Difference between revisions of "User:PeterKa"

From Conservapedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(My time at Wikipedia)
(format)
 
(149 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
My pages:
+
{{Userbox
 +
|border-c=#000
 +
|border-s=1
 +
|id-c=#fff
 +
|id-s=
 +
|id-fc=
 +
|info-c=#99CCCC
 +
|info-s=13
 +
|info-fc=#000
 +
|id=[[File:Icon-team.jpg|80px]]
 +
|info=<center>'''This user is part of the [[Conservapedia:CP Civility Association|CP Civility Association]].'''</center>
 +
}}<noinclude>
 +
{{Clear}}
  
−
* Read my [[User:PeterKa/Filipacchi | parody of Wikipedia's gender categories affair]]
+
Here are my ''American Thinker'' articles: https://www.americanthinker.com/author/peterkauffner/
−
* [[User:PeterKa/Arbcom | My Arbcom appeal]] has a blow-by-blow account of what happened during my time on Wikipedia.
 
−
* [[Diacritic]] — This is a zippy overview of the most controversial aspect of my editing.
 
−
* [[User:PeterKa/Diacritics_proposal |Diacritics proposal]] — You can find a detailed set of arguments here.
 
  
−
==My time at Wikipedia==
+
==Back from Hong Kong==
−
Back in 2012, I was a senior editor on Wikipedia and could boast tens of thousands of edits as well as a clean eight-year track record. I was especially active in a forum called “requested moves.” One day, an editor I will refer to as “IIO” got jealous of my unofficial status as an “RM expert” and started harassing me. Day after day, he complained about me in one forum after another. After a year of this, some admins summarily imposed a series of blocks.  Admins can block as they like, a power they need to deal with spammers and trolls. But unlike me, most editors who have been around for a while generally get some degree of due process and procedural protection, including second chances, topic bans, and interaction bans.
+
I'm back from Hong Kong and it was certainly quite a week to be there (Oct. 1-7). Hong Kong was once a British colony, but it has been ruled by China since 1997. The city has a unique "one country, two systems" form of government that allows a British-style legal system to flourish despite the fact that the local government now works for the Chinese Communist Party. There have been pro-democracy protests in the city since an extradition bill was proposed four months ago. The protests mushroomed after Carrie Lam, the city's hapless chief executive, issued a decree banning masks on Oct. 5. Vandalism was so intense that the entire subway system had to closed for the first time in its history. Not only that, but the city's High Court is likely to overturn the decree.<br/>As if protests and tear gas weren't enough, Hong Kong faces another serious problem: The city is experiencing one of the largest housing bubbles in economic history. Rising land values make the rich richer and leaves young couples unable to afford homes of their own. Everyone wants a piece of the action, including Chinese President Xi Jinping. Xi has a villa in Hong Kong at Repulse Bay. When I talked to the protesters, I suggested that they take a look at that.
−
 
+
<gallery>
−
The original block arose from a dispute as to whether the city of Can Tho should be spelled with diacritics, as the Vietnamese spell it, or without, as English-language reference works give it. When IIO is not picking a fight with me, he focuses on music and art articles, not Vietnam. The Can Tho issue was something that happened nine months earlier and didn’t involve him.
+
File:Dim sum.jpg|Dim sum is what Hong Kongers eat for breakfast.
−
 
+
File:Cookies from Jenny Bakery.jpg|Jenny Bakery in Mirador Mansion makes the city's favorite cookies.
−
Why diacritics? For whatever reason, Arbcom was cracking down on editors with dissent views on diacritics at this time. Wikipedia guidelines instruct editors to follow “[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Naming_conventions_%28use_English%29#Modified_letters the general usage]” on this question. I interpret this to mean that we should follow the Chicago Manual, Merriam-Webster, or some other widely used reference of this type. IIO argues that my approach discriminates against Vietnamese, as if this was a civil rights issue. (Before anyone takes this argument seriously, I should note that English-language websites run by the Vietnamese government also remove the diacritics.) A good style is one that goes unnoticed so that a reader can focus on content. Few English-language speakers are familiar with Vietnamese diacritics, so they stand out in running text. If the overarching thought the reader goes away with is “Gee, those Vietnamese use a lot of interesting marks,” that’s a failure of communication.
+
File:Hong Kong Ferry.jpeg|You get a magnificent view of the harbor aboard the white and green Hong Kong ferry.
−
 
+
File:Pro-democracy march in Wanchai, Hong Kong.jpeg|I stand in front of a pro-democracy march in Wanchai District, site of some of the most serious rioting. Masks provide protection against tear gas.
−
My case was discussed in ANI several times. Each time, the “consensus,” as it is called, was not to sanction me. At the time, I thought I’d won the battle. But it turned out that the only reason anyone respected these decisions is because there was an admin who was protecting me at that time. Once he took a break from editing, the consensus-making process was about as useful as last year’s J. Crew catalogue. In the harassment offensive that followed, many more editors became involved, few of whom were familiar with Vietnam-related issues. The offensive started with an attack on article I wrote on the [[Roman Warm Period]]. This time it featured crude insults and name calling. It continued with an attack on [[User:PeterKa/Filipacchi|my user page]] and an article I wrote on [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Han-Nom&oldid=563875554 Sino-Vietnamese characters]. None of that succeeded in provoking me into doing anything they could block me for. But Wikipedia has hundreds of admins, so a persistent editor can often find one who will do what he wants, a practice referred to as “forumshopping.” In the end, Team Harassment used a transparently bogus claim that I was edit warring as a pretext to block me.
+
File:V-Barracade across Nathan Road in Mongkok.jpg|This barricade was built in Mongkok District on Oct. 5. Although defended by a catapult, the police had little trouble removing it.
−
 
+
File:Poster on why attack subway.jpg|This bilingual poster looks at the fraught relationship between the protesters and Mass Transit Railway, the city's subway provider. The Hong Kong language, which you can see on the left, is not intelligible to mainland Chinese.  
−
Sue Gardner, executive director at the time, was intent on moving Wikipedia to the left. Perhaps this is why various political issues came up. As far as IIO and the rest of Team Harassment were concerned, the fact that I had narrowly escaped sanction earlier was reason enough to try again. Since Gardner left Wikipedia, other editors caught up in the great diacritics purge have returned. Compared to people who were more easily provoked, I was a lot more trouble to block and ban. Reinstating me at this point would require too many admins to backtrack.
+
File:Glass broken in Hong Kong protests.jpeg|The subway system has been overwhelmed by vandalism. This pane is at Mei Foo Station.
−
 
+
File:China_Liaison_Office,_Hong_Kong.jpeg|The "local government" headed by Carrie Lam is a front. This tower in Sai Ying Pun is the city's real center of power. It is the "secret" headquarters of the Communist Party.
−
People who should know have told me that Arbcom started manipulating my case behind the scenes well before I was banned. That would certainly help explain why so many editors became interested in my case at that time. If so, Arbcom effectively overrode the various ANI discussions that had gone in my favor. Arbcom is set up as a quasi judicial body, so it is irregular for the group to act in a case that was not appealed.
+
</gallery>
  
 
==What I have written==
 
==What I have written==
−
*[[Nazarene]]‎, [[J. Frank Norris]], [[Peter Ruckman]], [[Textus Receptus]], [[sensus plenior]], [[divine accommodation]], [[Yule]], [[Johannine Comma]], [[Codex Washingtonianus]], [[Star of Bethlehem]], [[Fundamentalism]], [[Andy McIntosh]]
+
*[[Nazarene]]‎, [[J. Frank Norris]], [[Peter Ruckman]], [[Textus Receptus]], [[sensus plenior]], [[divine accommodation]], [[Yule]], [[Johannine Comma]], [[Codex Washingtonianus]], [[Star of Bethlehem]], [[Fundamentalism]], [[Tertiary]], [[Andy McIntosh]], [[Akhenaten]], [[Tutankhamun]], [[Nefertiti]]
  
−
*[[Republicans (Jeffersonian)]],  [[Classical Chinese]], [[Empress Dowager Cixi]], [[diacritic]], [[Mandarin]], [[Nuclear option]], [[Star_Trek_franchise#Political_themes]], [[Tang Tuyet Minh]], [[Roman Warm Period]], [[No Gun Ri]], [[Vietcong]], [[Republic of China]], [[rule of law]], [[YAD06]], [[Girls' Generation]], [[Xia dynasty]], [[Shang dynasty]], [[rule of law]]
+
*[[Republicans (Jeffersonian)]],  [[Classical Chinese]], [[Empress Dowager Cixi]], [[diacritic]], [[Mandarin]], [[Nuclear option]], [[Star_Trek_franchise#Political_themes]], [[Tang Tuyet Minh]], [[Roman Warm Period]], [[No Gun Ri]], [[Vietcong]], [[Republic of China]], [[rule of law]], [[YAD06]], [[Girls' Generation]], [[Xia dynasty]], [[Shang dynasty]]

Latest revision as of 06:42, November 7, 2023

Icon-team.jpg
This user is part of the CP Civility Association.

Here are my American Thinker articles: https://www.americanthinker.com/author/peterkauffner/

Back from Hong Kong

I'm back from Hong Kong and it was certainly quite a week to be there (Oct. 1-7). Hong Kong was once a British colony, but it has been ruled by China since 1997. The city has a unique "one country, two systems" form of government that allows a British-style legal system to flourish despite the fact that the local government now works for the Chinese Communist Party. There have been pro-democracy protests in the city since an extradition bill was proposed four months ago. The protests mushroomed after Carrie Lam, the city's hapless chief executive, issued a decree banning masks on Oct. 5. Vandalism was so intense that the entire subway system had to closed for the first time in its history. Not only that, but the city's High Court is likely to overturn the decree.
As if protests and tear gas weren't enough, Hong Kong faces another serious problem: The city is experiencing one of the largest housing bubbles in economic history. Rising land values make the rich richer and leaves young couples unable to afford homes of their own. Everyone wants a piece of the action, including Chinese President Xi Jinping. Xi has a villa in Hong Kong at Repulse Bay. When I talked to the protesters, I suggested that they take a look at that.

  • Dim sum is what Hong Kongers eat for breakfast.

  • Jenny Bakery in Mirador Mansion makes the city's favorite cookies.

  • You get a magnificent view of the harbor aboard the white and green Hong Kong ferry.

  • I stand in front of a pro-democracy march in Wanchai District, site of some of the most serious rioting. Masks provide protection against tear gas.

  • This barricade was built in Mongkok District on Oct. 5. Although defended by a catapult, the police had little trouble removing it.

  • This bilingual poster looks at the fraught relationship between the protesters and Mass Transit Railway, the city's subway provider. The Hong Kong language, which you can see on the left, is not intelligible to mainland Chinese.

  • The subway system has been overwhelmed by vandalism. This pane is at Mei Foo Station.

  • The "local government" headed by Carrie Lam is a front. This tower in Sai Ying Pun is the city's real center of power. It is the "secret" headquarters of the Communist Party.

What I have written

Retrieved from "https://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=User:PeterKa&oldid=2001759"