| 1801–1804 |
William Cushing | William Paterson | Samuel Chase | Bushrod Washington | Alfred Moore
|
| 1804–1806 |
William Cushing | William Paterson | Samuel Chase | Bushrod Washington | William Johnson
|
| 1807–1810 |
William Cushing | Samuel Chase | Bushrod Washington | William Johnson | Henry B. Livingston | Thomas Todd
|
| 1810–1811 |
Samuel Chase | Bushrod Washington | William Johnson | Henry B. Livingston | Thomas Todd
|
| 1811–1812 |
Bushrod Washington | William Johnson | Henry B. Livingston | Thomas Todd | Gabriel Duvall
|
| 1812–1823 |
Bushrod Washington | William Johnson | Henry B. Livingston | Thomas Todd | Gabriel Duvall | Joseph Story
|
| 1823–1826 |
Bushrod Washington | William Johnson | Thomas Todd | Gabriel Duvall | Joseph Story | Smith Thompson
|
| 1826–1828 |
Bushrod Washington | William Johnson | Gabriel Duvall | Joseph Story | Smith Thompson | Robert Trimble
|
| 1828–1829 |
Bushrod Washington | William Johnson | Gabriel Duvall | Joseph Story | Smith Thompson
|
| 1830–1834 |
William Johnson | Gabriel Duvall | Joseph Story | Smith Thompson | John McLean | Henry Baldwin
|
| 1835 |
Gabriel Duvall | Joseph Story | Smith Thompson | John McLean | Henry Baldwin | James M. Wayne
|