Henry George

From Conservapedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Henry George

Born September 2, 1839
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Died October 29, 1897
New York City
Spouse Annie Corsina Fox

Henry George (September 2, 1839 - October 29, 1897)[1] was an American economist who wrote one of the most widely read economic treatises in history: Progress and Poverty (1879). The thesis of the book is the proposal that all government revenue should come from a single tax on land. He argued that land, unlike other factors of production, is supplied by nature and that rent is unearned surplus. The landless deserve their share of this surplus as a birthright, according to George.

Early life

Henry George was born in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, on the 2nd of September 1839. He settled in California in 1858; then later removed to New York in 1880; was first a printer, then an editor, but finally devoted all his life to economic and social questions.

In 1860, George met Annie Corsina Fox. Her family was very opposed to the relationship, and in 1861 they eloped.[2]

Publishing career

In 1871 he published Our Land Policy, which, as further developed in 1879 under the title of Progress and Poverty, speedily attracted the widest attention both in America and in Europe. In 1886 he published Protection or Free Trade. Henry George had no political ambition, but in 1886 he received an independent nomination as mayor of New York City with the United Labor Party,[3] which was a creation of New York's Central Labor Union.[4]

Campaign for Mayor of New York

During his run to be Mayor of the City of New York, George became so popular that it required a coalition of the two strongest political parties to prevent his election. He received 68,000 votes, against 90,000 for the coalition candidate. During the campaign, he enjoyed the support of Samuel Gompers and the Knights of Labor.[5]


Single Tax

His doctrine may be condensed as follows: The land of every country belongs of right to all the people of that country. This right cannot be alienated by one generation, so as to affect the title of the next, any more than men can sell their yet unborn children for slaves. Private ownership of land has no more foundation in morality or reason than private ownership of air or sunlight. But the private occupancy and use of land are right and indispensable. Any attempt to divide land into equal shares is impossible and undesirable. Land should be, and practically is now, divided for private use in parcels among those who will pay the highest price for the use of each parcel. This price is now paid to some persons annually, and it is called rent.

By applying the rent of land, exclusive of all improvements, to the equal benefit of the whole community, absolute justice would be done to all. As rent is always more than sufficient to defray all necessary expenses of government, those expenses should be met by a tax upon rent alone, to be brought about by the gradual abolition of all other taxes. Landlords should be left in undisturbed possession and nominal ownership of the land, with a sufficient margin over the tax to induce them to collect their rents and pay the tax. They would thus be transformed into mere land agents. Obviously this would involve absolute free trade, since all taxes on imports, manufactures, successions, documents, personal property, buildings or improvements would disappear. Nothing made by man would be taxed at all. The right of private property in all things made by man would thus be absolute, for the owner of such things could not be divested of his property, without full compensation, even under the pretense of taxation. The idea of concentrating all taxes upon ground-rent has found followers in Great Britain, North America, Australia and New Zealand. In practical politics this doctrine is confined to the "Single Tax, Limited," which proposes to defray only the needful public expenses from ground-rent, leaving the surplus, whatever it may be, in the undisturbed possession of land-owners.

Land Nationalization

Henry George was known for his belief and agitation in favor of land nationalization.[6][7][8]


His death on the 29th of October 1897 was followed by one of the greatest demonstrations of popular feeling and general respect that ever attended the funeral of any strictly private citizen in American history. The fundamental doctrine of Henry George, the equal right of all men to the use of the earth, did not originate with him; but his clear statement of a method by which it could be enforced, without increasing state machinery, and indeed with a great simplification of government, gave it a new form. This method he named the Single Tax.

Ideological Influence

Henry George's ideology has been highly influential, and has been credited as a major part of the creation of the British Fabian Society,[9] as well as influencing the creation of The Landlord's Game, the predecessor to Monopoly (board game)[10] and the American Progressive movement.[11]

Archibald Henderson, George Bernard Shaw's biographer notes that Shaw credits George singly with his conversion to socialism.[12] At 15 years of age, Shaw was so profoundly impacted by Georgism that he studied Progress and Poverty, started attending meetings of the Social Democratic Federation, and later studied the works of Karl Marx.[12]

Terence V. Powderly, Grand Master Workman for the Knights of Labor said in 1882 that "the main, all-absorbing question of the hour is the land question."[13][14] In 1884, the Knights inserted a clause(iv) in its platform that called for "all lands now held for speculative purposes be taxed to their full value"[15] The book was particularly popular with workers and trades unionists because they felt that George was on their side.[16]

John Dewey described George as "one of the world's great social philosophers, certainly the greatest which this country has produced."[17] According to Daniel Bell, a former sociologist at Harvard, "Henry George stands paramount in the authentic tradition of the great agrarian reformers of the United States."[18][19] George also had a huge impact on William Simon U'Ren, who became active in the Single Tax movement using Initiative, Referendum, and Recall as a means to push the Single Tax agenda.[20]

George made significant inroads with Christians and the Social Gospel movement. Walter Rauschenbusch, one of the largest figures of the early 20th century Social Gospel movement,[19] was a strong believer. Father Edward McGlynn, one of the most popular and prominent Catholic priests of his day,[21] was excommunicated for his outspoken support of Georgism.[22][23] Margaret Sanger, who would have an affair with a member of the Fabian Society, H. G. Wells, was raised to parents who were fans of Henry George. Particularly her father Michael. One of her brothers was even named after him, Henry George McGlynn Higgins. The middle name of McGlynn is a reference to Father Edward.

George's ideas even found a home among Progressive Republicans in the early 20th century. Amos Pinchot, a member of the inner circle of the Bull Moose progressives, was an ardent Georgist.[24]


  • Progress and Poverty (1879)
  • The Irish Land Question (1881)
  • Social Problems (1884)
  • Protection or Free Trade (1886)
  • The Condition of Labor (1891)
  • A Perplexed Philosopher (1892)
  • Political Economy (1898)

See also


  1. The Illustrated American, Volume 22
  2. Henry George: Collected Journalistic Writings, Volume 1
  3. American Labor History Made Easy!
  4. Trade Unions and Community: The German Working Class in New York City, 1870-1900
  5. The Samuel Gompers Papers: The Early Years of the American Federation of Labor, 1887-90
  6. The Progress of Nationalism in the United States, Edward Bellamy
  7. Henry George's Legacy in Economic Thought, Land Taxation or Land Nationalization?
  8. Land-Value Taxation: The Equitable Source of Public Finance
  9. The History of the Fabian Society, Pease, Edward R. (1912)
  10. The scandal behind the anti-capitalist roots of Monopoly. New York Post (January 25, 2015).
  11. Henry George and the Beginnings of Revolutionary Socialism in the United States, The Johns Hopkins University Studies in Historical and Political Science
  12. 12.0 12.1 (1911) George Bernard Shaw, his life and works. Stewart & Kidd company, 96. 
  13. Thirty Years of Labor. 1859-1889
  14. The Single Tax Movement in the United States
  15. Annual Report of the Bureau of Labor and Industrial Statistics: 1885, Volume 1, Knights of Labor platform, Adopted September 10th, 1884
  16. The Forum, Volume 3, Henry George's Economic Heresies
  17. (2008) The Later Works, 1925-1953: 1933-1934. SIU Press, 302. 
  18. (1996) Marxian Socialism in the United States. Cornell University Press, 27. 
  19. 19.0 19.1 (1994) Origins of Walter Rauschenbusch's Social Ethics. McGill-Queen's Press - MQUP, 104. 
  20. Single Tax Conference, Held in New York City, November 19 and 20, 1910, Under the Auspices of the Joseph Fels Fund Commission, Volume 1
  21. Henry George Dr. Edward McGlynn & Pope Leo XIII
  22. Making the Irish American: History and Heritage of the Irish in the United States
  23. Race, Radicalism, Religion, and Restriction: Immigration in the Pacific Northwest, 1890-1924
  24. Reformers and War, American Progressive Publicists and the First World War

External links