Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 279: Line 279:     
::::So you are connecting the dots with the evidence, or making leaps of judgement and conclusions.  Sorry, but I'm pretty meticulous about historical methodology, and it's just become a habit of second nature of mine.  We are discussing three issues, (1) Pinochet's relationship to the Chilean government before and after the coup; (2) CIA involvement prior and after the coup; (3) "Many in the US protested" after the coup, although you '''''still''''' have not made clear '''what they protested''', what is (a) CIA invovlement, or (b) human rights abuses.  All three issues deserve treatment, however all three issues must be treated separately and cannot be used to confuse the known historical facts supported by three investigations and their publiched results. A further suggestion to clarify things, eleiniate this bogus, unsourcedm, without reference to a timeframe claim of anonymous "many in the US" and produce a specific cite, attributable to specific, reputable person of group with a specific date of thier "protest'.  [[User:RobS|RobS]] 22:22, 15 April 2007 (EDT)
 
::::So you are connecting the dots with the evidence, or making leaps of judgement and conclusions.  Sorry, but I'm pretty meticulous about historical methodology, and it's just become a habit of second nature of mine.  We are discussing three issues, (1) Pinochet's relationship to the Chilean government before and after the coup; (2) CIA involvement prior and after the coup; (3) "Many in the US protested" after the coup, although you '''''still''''' have not made clear '''what they protested''', what is (a) CIA invovlement, or (b) human rights abuses.  All three issues deserve treatment, however all three issues must be treated separately and cannot be used to confuse the known historical facts supported by three investigations and their publiched results. A further suggestion to clarify things, eleiniate this bogus, unsourcedm, without reference to a timeframe claim of anonymous "many in the US" and produce a specific cite, attributable to specific, reputable person of group with a specific date of thier "protest'.  [[User:RobS|RobS]] 22:22, 15 April 2007 (EDT)
 +
 +
::::::Are you, in all seriousness, denying that Pinochet took over hours after the coup? That he was not in charge when Victor Jara was murdered? Whose forces arrested Jara then? Who tortured him? Who shot him? --PF Fox 22:18, 15 April 2007 (EDT)
679

edits

Navigation menu