| 1953–1954 |
Hugo Black | Stanley Reed | Felix Frankfurter | William O. Douglas | Robert H. Jackson | Harold Hitz Burton | Tom Clark | Sherman Minton
|
| 1955–1956 |
Hugo Black | Stanley Reed | Felix Frankfurter | William O. Douglas | Harold Hitz Burton | Tom Clark | Sherman Minton | John Harlan II
|
| 1956–1957 |
Hugo Black | Stanley Reed | Felix Frankfurter | William O. Douglas | Harold Hitz Burton | Tom Clark | John Harlan II | William Brennan
|
| 1957–1958 |
Hugo Black | Felix Frankfurter | William O. Douglas | Harold Hitz Burton | Tom Clark | John Harlan II | William Brennan | Charles E. Whittaker
|
| 1958–1962 |
Hugo Black | Felix Frankfurter | William O. Douglas | Tom Clark | John Harlan II | William Brennan | Charles E. Whittaker | Potter Stewart
|
| 1962–1965 |
Hugo Black | William O. Douglas | Tom Clark | John Harlan II | William Brennan | Potter Stewart | Byron White | Arthur Goldberg
|
| 1965–1967 |
Hugo Black | William O. Douglas | Tom Clark | John Harlan II | William Brennan | Potter Stewart | Byron White | Abe Fortas
|
| 1967–1969 |
Hugo Black | William O. Douglas | John Harlan II | William Brennan | Potter Stewart | Byron White | Abe Fortas | Thurgood Marshall
|