Difference between revisions of "Yahweh"

From Conservapedia
Jump to: navigation, search
(bolding hebrew since it illustrates a point here)
(i bet yo gonna love dis shit)
Line 1: Line 1:
 +
[[File:Tetragrammaton a.jpg|thumb|right|165px|God's name is a four-letter word...]]
 +
{{biblenav}}
 +
<s>Yevon</s> '''YHWH''' ('''Yahweh''', '''Jehovah''' or '''יהוה''') is the written name for the [[monotheistic]] [[God]] that the [[Jew]]s and [[Christian]]s would later worship.  YHWH is not, in fact, the 'name' of a god, but a name that is used to prevent violation of certain commandments.
 +
 +
The common rendering of ''YHWH'' is sometimes called the "tetragrammaton" (which is [[Greek]] for "a word of four letters").
 +
 +
==Tetragrammaton==
 +
===Etymology===
 +
There are several views of what YHWH means and where the term originated.  The most commonly accepted is that the term comes from "Y" (Hebrew yodh י) meaning "he," and the Proto-Semitic root "HWY," (> Hebrew: he waw he  היה
 +
) which means either "to be" or "to create" depending on context, mode and inflection, making YHWH "He who is" or alternately "He who [[Creator|creates]]."  In {{bible|Exodus|3|14}}, God states, in response to the question "who are you, that should send me to the people of [[Israel]]?" -  "Ehyeh asher ehyeh" "I am what I am." In context, the word "YHWH" could also mean "He who builds".
 +
 +
Without vowels, both scholars of the Bible and linguists can only guess on the variation of the root HWY. Root HWY resembles somewhat another root ḤWY (> Hebrew חוה ḥet waw he) "to live", which yields Canaanite "Ḥawwat", the original form of Hebrew "Ḥawwah" & [[Eve]].
 +
 +
A second theory is based on the [[Linguistics|linguistic]] [[evidence]] that the Semitic tri-root "HWY" indicates "to blow, to fall". This argument suggests YHWH might be indicating at a Storm God, as YHWH, the imperfect causative third-person, would mean "he causes to blow [the wind] ~ he causes to fall [the rain & lightning]".  This would blend with the theory that YHWH was an Edomic Storm God who was adopted into the Canaanite [[culture]].
 +
 +
===Pronunciation===
 +
The original pronunciation is lost to [[history]], because the Hebrew Bible contains no vowels, and of course those who would have known the pronunciation are long gone.  Further, it was historically considered disrespectful to speak God's name, outside of the most sacred of settings.  Even today, conservative and [[Orthodox Judaism|Orthodox Jews]] generally do not use His name, as they consider it very holy to even pronounce, while the Christians mostly refer to Him as "the LORD".<ref name="jps">Ronald L. Eisenberg. ''The JPS Guide to Jewish Traditions'', p627. Jewish Publication Society of America. 2004.</ref>
 +
 +
In practical terms, the pronunciation is probably ''Yahweh'' (the cognate ''yahwiyu'' is still attested in Arabic; coupled with the sound-correspondence ''-iyu'' to ''-eh'') or something fairly similar, and this is the usual translation into [[English]].
 +
 +
To avoid speaking God's name, because that's disrespectful, when [[Jew]]s read the Hebrew scriptures aloud in prayer, the four letters are pronounced mainly as ''Adonai'' (my [[lord]]), but also as ''[[El]]ohim'' (god'''''s''''' - in plural, singular "El") in a few cases. Taking the [[taboo]] even further, some conservative and Orthodox Jews simply call God "HaShem," literally meaning "the name."<ref name="jps"/> Another common Jewish practice, especially among English-speaking Orthodox, is to write the English name '"God" as ''G-d''.
 +
 +
===English translation===
 +
Most English [[Bible translations]] represent YHWH as ''"the <span style="font-variant:small-caps;">Lord</span>"'' (in small capitals when it stands in for YHWH) and ''"Lord <span style="font-variant:small-caps;">God"</span>'' or ''"The Sovereign <span style="font-variant:small-caps;">Lord</span>"'' (when it is "YHWH Adonai").
 +
 +
The translation as '''YHVH''' is no longer used. It is commonly believed that "ו" has shifted from "weh" to "veh" over the past several thousand years. (That, plus the fact that the ancient [[Roman]]s pronounced "V" like a W.)
 +
 +
===Jehovah v. YaHeWeHe===
 +
An earlier, less accurate English rendition of the name is ''Jehovah'', which was formed by a combination of the consonants YHWH and the cantillation marks (vowels) for "Adonai" (that's where the "o" comes from), as the word was written in the Tanakh, so that even the most absent-minded Jew wouldn't pronounce the Sacred Name and be [[Examples of God personally killing people|Struck Down in Flame]]. The "Y" became "J" and "W" became "V" because those were the letters that ancient [[Latin]] used to represent those sounds.<ref group=note>If you want to split hairs, ancient Latin didn't actually have a letter shaped like J -- it used a written I for both the long I vowel sound and the short Y sound.  Later Latin scholars invented J as a way to distinguish between these two sounds.</ref> Despite the sound changes in French that caused English J and V to sound nothing like their Latin ancestors, this doggedly incorrect transliteration is still used by certain [[tradition]]alist groups and [[Jehovah's Witnesses]].
 +
 +
Though "Jehovah" is generally found in English-speaking Christian groups, it can sometimes be found in English-speaking Jewish [[sect]]s as well.
 +
 +
Jehovah's Witnesses insist Jehovah is God's real name, or at least as close to it as "[[Jesus]]" is to the original Hebrew. They insist on using this name to distinguish him from what they call false gods.  There are also some sects, including many [[Christian Identity]] believers, who insist that "Yahweh" is the proper name.
 +
 +
==YHWH the god==
 +
Evidence from [[Archaeology|archaeological]] excavations (in the [[Douglas Adams]]ian tradition of "The Institute of Taking Impossibly Long Times to Find Out What's Painfully Obvious," as even a cursory reading of the millennia-old Tanakh or [[Old Testament]] with a right mind &mdash; although we're not sure how often that happens) strongly suggests that YHWH wasn't the ''only'' God, just one that Abraham promised to worship so he could take all of [[Palestine]], put the men [[Murder|to the sword]], the towns [[Arson|to the torch]], and the women [[Sex|to bed]]. The deal also included [[Sacrifice|sacrificing]] the good stuff &mdash; the [[gold]], silver, [[wine]], and [[animal]]s &mdash; to the <span style="font-variant:small-caps;">Lord</span>, i.e. making His [[priest]]s rich.
 +
 +
Evidences found in the Canaanite city of Ugarit suggests the ancient Israelites practiced a [[Polytheism|polytheistic]] North-west Semitic religion, with a creator god, ''El''.  Yahweh was associated with El, and became the "national god" of the Hebrews.  There is some evidence of a god "YW" who was the Son of El; YW is generally considered to either be YHWH or be some play on words to make a closer association. El (and therefor YHWH) had a wife, incidentally named [[Asherah]]) &mdash; amazingly the [[Mormon]]s got it right for once, and we'll all get our own [[planet]] called The ''Battlestar Galactica'', from which [[human]]s will evolve in to Cylons and found the Twelve Colonies of Man, and revert to polytheism.
 +
 +
Because YHWH so obviously made such a lousy cosmic protector, killing his own vassals with [[plague]]s, [[Hell]]fire and brimstone, His patron kingdoms being ground into dust by the Assyrians and whatnot, He was beefed up by a merger with El, making Him not only the particular God of the Hebrews but also THE MOST POWERFUL GOD IN THE COSMOS.  It's quite clear through even a cursory reading of the Old Testament (e.g. the [[Ten Commandments|First Commandment]]) that even then the Israelites did not consider Yahweh to be the only god, merely the most important one. Needless to say that He's frequently mentioned in plural (Elohim), and the single-most repeated phrase in the Old Testament is, "I am the YHWH your Elohim, the El of Abraham, [[Isaac]], and [[Jacob]]."
 +
 +
YHWH [[Amalekites|appears]] [[Deluge|to]] [[Sodom and Gomorrah|be]] [[Abortion|pro-choice]].
 +
 +
==YHWH and his Wives==
 +
[[File:Danseuse Arabe.jpg|thumb|right|200px|One of Yahweh's harem girls?]]
 +
In ancient Israel Yahweh was indeed worshipped alongside Asherah, and both archeological evidence as well as with biblical evidence confirms this. <ref>https://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/biblical-sites-places/puzzling-finds-from-kuntillet-ajrud%E2%80%94a-drawing-of-god-labeled-yahweh-and-his-asherah-or-the-egyptian-god-bes/</ref> <ref>https://www.seeker.com/gods-wife-edited-out-of-the-bible-almost-1766083399.html</ref> <ref>http://www.ancientpages.com/2017/04/12/ancient-yahweh-asherah-inscriptions-kuntillet-ajrud-remain-unsolved-biblical-mystery/</ref> <ref>https://www.blueletterbible.org/search/search.cfm?Criteria=Asherah&t=NKJV#s=s_primary_0_1</ref> To further elaborate, Asherah was a mother goddess in the ancient Semitic religion, identified as the queen consort of the Sumerian god Anu, and Ugaritic El, and Yahweh, the god of Israel and Judah.
 +
 +
But according to Psalms chapter 45, Yahweh/Elohim had many more bed partners to [[Sex|play with]]. The writer of this poem assures the reader that he/she isn't referring to David, but Elohim, who can pretty much be equated with Yahweh. The chapter from verse 6 onward runs thusly-
 +
 +
 +
45:6 ''Thy throne, O Elohim, is forever and ever: the scepter of thy kingdom is a right scepter.''
 +
 +
45:7 ''Thou lovest righteousness, and hatest wickedness: therefore Elohim, thy Elohim, hath anointed thee with the oil of gladness above thy fellows''
 +
 +
45:8 ''All thy garments smell of myrrh, and aloes, and cassia, out of the ivory palaces, whereby they have made thee glad.''
 +
 +
45:9 ''King's daughters are among thy honorable women, upon thy right hand did stand the queen in gold of Ophir.
 +
 +
45:10 ''Hearken, O daughter, and consider, and incline thine ear; forget also thine own people, and thy father's house.''
 +
 +
45:11 ''So shall the king greatly desire thy beauty: for he is thy Adonim; and worship thou him.'' <ref>http://qbible.com/hebrew-old-testament/psalms/45.html</ref>
 +
 +
 +
Ellicott's Commentary for English Readers has commented on verse 9 saying, ''(9) Honourable women.--Literally, precious ones, i.e., possibly the favourites of the harem.'' <ref>http://biblehub.com/psalms/45-9.htm</ref> Anyway, maybe these women of God had more charms to offer than Asherah, and that's why they weren't edited out of the Bible.
 +
 +
As with many other controversial chapters from the Bible it should be noted that there are numerous interpretations on this poem. Franz Delitzsch argued that the poem was written on the occasion of Jehoram of Judah's marriage with Athaliah, while Alexander Kirkpatrick maintained that it referred rather to the marriage of Solomon with an Egyptian princess. The psalm has frequently been interpreted as a Messianic prophecy. In Hebrews 1:8-9, verses 6-7 are quoted as allusions to Jesus, and among Jews as well the king has been identified with the Messiah and the bride with Israel.
 +
The verse marking for this psalm in the Revised Standard Version (RSV) differs from that used in other translations.
 +
The most controversial passage is verse 7, traditionally translated "thy throne, O god, is for ever and ever," because it seems as if the poet is addressing the king as "god," which is theologically problematic (since after all God can't have sexy women, right?) . Alternate translations include "your divine throne endures for ever and ever" and "the eternal and everlasting God has enthroned you." <ref>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psalm_45</ref> These alternate translations may be an attempt to erase any evidence that Yahweh had His own harem.
 +
 +
Anat, a West Semitic goddess of love and war <ref>https://www.britannica.com/topic/Anath</ref>, might also be a candidate for one of Yahweh's (presumably many) wives. Judges 5:6 mentions her, and Joseph's wife's name is told to be Asenath (''holy to Anath'') in Genesis 41:45.
 +
 +
==See also==
 +
*[[Gods Christians don't believe in]]
 +
*[[YMCA]]
 +
*[[Trinity]]
 +
*[[Allah]]
 +
 +
==Notes==
 +
{{reflist|group=note}}
 +
 +
==References==
 +
{{reflist}}
 +
 +
{{biblebox}}
 +
 +
[[Category:Biblical figures]]
 +
[[Category:Christian mythology]]
 +
[[Category:Deities]]
 +
[[Category:Euphemisms]]
 +
 +
 +
 
'''Yahweh''' is an Anglicized version of the Name of [[God]], as spoken during the time of the [[Temple of Jerusalem|Temple]] and understood by [[Judaism]] and [[Christianity]] as taught in the [[Old Testament]] or the [[Bible]]. In [[Hebrew]], The Name is written using four consonants called the [[tetragrammaton]], but never spoken.
 
'''Yahweh''' is an Anglicized version of the Name of [[God]], as spoken during the time of the [[Temple of Jerusalem|Temple]] and understood by [[Judaism]] and [[Christianity]] as taught in the [[Old Testament]] or the [[Bible]]. In [[Hebrew]], The Name is written using four consonants called the [[tetragrammaton]], but never spoken.
 
{{language box
 
{{language box

Revision as of 06:58, February 27, 2018

File:Tetragrammaton a.jpg
God's name is a four-letter word...

Template:Biblenav Yevon YHWH (Yahweh, Jehovah or יהוה) is the written name for the monotheistic God that the Jews and Christians would later worship. YHWH is not, in fact, the 'name' of a god, but a name that is used to prevent violation of certain commandments.

The common rendering of YHWH is sometimes called the "tetragrammaton" (which is Greek for "a word of four letters").

Tetragrammaton

Etymology

There are several views of what YHWH means and where the term originated. The most commonly accepted is that the term comes from "Y" (Hebrew yodh י) meaning "he," and the Proto-Semitic root "HWY," (> Hebrew: he waw he היה ) which means either "to be" or "to create" depending on context, mode and inflection, making YHWH "He who is" or alternately "He who creates." In

800px-Crop Book of Isaiah 2006-06-06.jpg
Bible

Sections
Old Testament
New Testament
Pentateuch
The Gospels

About
History
Canon
Exegesis
Accuracy
Criticism
Inerrancy
Literalism
Chronology
Translations
Hermeneutics

Concepts
Sabbath
Sin
Resurrection
Prophet
The Virgin Birth
Tithe

See also
Christianity

, God states, in response to the question "who are you, that should send me to the people of Israel?" - "Ehyeh asher ehyeh" "I am what I am." In context, the word "YHWH" could also mean "He who builds".

Without vowels, both scholars of the Bible and linguists can only guess on the variation of the root HWY. Root HWY resembles somewhat another root ḤWY (> Hebrew חוה ḥet waw he) "to live", which yields Canaanite "Ḥawwat", the original form of Hebrew "Ḥawwah" & Eve.

A second theory is based on the linguistic evidence that the Semitic tri-root "HWY" indicates "to blow, to fall". This argument suggests YHWH might be indicating at a Storm God, as YHWH, the imperfect causative third-person, would mean "he causes to blow [the wind] ~ he causes to fall [the rain & lightning]". This would blend with the theory that YHWH was an Edomic Storm God who was adopted into the Canaanite culture.

Pronunciation

The original pronunciation is lost to history, because the Hebrew Bible contains no vowels, and of course those who would have known the pronunciation are long gone. Further, it was historically considered disrespectful to speak God's name, outside of the most sacred of settings. Even today, conservative and Orthodox Jews generally do not use His name, as they consider it very holy to even pronounce, while the Christians mostly refer to Him as "the LORD".[1]

In practical terms, the pronunciation is probably Yahweh (the cognate yahwiyu is still attested in Arabic; coupled with the sound-correspondence -iyu to -eh) or something fairly similar, and this is the usual translation into English.

To avoid speaking God's name, because that's disrespectful, when Jews read the Hebrew scriptures aloud in prayer, the four letters are pronounced mainly as Adonai (my lord), but also as Elohim (gods - in plural, singular "El") in a few cases. Taking the taboo even further, some conservative and Orthodox Jews simply call God "HaShem," literally meaning "the name."[1] Another common Jewish practice, especially among English-speaking Orthodox, is to write the English name '"God" as G-d.

English translation

Most English Bible translations represent YHWH as "the Lord" (in small capitals when it stands in for YHWH) and "Lord God" or "The Sovereign Lord" (when it is "YHWH Adonai").

The translation as YHVH is no longer used. It is commonly believed that "ו" has shifted from "weh" to "veh" over the past several thousand years. (That, plus the fact that the ancient Romans pronounced "V" like a W.)

Jehovah v. YaHeWeHe

An earlier, less accurate English rendition of the name is Jehovah, which was formed by a combination of the consonants YHWH and the cantillation marks (vowels) for "Adonai" (that's where the "o" comes from), as the word was written in the Tanakh, so that even the most absent-minded Jew wouldn't pronounce the Sacred Name and be Struck Down in Flame. The "Y" became "J" and "W" became "V" because those were the letters that ancient Latin used to represent those sounds.[note 1] Despite the sound changes in French that caused English J and V to sound nothing like their Latin ancestors, this doggedly incorrect transliteration is still used by certain traditionalist groups and Jehovah's Witnesses.

Though "Jehovah" is generally found in English-speaking Christian groups, it can sometimes be found in English-speaking Jewish sects as well.

Jehovah's Witnesses insist Jehovah is God's real name, or at least as close to it as "Jesus" is to the original Hebrew. They insist on using this name to distinguish him from what they call false gods. There are also some sects, including many Christian Identity believers, who insist that "Yahweh" is the proper name.

YHWH the god

Evidence from archaeological excavations (in the Douglas Adamsian tradition of "The Institute of Taking Impossibly Long Times to Find Out What's Painfully Obvious," as even a cursory reading of the millennia-old Tanakh or Old Testament with a right mind — although we're not sure how often that happens) strongly suggests that YHWH wasn't the only God, just one that Abraham promised to worship so he could take all of Palestine, put the men to the sword, the towns to the torch, and the women to bed. The deal also included sacrificing the good stuff — the gold, silver, wine, and animals — to the Lord, i.e. making His priests rich.

Evidences found in the Canaanite city of Ugarit suggests the ancient Israelites practiced a polytheistic North-west Semitic religion, with a creator god, El. Yahweh was associated with El, and became the "national god" of the Hebrews. There is some evidence of a god "YW" who was the Son of El; YW is generally considered to either be YHWH or be some play on words to make a closer association. El (and therefor YHWH) had a wife, incidentally named Asherah) — amazingly the Mormons got it right for once, and we'll all get our own planet called The Battlestar Galactica, from which humans will evolve in to Cylons and found the Twelve Colonies of Man, and revert to polytheism.

Because YHWH so obviously made such a lousy cosmic protector, killing his own vassals with plagues, Hellfire and brimstone, His patron kingdoms being ground into dust by the Assyrians and whatnot, He was beefed up by a merger with El, making Him not only the particular God of the Hebrews but also THE MOST POWERFUL GOD IN THE COSMOS. It's quite clear through even a cursory reading of the Old Testament (e.g. the First Commandment) that even then the Israelites did not consider Yahweh to be the only god, merely the most important one. Needless to say that He's frequently mentioned in plural (Elohim), and the single-most repeated phrase in the Old Testament is, "I am the YHWH your Elohim, the El of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob."

YHWH appears to be pro-choice.

YHWH and his Wives

File:Danseuse Arabe.jpg
One of Yahweh's harem girls?

In ancient Israel Yahweh was indeed worshipped alongside Asherah, and both archeological evidence as well as with biblical evidence confirms this. [2] [3] [4] [5] To further elaborate, Asherah was a mother goddess in the ancient Semitic religion, identified as the queen consort of the Sumerian god Anu, and Ugaritic El, and Yahweh, the god of Israel and Judah.

But according to Psalms chapter 45, Yahweh/Elohim had many more bed partners to play with. The writer of this poem assures the reader that he/she isn't referring to David, but Elohim, who can pretty much be equated with Yahweh. The chapter from verse 6 onward runs thusly-


45:6 Thy throne, O Elohim, is forever and ever: the scepter of thy kingdom is a right scepter.

45:7 Thou lovest righteousness, and hatest wickedness: therefore Elohim, thy Elohim, hath anointed thee with the oil of gladness above thy fellows

45:8 All thy garments smell of myrrh, and aloes, and cassia, out of the ivory palaces, whereby they have made thee glad.

45:9 King's daughters are among thy honorable women, upon thy right hand did stand the queen in gold of Ophir.

45:10 Hearken, O daughter, and consider, and incline thine ear; forget also thine own people, and thy father's house.

45:11 So shall the king greatly desire thy beauty: for he is thy Adonim; and worship thou him. [6]


Ellicott's Commentary for English Readers has commented on verse 9 saying, (9) Honourable women.--Literally, precious ones, i.e., possibly the favourites of the harem. [7] Anyway, maybe these women of God had more charms to offer than Asherah, and that's why they weren't edited out of the Bible.

As with many other controversial chapters from the Bible it should be noted that there are numerous interpretations on this poem. Franz Delitzsch argued that the poem was written on the occasion of Jehoram of Judah's marriage with Athaliah, while Alexander Kirkpatrick maintained that it referred rather to the marriage of Solomon with an Egyptian princess. The psalm has frequently been interpreted as a Messianic prophecy. In Hebrews 1:8-9, verses 6-7 are quoted as allusions to Jesus, and among Jews as well the king has been identified with the Messiah and the bride with Israel. The verse marking for this psalm in the Revised Standard Version (RSV) differs from that used in other translations. The most controversial passage is verse 7, traditionally translated "thy throne, O god, is for ever and ever," because it seems as if the poet is addressing the king as "god," which is theologically problematic (since after all God can't have sexy women, right?) . Alternate translations include "your divine throne endures for ever and ever" and "the eternal and everlasting God has enthroned you." [8] These alternate translations may be an attempt to erase any evidence that Yahweh had His own harem.

Anat, a West Semitic goddess of love and war [9], might also be a candidate for one of Yahweh's (presumably many) wives. Judges 5:6 mentions her, and Joseph's wife's name is told to be Asenath (holy to Anath) in Genesis 41:45.

See also

Notes

References

Template:Biblebox


Yahweh is an Anglicized version of the Name of God, as spoken during the time of the Temple and understood by Judaism and Christianity as taught in the Old Testament or the Bible. In Hebrew, The Name is written using four consonants called the tetragrammaton, but never spoken.

Yahweh
Hebrew name
Hebrew יַהְוֶה
Romanization Yahweh

However, because Jews generally were forbidden by the Third Commandment to pronounce the sacred name, the vowels of Adonai (literally 'my lords') were normally inserted between its consonants, resulting in the name 'Jehovah'. Reflecting the same taboo, the earlier English translations of the Bible replaced the name with the phrase 'the LORD'. Because Jesus' followers routinely called him adon ('boss', 'lord', which translated into the gospels' Greek as kurios), the two titles became confused in English, to the point where it became unclear whether the phrase 'the LORD' was referring to Jesus or to Yahweh.

In the 19th century, German scholar Wilhelm Gesenius suggested that the tetragrammaton (יְהֹוָה) be vowelized as יַהְוֶה, corresponding to the romanization "Yahweh."

Sources

  • Armstrong, K., The Battle for God (Harper Perennial, 2000)
  • Burrows, M., The Dead Sea Scrolls (Secker & Warburg, 1956)
  • Cruden, A., Complete Concordance to the Old and New Testaments (Lutterworth, 1930)
  • Cross, C., Who Was Jesus? (Hodder & Stoughton, 1970)
  • Finkelstein, I. and Silberman, N. A, The Bible Unearthed (The Free Press/Simon & Schuster, 2001)
  • The Holy Bible (King James Version)
  • James, M. R., The Apocryphal New Testament (Clarendon, Oxford, 1953)
  • The New English Bible (Oxford & Cambridge University Presses, 1970)
  • The New Jerusalem Bible (Darton, Longman & Todd, 1990)
  • Lemesurier, P., The Armageddon Script (Element Books, 1981)
  • Peake, A.S., Commentary on the Bible (Nelson, 1962)
  • Powell Davies, A., The Meaning of the Dead Sea Scrolls (Mentor Books, New York, 1956)
  • Schonfield, H. J., The Passover Plot (Hutchinson, 1965)
  • Schonfield, H. J., The Pentecost Revolution (Macdonald, 1974)
  • Schonfield, H.J., Those Incredible Christians (Bernard Geis, New York, 1968)
  • Vermes, G., The Dead Sea Scrolls in English (Penguin, 1968)
  • Vermes, G., The Dead Sea Scrolls: Qumran in Perspective (Collins, 1977)
  • Vermes, G., Jesus the Jew (Collins, 1973)
  • Young, R., Analytical Concordance to the Holy Bible (Lutterworth, 1939)


Cite error: <ref> tags exist for a group named "note", but no corresponding <references group="note"/> tag was found, or a closing </ref> is missing