Debate: Is there a biblical basis for soul sleep

From Conservapedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

I notice that while Catholics and mainline Protestants traditionally differ on theology drastically, they seem to be united in contempt for the teachings of Seventh-day Adventism, one of the being soul sleep. If one searches up "soul sleep" on the internet, the results will mostly be filled with dozens upon dozens of pages claiming to refute the doctrine that souls sleep in the grave unconscious after death until the resurrections (one for the saved and one for the damned).

I've examined Bible verses cited by both sides of the debate to justify their arguments, and the Seventh-day Adventists, from my observations, have provided a more compelling case. Over and over, death is described as a sleep in the Bible, and I find it odd that "biblical literalists" insist the term "sleep" doesn't refer to actual unconscious sleep.

There will probably be other fellow Conservapedia users who disagree, and I hope to spark a meaningful discussion with this debate page. Would anyone else like to point to a few Bible verses which give the appearance of either substantiating or refuting soul sleep? —LT (The Old Right was right!) Tuesday, 20:59, November 28, 2022 (EST)

  • The word of God is piercing to the dividing asunder of soul and spirit.
  • Ye must be spiritually born.
  • To be carnally minded is death.
  • The carnal mind is enmity with God, is not subject to God, nor indeed can be.
RobSGive Peace a chance 12:34, November 29, 2022 (EST)
The spirit gives life. RobSGive Peace a chance 12:36, November 29, 2022 (EST)
Yes, it's true that salvation ensures eternal life, though eternal life begins once we go to Heaven. I believe Scripture still makes it clear that the dead sleep in the grave until the resurrections? (one for the saved at Christ's return, and the second one 1,000 years later for the damned) —LT (The Old Right was right!) Tuesday, 12:38, November 29, 2022 (EST)
"eternal life begins once we go to Heaven"
Bzzzt. Wrong.
"whoever hears my word and believes him who sent me has [present tense] eternal life. He does not come into judgment, but has passed [past tense] from death to life. (John 5:24).
RobSGive Peace a chance 12:43, November 29, 2022 (EST)
If a person has the conscious choice and free will to accept God's grace, they have the same will to turn away from it. So long as people are in the flesh, they must persistently be vigilant in maintaining their salvation (and pleading God to blot out their conscious sins). Eternal life cannot begin while one is alive in this mortal realm because we must die and perish for the first time. Of course, the debate over eternal security is best reserved for a separate debate page on that particular doctrine, since this one is about soul sleep. As for John 5:24, it's obvious that eternal life begins for the saved after they die (or, for those alive when Christ returns, being brought to Heaven). The death they do not face is the second death. —LT (The Old Right was right!) Tuesday, 12:49, November 29, 2022 (EST)
"Eternal life cannot begin while one is alive."
Ok, you made your point. You reject the word of God. Not much more to discuss. You are under law. RobSGive Peace a chance 13:20, November 29, 2022 (EST)
RobSmith, you are misinterpreting the verse you cite. If eternal life begins at some point in a person's lifetime while on the earth, that would mean a) they are already immortal, and b) there's eternal security. Both are untrue. Except for those brought directly to Heaven (or, in the case of Jesus, He ascended there Himself), everyone in this mortal realm will die. (how can one have eternal life if they die?) As for eternal security, there's numerous Bible verses debunking it. I hope you read the Gospels to understand the messages Jesus preaches? —LT (The Old Right was right!) Tuesday, 15:46, November 29, 2022 (EST)
The spirit of God is eternal, and we are partakers of that spirit. "For the preaching of the cross is to them that perish foolishness; but unto us which are [present tense] saved it is the power of God.
Digression: Now recent translations have changed "them that perish" to "them that are perishing"; I suppose the intention is to convey the idea that there still is time for "them that perish" to repent while still in the flesh. Either way, it does not change the meaning. "Let the dead bury the dead". But we that are saved are inheritors of eternal life while still in the flesh. RobSGive Peace a chance 16:52, November 29, 2022 (EST)
In Genesis, God said, "In the day you eat of it ye shall surely die." Guess what? They didn't die in the flesh that day. So what does God mean by "death"? Answer: Separation. Separation from God. "Let the separated from God bury the corpse." That was Jesus's meaning. To have "eternal life" is to be united, or re-united, with God. You do not have to be a corpse to have eternal life. A person spared from God's judgement (i.e. "saved" from judgement) is a partaker of (or with) God's spirit. RobSGive Peace a chance 16:58, November 29, 2022 (EST)
I hope you're not implying that "death isn't real death" as most Christian denominations unfortunately insinuate in insisting that Hell burns forever and ever. The first lie in humanity, uttered by Satan that "you won't surely die," has simply been remodeled into "you don't really die in Hell, but simply are tormented forever." If the doomed are eternally tormented consciously, then they have immortality. And what does the Bible say? The Gospel of Matthew:
“ And do not fear those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. Rather fear him who can destroy both soul and body in hell. ”

—Matthew 10:28

It's very straightforward: the lost are permanently destroyed. Here's another insightful verse to examine:
“ ...just as Sodom and Gomorrah and the surrounding cities, which likewise indulged in sexual immorality and pursued unnatural desire, serve as an example by undergoing a punishment of eternal fire. ”

—Jude 1:7

Sodom and Gomorrah stopped burning a long, long time ago. The word eternal refers to the effects of the fire, because the cities are eternally destroyed. Likewise, when the Bible describes hellfire as eternal, it's not the fires themselves that burn forever, rather the effects of hellfire that last forever: the lost are simply annihilated. If one denies this, then there's the words of the Book of Revelation:
“ He will wipe away every tear from their eyes, and death shall be no more, neither shall there be mourning, nor crying, nor pain anymore, for the former things have passed away. ”

—Revelation 21:4

How can the righteous who inherit God's kingdom have no mourning or crying if there's endless pain being cried out by the unrighteous being tormented in agonizing for all of eternity? God's will is not to endlessly torment those who fall short of being saved. Those who reject God are doomed to death, plain and simple. For more information, this sermon by Doug Batchelor is beyond excellent. Of course, this topic is best reserved for a separate debate page. —LT (The Old Right was right!) Wednesday, 22:14, November 29, 2022 (EST)
Okay, man has a spirit, too. Christians are partakers of God's spirit. The prideful don't need God's spirit. Depart from me. I never knew ye. So they, their spirits that is - not their "souls" cause they lost that when they lost life in the flesh - become eternally separated and live in outer darkness with each other, segregated from God's children (like sheep and goats or wheat and chaff), where they get to torment each other, and feel tormented themselves, and live in pride forever. RobSGive Peace a chance 16:19, November 30, 2022 (EST)


It is not your soul that needs saving, it is your spirit. You need a clean spirit. The spirit gives life.
Psalm 89:48. 48 What man is he that liveth, and shall not see death? shall he deliver his soul from the hand of the grave?
fear him who can destroy both soul and body
Both will be destroyed. And it's God who is the one who will do it.
piercing even to the dividing asunder of soul and spirit
The spirit is eternal. Ye must be spiritually born. Get off thus "soul" donkey. It's a dead end. RobSGive Peace a chance 07:14, November 30, 2022 (EST)
The spirit is eternal? I'd like to see a Bible verse substantiating that notion. Last I checked, death denial originated with Satan telling Eve, "you will not surely die." —LT (The Old Right was right!) Wednesday, 15:05, November 30, 2022 (EST)
God is Spirit Jn 4:24
they that worship him must worship him in spirit and in truth, also Jn 4:24
the Father seeketh such to worship him Jn 4:23
He hath given us of his spirit 1 Jn 4:13
RobSGive Peace a chance 15:27, November 30, 2022 (EST)
the words that I speak unto you, they are spirit, and they are life
RobSGive Peace a chance 15:34, November 30, 2022 (EST)
So how do these verses provide the case that the lost will eternally be consciously tormented? —LT (The Old Right was right!) Wednesday, 15:36, November 30, 2022 (EST)
Well, if you want to be eternally separated from God (death), go ahead and do that. It's your choice. The conscious, eternal torment is being (or knowing) you are eternally separated from God (without recourse).
Put another way, knowing you are eternally separated from God's love. RobSGive Peace a chance 15:45, November 30, 2022 (EST)
God is love; God is also light. Contrary to popular myth, hell is not flames and fire; hell is an extremely cold place in outer darkness where there is no light. RobSGive Peace a chance 15:48, November 30, 2022 (EST)
Back when I believed that Hell was eternal, I similarly thought that the common depiction of a endless burning didn't make much sense, since it's meant to be a place of permanent isolation from God's warmth. Of course, you have yet to provide sound biblical evidence that the lost just consciously suffer endlessly. The Bible says over and over that the lost perish, and, simply put, die. They are destroyed. —LT (The Old Right was right!) Wednesday, 15:53, November 30, 2022 (EST)
Yes, fear him who can destroy both body and soul (basically, it's a warning to repent and become a partaker of God's spirit). That's why I said you're barking up the wrong tree with this "soul" stuff. Your life in the body, or your soul in the body, will end. But the spirit is eternal and gives life. Those without God's spirit in this life or the next, suffer eternal torment. RobSGive Peace a chance 16:01, November 30, 2022 (EST)
According to the Book of Revelation:
“ He will wipe away every tear from their eyes, and death shall be no more, neither shall there be mourning, nor crying, nor pain anymore, for the former things have passed away. ”

—Revelation 21:4

How can there be no more pain, crying, suffering, and mourning if the lost are endlessly in torment? Not all among the lost are those who lived consciously malicious lives such as persistent militant atheists; some may be teenagers who lived a life of despair and committed suicide after reaching the age of accountability. If even those individuals are tormented eternally, then how will the righteous in the kingdom of God not be mourning in sorrow? —LT (The Old Right was right!) Wednesday, 16:06, November 30, 2022 (EST)
Okay, man has a spirit. Christians are partakers of God's spirit. The prideful don't need God. Depart from me. I never knew ye. So those spirits which rejected God (and have already lost their souls when they lost life in the body) get to live in outer darkness eternally and torment each other while feeling tormented themselves missing out. RobSGive Peace a chance 16:27, November 30, 2022 (EST)


In the beginning was the Word (Gr. logos), and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.
Note: Chronologically speaking, this is the first verse of the Bible. While Gen. 1:1 begins, "In the beginning God created" speaks of God's actions, John 1:1 tells us what existed before that. RobSGive Peace a chance 15:40, November 30, 2022 (EST)

A sound proof that souls sleep after death: Jesus said so!

In the Gospel of Matthew:

“ While he was saying these things to them, behold, a ruler came in and knelt before him, saying, “My daughter has just died, but come and lay your hand on her, and she will live.” And Jesus rose and followed him, with his disciples. And behold, a woman who had suffered from a discharge of blood for twelve years came up behind him and touched the fringe of his garment, for she said to herself, “If I only touch his garment, I will be made well.” Jesus turned, and seeing her he said, “Take heart, daughter; your faith has made you well.” And instantly the woman was made well. And when Jesus came to the ruler’s house and saw the flute players and the crowd making a commotion, he said, “Go away, for the girl is not dead but sleeping.” And they laughed at him. But when the crowd had been put outside, he went in and took her by the hand, and the girl arose. And the report of this went through all that district. ”

—Matthew 9:18–26

Notice what Jesus said? The dead girl is merely sleeping. If one believes in soul sleep, it makes perfect since: if death is a sleep, then the dead girl is simply sleeping in the grave unconscious, and when he revived her, she simply woke up.

If you don't believe that death is a sleep and instead promote the idea that people face judgment immediately after death, then there would come the conclusion that the girl died, faced judgment, presumably was brought to either Heaven or Hell, and then got yanked out of Heaven or Hell when brought back to life on the earth. That wouldn't make much sense, would it? —LT (The Old Right was right!) Tuesday, 12:58, November 29, 2022 (EST)

I don't see what your point is, or how you manage a doctrine out of it. So your argument is that cremated bodies are sleeping. Big deal. RobSGive Peace a chance 13:17, November 29, 2022 (EST)
It's important to understand the Bible's messages properly so one is not led astray by false teachings. My point is that it makes no sense for the dead girl to have been judged, gone to either Heaven or Hell, and then suddenly got yanked out back into the earth. And yet, that's the conclusion arrived if one denies soul sleep and instead believes in immediate judgment after death. What do most Christian denominations say about soul sleep currently? The vast majority deny it, and thus their doctrines lead to all sorts of bizarre nonsensical conclusions. —LT (The Old Right was right!) Tuesday, 15:49, November 29, 2022 (EST)
Sorry. I don't see any of that in this passage. RobSGive Peace a chance 16:52, November 29, 2022 (EST)
Not to sidetrack the discussion, but by this non-biblical or extra-biblical definition of "soul sleep", a person under anesthesia is in soul sleep. RobSGive Peace a chance 17:12, November 29, 2022 (EST)
How is this non-biblical to begin with? Look at the passage above I cited; Jesus Himself says, "the girl is not dead but sleeping." How much more obvious could it get? —LT (The Old Right was right!) Wednesday, 22:02, November 29, 2022 (EST)
Also, while all that might not be fully elaborated in this passage alone I cited above, hopefully you read the Bible through and through sufficiently to have noticed the passages describing death as a sleep. —LT (The Old Right was right!) Wednesday, 22:18, November 29, 2022 (EST)
I can answer that, but we're just not there yet. Presumably you're speaking about those asleep in the Lord, meaning they will not suffer the second death (eternal separation from God). RobSGive Peace a chance 15:56, November 30, 2022 (EST)
Well, whether saved or lost, the dead sleep in the grave until the resurrection they will be raised up in. —LT (The Old Right was right!) Wednesday, 15:58, November 30, 2022 (EST)
You got the timeline screwed up. Go back to John 5:24 - you are resurrected to life the minute you believeth on him who sent me. RobSGive Peace a chance 16:04, November 30, 2022 (EST)
Eternal life means eternal, and therefore by assuming that a saved person will be absolutely guaranteed a place in Heaven upon repentance while still in the flesh, it relies on the premise of eternal security, which the Bible debunks. —LT (The Old Right was right!) Wednesday, 16:11, November 30, 2022 (EST)
To put it naively - and I'm sure you've heard it a thousand times - to be born again is to be resurrected from death to life.
That may sound redundant to a lot of people (since their ears are dull of hearing). Nevertheless, it's true. RobSGive Peace a chance 16:08, November 30, 2022 (EST)
And the resurrection from death to life for the saved will occur... at the first resurrection when Christ returns. Not while one is still in the flesh. —LT (The Old Right was right!) Wednesday, 16:13, November 30, 2022 (EST)
Okay, deny the word of God (Jn 5:24, etc). Each word shall be held to account. RobSGive Peace a chance 16:23, November 30, 2022 (EST)
I simply differ with your interpretation of the verse which leads to bizarre conclusions. —LT (The Old Right was right!) Wednesday, 16:25, November 30, 2022 (EST)
The word of God is foolishness to them that perish or are perishing. Take your pick which translation you like. RobSGive Peace a chance 16:30, November 30, 2022 (EST)

Arguments against soul sleep

"You have made known to me the path of life; You will fill me with joy in Your presence, with eternal pleasures at Your right hand (Psalm 16:11)." The people in heaven are in a state of joy and not in a state of sleep. "Closing his psalm, David thanks the Lord for showing him the way of life that leads to heaven. There is nothing drab or boring about heaven. It is a place of fullness of joy and unending delights. The greatest joy comes from being in Jesus' presence."[1]

"They called out in a loud voice, "How long, Sovereign Lord, holy and true, until you judge the inhabitants of the earth and avenge our blood?" (Revelation 6:10)." These departed saints are awake and not sleeping.

From the account that Jesus gave of the rich man and Lazarus (Luke 16:19-31) we discover that unbelievers are also conscious when they are dead.[2]

During the transfiguration of Jesus, Moses and Elijah appear. There is no mention of them being awoken from some soul sleep "hibernation". Admittedly, this is an argument from silence which are not the strongest arguments when it comes to historical matters.

In 1 Samuel 28, Samuel comes back to earth after dying too.

Also, consider this verse of the Bible For Christ also suffered once for sins, the just for the unjust, that He might bring us to God, being put to death in the flesh but made alive by the Spirit, by whom also He went and preached to the spirits in prison (1 Peter 3:18,19). You can't preach to departed people who are sleeping. And why would Jesus preach to angels who have already not fallen or fallen (As in fallen angels).

"Are they not all ministering spirits sent forth to minister to those who will inherit salvation (Hebrews 1:14)." Both God and the angels are awake. Why should the departed saints in heaven be any different? Conservative (talk) 17:11, November 30, 2022 (EST)

Addressing the Lazarus argument

Let's carefully examine the passage in the Gospel of Luke:

“ There was a rich man who was clothed in purple and fine linen and who feasted sumptuously every day. And at his gate was laid a poor man named Lazarus, covered with sores, who desired to be fed with what fell from the rich man's table. Moreover, even the dogs came and licked his sores. The poor man died and was carried by the angels to Abraham's side. The rich man also died and was buried, and in Hades, being in torment, he lifted up his eyes and saw Abraham far off and Lazarus at his side. And he called out, ‘Father Abraham, have mercy on me, and send Lazarus to dip the end of his finger in water and cool my tongue, for I am in anguish in this flame.’ But Abraham said, ‘Child, remember that you in your lifetime received your good things, and Lazarus in like manner bad things; but now he is comforted here, and you are in anguish. And besides all this, between us and you a great chasm has been fixed, in order that those who would pass from here to you may not be able, and none may cross from there to us.’ And he said, ‘Then I beg you, father, to send him to my father's house—for I have five brothers—so that he may warn them, lest they also come into this place of torment.’ But Abraham said, ‘They have Moses and the Prophets; let them hear them.’ And he said, ‘No, father Abraham, but if someone goes to them from the dead, they will repent.’ He said to him, ‘If they do not hear Moses and the Prophets, neither will they be convinced if someone should rise from the dead.’ ”

—Luke 16:19–31

First of all, this is a parable using symbolisms. The rich man represents the Pharisees who are selfish and arrogant, while Lazarus represents Gentiles who seek the truth. The lesson is not even about the timing of judgment after death, as it's instead a warning to the Pharisees and scribes who are in the false illusion of preserving God's commandments. Note that the parable uses "Hades," a Greek pagan concept, rather than "hell."

Secondly, it doesn't even clarify that Lazarus and the rich man wake up immediately after death concurrent with a consistent timeline. For more information, see here, plus this sermon by Doug Batchelor. —LT (The Old Right was right!) Wednesday, 17:40, November 30, 2022 (EST)

(cont.) The problem with taking the parable literally

Now, I can fully see how people think the parable implies immediate judgment after death; when Lazarus and the rich man die, at the time of the rich man's torment, he says to Abraham that his brothers are still alive on the Earth. Therefore, it naturally implies that they are already individually judged before the second return of Christ, since there's still people alive on the planet in the flesh. Therefore, if you take the parable literally, you come to the conclusion that there's immediate judgment, and that there's almost a "temporary" heaven and hell before the Final Judgment.

But... hold on, to reiterate, Jesus in that parable used the word "Hades." And everyone back in His day who heard the parable, just as everyone nowadays should comprehend, Hades is a concept from pagan Greek mythology. So if you take the parable literally, that means that you come to the conclusion of pagan Greek mythology being directly relevant to what the Bible (specifically, Jesus) says about happens after one dies, which... doesn't sound right. And that's not all. Note that in the important part in the parable, the rich man, suffering in "Hades," is directly talking to Abraham, who's evidently in the kingdom of God. So if it's to be taken literally, do people in a "temporary hell" have direct communication with those in a "temporary heaven"? There's absolutely no Scripture directly substantiating this in any way. It's just like the doctrine of Purgatory: based on contorted interpretations. (yes, I once defended the notion of Purgatory, though that was before I deeply analyzed Scripture)

Nothing about Lazarus and the rich man is about whether judgment is immediate, and about whether there's a temporary hell and heaven. It's a warning against the Pharisees' and scribes' rejection of Jesus, part of it being that they will ultimately find themselves on the outside while Abraham and the Old Testament prophets (who the Pharisees and scribes think they are fulfilling the intentions of) are on the inside. To properly understand the parable, one must think about the true emphasis Jesus is placing.

Not every Bible verse is to be taken at literal face value. Each is to be understood in their respective proper context. As I increasingly ponder about what Scripture is truly saying, it seems that Calvinist teachings are derived from a literal interpretation of parables and the following conclusions that result from such "biblical literalism." —LT (Exodus 23:2) Monday, 16:31, December 26, 2022 (EST)

There are multiple teachings in this parable. Using scripture to interpret scripture, I think Romans chapt 7 is a good starting point to unravel it. [3] RobSGive Peace a chance 18:22, December 26, 2022 (EST)
But let me back up; once again I'm going to point to Romans 5:7, Death reigned from Adam to Moses, and ask 'Did the Law bring life, or did Jesus Christ?' RobSGive Peace a chance 18:52, December 26, 2022 (EST)
<In context, we are trying to understand ‘If they do not hear Moses and the Prophets, neither will they be convinced if someone should rise from the dead.’> RobSGive Peace a chance 18:54, December 26, 2022 (EST)
So Paul addresses this question at length, beginning at verse 9 in chapt 7 until the end: For I was alive without the law once (i.e. before he heard Moses and the Prophets): but when the commandment came, sin revived, and I died.
Now there may be some extraneous material between verse 9 and the end to some readers, but we can go over it all if need be. RobSGive Peace a chance 19:08, December 26, 2022 (EST)
Retrieved from "https://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=Debate:_Is_there_a_biblical_basis_for_soul_sleep&oldid=1916647"