. [[User:RobSmith|Rob Smith]] 14:11, 6 August 2011 (EDT) | + | So, User:BS was blocked, evidently, for ideological views he expressed on another site, assuming the two are the same person. [[User:RobSmith|Rob Smith]] 14:11, 6 August 2011 (EDT) |